<abstract xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"><p>Three cases of violation of forest management regulations in Estonia in 2004, 2005 and 2007 are presented in the study where the required lower limit of basal area after thinnings was not followed. These stands were revisited in 2017 to assess the impacts of such thinnings. The actual thinnings were well justified from the silvicultural and economic viewpoints. All three stands were ecologically in good condition in 2017. Also, all three stands had already reached the required age or dimensions allowing regeneration cutting in 2017. Forest management regulations on thinning did not work well in the studied cases and therefore some changes in the current regulations are necessary in Estonia.</p></abstract>

Three cases of violation of forest management regulations in Estonia in 2004, 2005 and 2007 are presented in the study where the required lower limit of basal area after thinnings was not followed. These stands were revisited in 2017 to assess the impacts of such thinnings. The actual thinnings were well justified from the silvicultural and economic viewpoints. All three stands were ecologically in good condition in 2017. Also, all three stands had already reached the required age or dimensions allowing regeneration cutting in 2017. Forest management regulations on thinning did not work well in the studied cases and therefore some changes in the current regulations are necessary in Estonia.

Revisiting the actual cases of violations of forest management regulations on thinning

Forestry Studies

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Harvendusraietel toimunud metsaõigusnormide rikkumise juhtumite hindamine

Three cases of violation of forest management regulations in Estonia in 2004, 2005 and 2007 are presented in the study where the required lower limit of basal...

Juhtum	Aasta	Puuliik	Rinne	Diameeter (cm)	Kõrgus (m)	Vanus (a)	Tagavara (m³ ha⁻¹)	Tihedus (tk ha⁻¹)
1	2005	KS	1	24	25	55	206
		MA	1	22	24	60	15
		KU	2	16	17	40	86

	2017	KS	1	26	26	67	225
		MA	1	24	26	72	44
		KU	2	22	20	52	155

2	2004	MA	1	22	22	68	261

	2017	MA	1	28	23	81	160
		MA	J	1	2	10		7000
		KS	J	2	4	10		1000
		HB	J	2	4	10		1000

3	2007	MA	1	22	19	90	235

	2017	MA	1	26	22	100	196
	2017	MA	J	1	2	6		5000

Juhtum	Asukoht	Pindala ha	Boniteet	Kasvukohatüüp
1	Võrumaa, Antsla vald	0,7	1A	Jänesekapsa
2	Võrumaa, Setomaa vald	1,9	2	Pohla
3	Võrumaa, Setomaa vald	3,6	3	Pohla

Nr	Kirjeldus	Juhtum 1	Juhtum 2	Juhtum 3
1. Reaalne juhtum, kus metsaomanik tegi harvendusraie.
	Eraldisel kasvava metsa rahaline väärtus 2017. a, eurodes	9 692	15 052	33 810
	Eraldisel tehtud harvendusraiega saadud netotulu, eurodes	761	7 077	11 742
	Metsa varasema uuendamisega seoses saadav lisatulu tulevikus, eurodes	0	3 566	3 791
	Metsa ja tegevuste koguväärtus kokku, eurodes	10 453	25 695	49 343
2. Juhul, kui metsaomanik oleks jätnud harvendusraie tegemata.
	Eraldisel kasvava metsa rahaline väärtus kokku 2017. a, eurodes	8 280	24 687	37 905

Revisiting the actual cases of violations of forest management regulations on thinning

Article Category: Short communication

Data publikacji: 11 mar 2021

Zakres stron: 145 - 151

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/fsmu-2020-0021

Słowa kluczowe
thinning regulation, minimum basal area, forestry legislation

© 2020 Henn Korjus et al., published by Sciendo

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Uuritud juhtumites puistute takseerandmed metsamajandamiskavade andmetel enne harvendusraiet ja välitööde andmetel 2017. a.

Uuritud harvendusraie juhtumites olevate puistute üldandmed.

Uuritud juhtumites kasvava metsa väärtuse ja metsamajanduslike tegevuste rahaline hinnang nii harvendusraie tegemisel kui ka tegemata jätmisel.

Revisiting the actual cases of violations of forest management regulations on thinning

Article Category: Short communication

Data publikacji: 11 mar 2021

Zakres stron: 145 - 151

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/fsmu-2020-0021

Słowa kluczowethinning regulation, minimum basal area, forestry legislation

© 2020 Henn Korjus et al., published by Sciendo

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Uuritud juhtumites puistute takseerandmed metsamajandamiskavade andmetel enne harvendusraiet ja välitööde andmetel 2017. a.

Uuritud harvendusraie juhtumites olevate puistute üldandmed.

Uuritud juhtumites kasvava metsa väärtuse ja metsamajanduslike tegevuste rahaline hinnang nii harvendusraie tegemisel kui ka tegemata jätmisel.

Słowa kluczowe
thinning regulation, minimum basal area, forestry legislation