Global Collaboration in Artificial Intelligence: Bibliometrics and Network Analysis from 1985 to 2019

Haotian Hu; Dongbo Wang; Sanhong Deng

Otwarty dostęp

Global Collaboration in Artificial Intelligence: Bibliometrics and Network Analysis from 1985 to 2019

Haotian Hu

Dongbo Wang

oraz

Sanhong Deng

| 07 wrz 2020

Journal of Data and Information Science

Tom 5 (2020): Zeszyt 4 (November 2020)

O artykule

Poprzedni artykuł

Następny artykuł

Zacytuj

Udostępnij

Article Category: Research Paper

Data publikacji: 07 wrz 2020

Zakres stron: 86 - 115

Otrzymano: 31 sty 2020

Przyjęty: 11 cze 2020

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/jdis-2020-0027

Słowa kluczowe
Artificial intelligence, International collaboration, Collaboration pattern, Bibliometric analysis, Social network analysis

© 2020 Haotian Hu et al., published by Sciendo

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Comparison of the number of articles and proceedings papers 1985–2019.

Extraction process for country and institution information.

The temporal trend lines of collaboration at the author level in artificial intelligence field.

The temporal trend lines of collaborat ion at the country/region level in artificial intelligence field.

The temporal trend lines of collaboration at the institutional level in artificial intelligence.

The country collaboration network in the global artificial intelligence field between 1985 and 2019.

Complete institutional collaboration network in the global artificial intelligence field between 1985 and 2019.

The biggest sub-network of the international-institution collaboration network (BSIN) in the global field of artificial intelligence between 1985 and 2019.

Country distribution of institutions in the BSIN.

Institutions with high BC in the biggest sub-network of international-institution collaboration network.

Rank	Institution	Country	BC	Degree
1	Chinese Academy of Sciences	China	0.405336672	4
2	Ton Duc Thang University	Vietnam	0.384635685	18
3	Georgia Institute of Technology	USA	0.371527778	3
4	University of Alberta	Canada	0.350694444	4
5	University of Kurdistan	Iran	0.295375309	14
6	Islamic Azad University	Iran	0.288076771	11
7	Duy Tan University	Vietnam	0.223353933	13
8	MIT	USA	0.203373016	4
9	University of Tabriz	Iran	0.153155313	7
10	Oxford	UK	0.12202381	5
11	University of Technology Malaysia	Malaysia	0.095804022	5
12	Penn State University	USA	0.091765873	3
13	University of Tehran	Iran	0.039564365	3
14	University of Technology Sydney	Australia	0.036280213	5
15	Near East University	Turkey	0.033982326	3
16	Sejong University	South Korea	0.032871873	5
17	University of Malaya	Malaysia	0.031909121	3
18	GTEV ReX Ltd	UK	0.03125	2
19	University of Toronto	Canada	0.03125	2
20	Hong Kong Polytechnic University	China	0.03125	3
21	National University of Singapore	Singapore	0.030505952	4
22	Johns Hopkins University	USA	0.030505952	4
23	University of Southern Queensland	Australia	0.028754488	4
24	University of Salamanca	Spain	0.015376984	3
25	Osaka Institute of Technology	Japan	0.015376984	3
26	Korea Institute of Geoscience & Mineral Resources KIGAM	South Korea	0.006101012	4
27	Korea University of Science & Technology	South Korea	0.005030213	3
28	University of South Eastern Norway	Norway	0.005030213	2
29	University College of Southeast Norway	Norway	0.003571429	2
30	UTM	Malaysia	0.003515133	4
31	Xi’an University of Science & Technology	China	0.001070799	3
32	Nanjing Normal University	China	0.001070799	2
33	Hanoi University	Vietnam	0.000907137	2
34	Obuda University	Hungary	0.000496032	3

Countries and regions with a high percentage of collaboration in the global field of AI between 1985 and 2019.

Rank	Country/region	Total papers	Collaborative papers	Percentage of collaborative papers
1	Vietnam	189	170	89.95%
2	Saudi Arabia	344	277	80.52%
3	U Arab Emirates	128	99	77.34%
4	Pakistan	301	229	76.08%
5	Sweden	332	251	75.60%
6	Switzerland	365	266	72.88%
7	Denmark	173	126	72.83%
8	Netherlands	578	402	69.55%
9	Tunisia	158	109	68.99%
10	Iran	1,279	880	68.80%
11	Slovenia	156	107	68.59%
12	Malaysia	737	499	67.71%
13	Portugal	461	310	67.25%
14	Belgium	310	206	66.45%
15	France	1,444	954	66.07%
16	Egypt	262	173	66.03%
17	Australia	1,180	773	65.51%
18	New Zealand	152	99	65.13%
19	Singapore	455	289	63.52%
20	Colombia	133	84	63.16%
21	Serbia	160	101	63.13%
22	Finland	234	146	62.39%
23	Israel	218	136	62.39%
24	Spain	1,960	1,218	62.14%
25	Italy	1,377	855	62.09%
26	Turkey	909	561	61.72%
27	Mexico	459	283	61.66%
28	Norway	191	117	61.26%
29	UK	3,070	1,863	60.68%
30	Canada	1,463	877	59.95%
31	Taiwan	888	532	59.91%
32	South Korea	869	516	59.38%
33	Brazil	1,077	638	59.24%
34	Greece	500	291	58.20%
35	Germany	1,538	892	58.00%
36	Austria	337	193	57.27%
37	USA	7,763	4,436	57.14%
38	Japan	1,239	697	56.26%
39	China	6,444	3,596	55.80%
40	Ireland	206	114	55.34%
41	Algeria	204	111	54.41%
42	Thailand	151	80	52.98%
43	Indonesia	180	95	52.78%
44	India	2,080	1,092	52.50%
45	South Africa	205	105	51.22%
46	Hungary	159	81	50.94%
47	Russia	540	267	49.44%
48	Czech Republic	379	164	43.27%
49	Slovakia	143	61	42.66%
50	Romania	627	263	41.95%
51	Poland	866	360	41.57%

Countries/regions with high BC in the collaborative network.

Rank	Country/region	BC	Degree
1	US	0.194044287	59
2	Spain	0.121497557	45
3	France	0.09336937	47
4	UK	0.08893566	53
5	Malaysia	0.066529876	26
6	Italy	0.049736817	39
7	Slovenia	0.046246703	17
8	China	0.044717068	45
9	Germany	0.044155013	41
10	Australia	0.041308894	37
11	Serbia	0.025974026	3
12	Canada	0.025611038	37
13	Iran	0.022606583	28
14	Poland	0.019977656	23
15	Netherlands	0.017546622	33
16	Saudi Arabia	0.014945119	19
17	Russia	0.013316129	20
18	Vietnam	0.01329915	22
19	Portugal	0.013039462	27
20	India	0.011128811	32

Top 20 AI publications and their paper amounts between 1985 and 2019.

Rank	Journals	Papers	Percent (%)
1	EXPERT SYSTEMS WITH APPLICATIONS	461	1.206%
2	IEEE ACCESS	290	0.759%
3	AI MAGAZINE	233	0.610%
4	ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE	220	0.576%
5	APPLIED SOFT COMPUTING	192	0.502%
6	ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE	191	0.500%
7	SENSORS	152	0.398%
8	NEUROCOMPUTING	139	0.364%
9	ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE REVIEW	122	0.319%
10	NEURAL COMPUTING & APPLICATIONS	122	0.319%
11	JOURNAL OF INTELLIGENT & FUZZY SYSTEMS	114	0.298%
12	MINDS AND MACHINES	111	0.290%
13	INFORMATION SCIENCES	105	0.275%
14	KNOWLEDGE-BASED SYSTEMS	104	0.272%
15	ENERGIES	103	0.269%
16	ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN MEDICINE	99	0.259%
17	APPLIED ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE	96	0.251%
18	EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH	96	0.251%
19	AGRO FOOD INDUSTRY HI-TECH	94	0.246%
20	KYBERNETES	93	0.243%

eISSN:: 2543-683X
Język:: Angielski

Częstotliwość wydawania:: 4 razy w roku
Dziedziny czasopisma:: Computer Sciences, Information Technology, Project Management, Databases and Data Mining

Kanał RSS czasopisma

Global Collaboration in Artificial Intelligence: Bibliometrics and Network Analysis from 1985 to 2019

Article Category: Research Paper

Data publikacji: 07 wrz 2020

Zakres stron: 86 - 115

Otrzymano: 31 sty 2020

Przyjęty: 11 cze 2020

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/jdis-2020-0027

Słowa kluczowe
Artificial intelligence, International collaboration, Collaboration pattern, Bibliometric analysis, Social network analysis

© 2020 Haotian Hu et al., published by Sciendo

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Figure 1

Figure 2

Figure 3

Figure 4

Figure 5

Figure 6

Figure 7

Figure 8

Figure 9

Institutions with high BC in the biggest sub-network of international-institution collaboration network.

Countries and regions with a high percentage of collaboration in the global field of AI between 1985 and 2019.

Countries/regions with high BC in the collaborative network.

Top 20 AI publications and their paper amounts between 1985 and 2019.

Global Collaboration in Artificial Intelligence: Bibliometrics and Network Analysis from 1985 to 2019

Article Category: Research Paper

Data publikacji: 07 wrz 2020

Zakres stron: 86 - 115

Otrzymano: 31 sty 2020

Przyjęty: 11 cze 2020

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/jdis-2020-0027

Słowa kluczoweArtificial intelligence, International collaboration, Collaboration pattern, Bibliometric analysis, Social network analysis

© 2020 Haotian Hu et al., published by Sciendo

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Figure 1

Figure 2

Figure 3

Figure 4

Figure 5

Figure 6

Figure 7

Figure 8

Figure 9

Institutions with high BC in the biggest sub-network of international-institution collaboration network.

Countries and regions with a high percentage of collaboration in the global field of AI between 1985 and 2019.

Countries/regions with high BC in the collaborative network.

Top 20 AI publications and their paper amounts between 1985 and 2019.

Słowa kluczowe
Artificial intelligence, International collaboration, Collaboration pattern, Bibliometric analysis, Social network analysis