Open Access

Remote consultations in general practice – A systematic review


Cite

Figure 1

Flow diagram of the literature search and study selection.
Flow diagram of the literature search and study selection.

General characteristics of the included studies.

Study Year of publication Country Study design Study topic Sample size Participants Duration Type of service Main outcomes Limitation Covid-19 related
Banks 2017 (15) UK Qualitative interview study Usage of electronic consultation system 23 GPs GPs and other health workers 15 months in 2016 • E-consultations (by mail) • Physical consultati The technology did not justify the financial investment. Evaluation of only one e-system No
Atheron 2017 (16) UK Case study What are the alternatives to physical consultation? 45 staff members in GPs’ office other health workers and patients 10 months in 2015 and 2016 • Telephone calls • Video calls • Mail Implementing alternatives to physical consultation should be moderate and gradual. One specific ethnic group was included No
Newbould 2018 (17) UK Qualitative study To identify enablers and barriers to adopting a telephone first approach Semi- structured interview 53 GPs GPs 6 months in 2018 • Telephone first approach Approach is an improvement of previous system. Only included staff who believe in this approach No
Randhawa 2018 (18) UK Qualitative pilot study Views of GPs on video consultations Semi- structured interview 12 GPs GPs 1 month in 2014 • Video consultations Video consultations can be useful, practical. Success of service depends on availability and quality of technology No
Cowie 2018 (19) UK A multi- methods study Evaluation of digital consultations 11 GPs GPs 4 months in 2017 • eConsult (web-based triage and consultation system) GPs had high satisfaction, improves quality of care. Short time, low number of participants No
Zanaboni 2020 (20) Norway Online survey Use and experience with e-consultation 2,043 patients patients 14 days in 2017 • E-consultations (by mail) One of the first countries that implemented e-consultation, it improves the quality of care. Online survey was used by patients who have computer knowledge, not applicable for the whole population No
López Seguí 2020 (21) Spain Retro- spective cross-sectional study Can teleconsultations reduce the number of visits? 3,559 messages for 2,268 teleconsultations GPs 4 months in 2018 • eConsulta (by mail) Teleconsultations can reduce the number of visits. No systemized approach, only a few GP were included No
Sharma 2020 (22) UK Cross- sectional study Satisfaction of patients with remote consultations 95 GPs GPs and other health workers 1 month in 2020 • Telephone calls • Video calls • Mail • Physical consultation The implementation of remote consultation requires good financial support for the IT infrastructure. Small sample Yes
Morreel 2020 (23) Belgium Real-time observational study Organizations and characteristics of primary care 21 GPs 15,655 consultations GPs 5 weekends in 2019 • Home visits • Telephone- • Physical consultation GPs changed their way of working rapidly, almost immediately. Safety problems Yes
Murphy 2021 (24) UK A mix- methods longitudinal study Impact of rapid implementation of remote consultations in pandemic of Covid-19 87 GPs GPs and other health workers 4 months in 2020 compared to 2019 • Telephone calls • Video calls • Mail Remote consultation is necessary. Patients were not interviewed Yes
Andreson 2021 (25) UK Satisfaction measurement using a four-step questionnaire Satisfaction of patients with remote consultations 104 patients patients 3 separate days in 2021 • Telephone calls • Video calls Remote consultations are effective complement to physical consultation. Online survey was used by patients who have computer knowledge, not applicable for the whole population No
Mathew 2021 (26) Australia Online survey What kind of telehealth tool is the most acceptable for patients? 154 patients patients 2 months in 2020 • Telephone calls • Video calls The perception of telephone consultation is strongly positive. Study performed on a local level No

Search strategy for each database.

Database Search Strategy Result all (free)
PubMed “Remote Consultation”[Mesh] AND (“General Practitioners”[Mesh] OR “Family Medicine” [Mesh] OR “Primary care” [Mesh]) 42 (23)
Scopus TITLE-ABS-KEY “Remote Consultation” AND (“General Practitioners” OR “Family Medicine” OR “Primary care”) 611 (431)
Web of Science TS=(remote consultation)) AND TS=(general practice) 73 (47)
IEEE library (“All Metadata”:“Remote Consultation))”) AND (“All Metadata”: “General Practice ” OR “Family Medicine” OR “Primary care”)) 2 (0)
eISSN:
1854-2476
Language:
English
Publication timeframe:
4 times per year
Journal Subjects:
Medicine, Clinical Medicine, Hygiene and Environmental Medicine