The coastal zone of the Baltic Sea, relatively small and shallow with limited water exchange, is very sensitive to human impact. Due to hydrological regime, cultural eutrophication is one of the most urgent problems of water quality in the Gulf of Gdańsk and the Vistula Lagoon.
Human impact on environmental conditions has increased considerably since the Middle Ages (Starkel 2001). The development of agriculture has resulted in deforestation and a significant reduction in grazing land. Transport of eroded sediments of the river delta surface shows a significant increase due to the development of Vistula River branches. The Nogat, in the past a separate river, merged with the Vistula in the 13th and 14th centuries. The first attempt to regulate the river flow was undertaken after the big flood in 1829. The regulation was completed after the next tragic flood in 1888. An artificial mouth of the Vistula was created near Świbno. Since 1895, the Szkarpawa and the Dead Vistula (in Polish: Martwa Wisła) have been cut off from the main river course, which flows directly into the Gulf of Gdańsk (Makowski 1995). A new hydrological system was completed in 1915, when the Nogat was isolated by the construction of a dam. Urbanization, progressive industrialization and an increase in the wastewater inflow have had a strong environmental impact over the last 200 years, reflected i.a. in clear changes in the hydrological regime. Transport of large amounts of nutrients, organic matter and pollutants by the rivers has resulted in environmental degradation of the Gulf of Gdańsk and its progressive eutrophication in particular (Pliński 1991). The Gulf of Gdańsk and the Vistula Lagoon are considered one of the most polluted regions of the whole Baltic Sea. In the former basin, the content of nitrates increased five times, whereas the content of phosphorus – two times. The eutrophication process causes an increase in biological production, which leads to increased fishery yields. However, many negative effects have also been observed, e.g. increased deposition of organic matter, reduced water transparency and vertical extent of the photic zones, and oxygen deficiency including the occurrence of hypoxia and anoxia periods (e.g. Łysiak-Pastuszak et al. 2004).
Eutrophication has resulted in structural changes in plant and animal communities, and a general decline in biodiversity (Howarth et al. 2000). A decrease in plankton diversity in the Gulf of Gdańsk has been widely discussed (e.g. Witkowski & Pempkowiak 1995; Niemkiewicz & Wrzołek 1998; Leśniewska & Witak 2008; 2011). The so-called “anthropogenic assemblages” with pollution-resistant taxa, i.e.
The objective of this study was (1) to differentiate the diatom assemblage zones based on floristic spectra and ecological groupings in subbottom sediments of the SW Gulf of Gdańsk and the Vistula Lagoon, (2) to compare the distinguished zones with respect to habitat and salinity preferences of the main species, including autochthonous and allochthonous forms and (3) to perform spatial analysis of cultural eutrophication effects on subfossil diatom flora of both basins with an emphasis on the role of inflows of riverine waters.
The Gulf of Gdańsk is formally separated from the rest of the Baltic Sea by a line connecting Cape Rozewie in Poland on the western side and Cape Taran in Lithuania on the eastern side (Fig. 1). It constitutes the southern part of the Gdańsk Basin (Majewski 1990). The gulf is part of an elongated trough with a varied bed dip. The shallows occur in its western and eastern parts, as well as in the neighborhood of the Vistula River mouth. In the west, the Hel Peninsula, which is a natural sand barrier, separates the inner part of the Gulf of Gdańsk, i.e. Puck Bay (Majewski 1990). The average depth of the western part of Puck Bay, called the Puck Lagoon, is ca. 3.13 m, while the mean depth of the Outer Puck Bay having a wide connection with the open waters of the Gulf of Gdańsk was estimated at 20.5 m. The Vistula Lagoon, a relatively narrow and long basin, is separated from the Baltic Sea by a natural sand barrier – the Vistula Spit (Łomniewski 1958). At present, only a narrow strait near the Russian port of Baltiysk enables the exchange of water with the Gulf of Gdańsk. It is a very shallow water body with an average depth of 2.7 m and a maximum depth of 5.2 m. However, its south-western part, known as the Elbląg Lagoon, with an average depth of 2.4 m, is shallower than the rest of the lagoon (Wypych 1975).
The hydrological regime in both basins is associated with the depth, climatic conditions and the inflow of saline waters from the open Baltic Sea. The freshwater discharge from the surrounding coastal areas is another important factor affecting the hydrology of the study area. The Vistula Lagoon is strongly controlled by riverine waters of the Nogat, the Pregola, the Bauda, the Narusa, the Pasłęka, the Mamonovka etc. The hydrological regime in the deeper part of the Gulf of Gdańsk is controlled by the strong runoff from the Vistula mouth. The impact of other rivers, e.g. the Kacza, the Oliwski Stream that discharge into the Outer Puck Bay, is limited to the proximity of their estuaries (Majewski 1972). The E, ENE and ESE winds cause the Vistula runoff to incline westward (Kravtsov et al. 2002). The prevailing winds blowing from W, WNW and WSW deflect riverine waters, which spread toward the east. Winds from the SW, S and SE directions markedly increase the distance of spreading the Vistula waters, whereas those from the N, NW and NE limit the spread to the vicinity of the mouth.
Seasonal stratification in the water column occurs in the SW part of the Gulf of Gdańsk. The 50–60 m deep surface layer is the main part of the waters and is characterized by low variation in seasonal salinity and temperature changes (Cyberska 1990). Pycnocline, halocline and thermocline layers are located in the deeper part of the study area, at depths between 60 and 80 m. Bottom waters with constant temperature and salinity are below a depth of 80 m, which is outside the study area. The mixing affects the entire water column of the Vistula Lagoon due to the limited depth, and therefore vertical stratification usually does not occur (Grekov et al. 1975).
Average annual salinity of the surface water in the SW part of the Gulf of Gdańsk oscillates between 7.25 PSU in the vicinity of the Hel Peninsula tip and 7.21 near the port of Gdynia (Nowacki 1993). In the neighborhood of the Vistula mouth, this value decreases to 4.51 PSU (Cyberska 1992). The Vistula Lagoon is much more freshening. Its salinity fluctuates from 1.65 PSU in the Elbląg Lagoon via 2.76 PSU in the central region to 4.72 PSU near the Baltiysk Strait.
The material studied consists of the uppermost parts of 15 sediment cores collected from two different environmental settings (Fig. 1). Parameters and lithology of the analyzed core parts are included in Table 1. Seven cores were retrieved using a vibro corer from the south-western part of the Gulf of Gdańsk, between the region of Gdańsk and Gdynia and the Hel Peninsula. In five of them (2/2001, 3/2001, 4/2001, 6/2001, 7/2001), anthropogenic assemblages were found in subbottom sediments (Table 2). The Vistula Lagoon sediments were collected at 8 sites using an Eijkelkamp corer. Boreholes ZW 8 and ZW 12 were made near the Vistula Spit, cores ZW 4, ZW 11 and ZW 15 were retrieved from the central part of the lagoon. Additionally, cores ZW 1, ZW 10 and ZW 14 originate from the southern part of the basin. Anthropogenic flora was recorded in all samples collected from the Vistula Lagoon. The whole material used for the diatom analysis was provided by the Polish Geological Institute, the Branch of Marine Geology, Gdańsk.
Parameters of the analyzed cores
Region
Core Nb
φ
λ
Water depth [m]
Lithology
Gulf of Gdańsk
2/2001
54°30.658′N
18°42.768′E
30.0
silt, black (N1), at a depth of 8 cm single shells of
3/2001
54°33.640′N
18°44.913′E
54.5
muddy sand, dark-grey (N2), HCl–;
4/2001
54°31.083′N
18°41.349′E
29.8
silt, black (N1), at the top - admixture of sand with grains of gravel; single shells of
6/2001
54°33.282′N
18°47.938′E
62.0
silty mud, black (N1), organic matter, HCl–;
7/2001
54°31.008′N
18°52.569′E
65.0
silty mud, black (N1), organic matter, single shells of marine mollusks above a depth of 20 cm, HCl–;
Vistula Lagoon
ZW 1
54°15.75′N
19°23.416′E
2.1
silty mud, black (N1) and olive-black (5Y 2/1);
ZW 4
54°18.666′N
19°21.583′E
2.7
silty mud, black (N1), HCl–;
ZW 8
54°22.448′N
19°27.536′E
2.2
mud dark yellowish brown (10YR 4/2), HCl–;
ZW 10
54°19.631′N
19°31.280′E
1.8
mud, HCl–;
ZW 11
54°22.1′N
19°43.183′E
3.4
silty mud, green-black, (5GY 2/1) and dark-green (5GY 4/1);
ZW 12
54°25.566′N
19°36.366′E
2.2
silty mud, green-black (5GY 2/1), HCl–;
ZW 14
54°22.333′N
19°40.20′E
2.5
sandy mud, with admixture of fine sands, numerous shells of freshwater mollusks, HCl–;
ZW 15
54°26.40′N
19°43′E
4.3
silty mud, grey-black (N2) and green-black (5G 2/1)
Characteristic features of anthropogenic diatom assemblage zones distinguished in the cores from the Gulf of Gdańsk
Diatom Assemblage Zone
Depth [cm]
Diversity number of taxa/number of genera
State of diatoms
2/2001-III
19–0
116/41
good
3/2001-IV
20–0
106/30
good + some broken valves
4/2001-V
18–0
146/47
good + some broken valves
6/2001-V
25–0
144/45
good + some broken valves
7/2001-IV
20–0
85/31
good
Diatom samples were prepared according to standard methods (Battarbee 1986). The counting method of Schrader and Gersonde (1978) was used and from 500 to 700 valves were counted in each sample to estimate the percentage abundance of particular taxa. The diatoms were divided into planktic and benthic groups (Round 1981). In addition, autochthonous taxa i.e. typical of a given basin (marine and brackish water) and allochthonous (freshwater) taxa i.e. of riverine origin were distinguished in the planktic group. Diatoms were grouped with respect to their salinity requirements according to Kolbe’s (1927) halobian system: euhalobous (salinity > 30 PSU), mesohalobous (5–20 PSU), oligohalobous halophilous (< 5 PSU), and indifferent (0–2 PSU) and halophobous (0 PSU).
The identification and ecological information was obtained from works by Hustedt (1927–1966), Lange-Bertalot & Krammer (1987), Krammer & Lange-Bertalot (1986, 1988, 1991a,b), Pankow (1990), Denys (1991), Vos & de Wolf (1993), Van Dam et al. (1994), Witkowski et al. (2000), Lange-Bertalot (2001).
The percentage content of all ecological groups was calculated in each sample. Diatom assemblage zones (DAZ) were distinguished based on relative abundance of diatom taxa and prevalent ecological groups. All diatom assemblage zones distinguished in the studied material were described in detail by Witak (2010). Brief summary of results on the diatom flora preserved in the sediments of the Gulf of Gdańsk is shown in Table 2, whereas of the Vistula Lagoon in Table 3.
Characteristic features of anthropogenic diatom assemblage zones distinguished in the cores of the Vistula Lagoon
Diatom Assemblage Zone
Depth [cm]
Diversity number of taxa/number of genera
State of diatoms
ZW 1-IV
10–0
58/23
good + some broken valves
ZW 4-IV
30–0
22/11
poor + many broken valves
ZW 8-IV
48–0
59/29
good
ZW 10-IV
30–0
67/30
good
ZW 11-IV
17–0
26/17
poor
ZW 12-IV
52–0
85/29
good + some broken valves
ZW 14-IV
30–0
74/38
good + some broken valves
ZW 15-III
20–0
19/13
poor
Due to hydrological differences between the Gulf of Gdańsk and the Vistula Lagoon, the diatom flora preserved in their superficial sediments is characterized by diverse structure (Fig. 2). General benthic flora dominated in the assemblages from the first basin, particularly in DAZ 3/2001-IV. In the remaining cores, autochthonous plankton occurs frequently, represented mostly by marine and brackish species. Allochthonous plankton with freshwater and riverine diatoms was observed only in DAZ 2/2001-III and 4/2001-V, in the shallower part of the gulf in the region of the Vistula runoff. Abundant benthic diatoms were found in the coastal zone of the Vistula Lagoon, i.e. near the Vistula Spit (DAZ ZW 8-IV and ZW 12-IV) and in the southern part of the basin (DAZ ZW 10-IV and ZW 14-IV). Riverine planktic diatoms dominated in the central part of the lagoon (DAZ ZW 1-IV, ZW 4-IV, ZW 11-IV, ZW 15-III). Brackish water plankton was observed only near Krynica Morska (DAZ ZW 8-IV) and Tolkmicko (DAZ ZW 10-IV). Freshwater taxa occurred frequently in all diatom assemblages of the Vistula Lagoon.
The diatom taphocoenose of DAZ 3/2001-IV was strongly dominated by benthic taxa belonging to different salinity groups (Figs 3, 4, Table 2).
The clear increase in the abundance of planktic species, preferring marine and brackish water habitats was also observed in DAZ 6/2001-V. The former group was represented mostly by
A similar change in the composition of diatom species and their frequency was observed in DAZ 7/2001-IV. The benthic group dominated in the lower limit of the zone, including mainly euhalobous species (
The increase in the frequency of planktic forms (up to 60%) was also recorded in DAZ 4/2001-V. This group included marine species such as
The most characteristic feature of the assemblage preserved in the subbottom sediments of core 2/2001 is the abundance of the planktic group. Its main components were marine taxa, e.g.
The taphocoenose DAZ ZW 8-IV was dominated by freshwater benthic diatoms (Figs 3, 4, Table 3), among which
Diatoms observed in DAZ ZW 12-IV were dominated by benthic freshwater taxa, however, the content of the remaining halobous groups was generally higher. The major components of the oligohalobous indifferent group were represented by the following taxa:
The strong dominance of freshwater planktic species is the most striking feature of the diatom assemblage from DAZ ZW 4-IV. However, the total content of plankton clearly decreased in the upward direction within the core. Its main components were
A relatively high content of benthic species was observed in DAZ ZW 11-IV. They were mainly represented by
The diatom assemblage observed in DAZ ZW 15-III was also strongly dominated by oligohalobous indifferent taxa. However, the frequency of planktic and benthic diatoms is similar. The former group was represented by
Planktic forms belonging to various halobous groups in DAZ ZW 1-IV played the most important role. The freshwater species
The diatom community of DAZ ZW 10-IV was dominated by benthic forms. This group was represented by freshwater species, e.g.
The content of planktic taxa in DAZ ZW 14-IV did not exceed 20%. The main component was
At present, eutrophication of water bodies is an effect of slow natural and fast cultural (anthropogenic) processes, which involve an increase in nutrient concentrations in ecosystems, followed by changes in primary production (HELCOM 2009). In the Baltic Sea, the phosphorus and nitrogen load has increased several times since the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries, whereas phytoplankton production has doubled (Elmgren 1989). Urbanization, agriculture, industrial sewage and soil erosion in the catchment area have become the most important sources of nitrogen and phosphorus load (Rönnberg & Bonsdorf 2004). Biological and ecological effects are particularly pronounced and visible in the coastal zone of the Baltic Sea (e.g. Łysiak-Pastuszak et al. 2004). As a result of reduced light transparency in the water column, the depth of the euphotic layer significantly decreased (Andrén et al. 1999). On the other hand, building dams on rivers significantly reduces the silica load (Humborg et al. 2008). As a result, small centric diatom taxa with poorly silicified cell walls developed well in phytoplankton (Olli et al. 2008). Moreover, indigenous species are replaced by pollution-tolerant taxa, both in planktic and benthic groups. At the same time, the growing toxicity resulting from large cyanobacteria blooms are observed (Mazur-Marzec & Pliński 2009).
The clear human impact on the structure of diatom flora is well documented in the Gulf of Gdańsk. Very specific subfossil, so-called anthropogenic diatom assemblages occurred in the bottom sediments of cores 2/2001, 3/2001, 4/2001, 6/2001 and 7/2001. The most important anthropogenic diatoms are
Changes in species composition in anthropogenic taphocoenoses of the Gulf of Gdańsk Arrow ↓ indicates a decrease in the number of genera/taxa in relation to the older Post-Littorina diatom flora (Witak 2010).
DAZ
2/2001-III
3/2001-IV
4/2001-V
6/2001-V
7/2001-IV
Number of genera
↓10
↓8
↓7
↓3
↓18
Number of taxa
↓71
↓38
↓30
↓30
↓65
Some kind of spatial trend can be inferred from the diatom record, although the loss of taxa varies between DAZs. The largest differences, compared to older Post-Littorina diatom assemblage zones, are observed in taphocoenoses preserved in sediments that were retrieved from the eastern part of the study area (i.e. cores 2/2001 and 7/2001). Unfortunately, the youngest sediments of core 1/2001 did not contain diatoms. The number of taxa that disappeared in the youngest deposits is much smaller in the cores collected at the sites located in the north and the west (3/2001, 4/2001, 6/2001). Diatom assemblages affected by human impact did not develop in core 5/2001 drilled in the westernmost part of the study area.
This shift indicates that changes in the species composition are associated with the distance from the Vistula River estuary, which is the major source of wastewater in this area.
The increase in the content of eutraphentic benthic forms was recorded in DAZ. An important species, especially in DAZ 2/2001-III, was
Halophilous benthic species, i.e.
A strong human impact on the species composition and abundance of the diatom flora is well documented in the planktic group. The dominance of small-sized species is the most characteristic feature of this group. According to Andrén et al. (1999), this fact can be linked to the decreasing depth of the euphotic zone, which is a result of the eutrophication process.
Furthermore, higher content of freshwater taxa was observed in the subfossil plankton preserved in the deposits of the shallower part of the Gulf of Gdańsk (cores 2/2001 and 4/2001). In this group, eutraphentic and pollution-tolerant forms –
The clear environmental changes associated with human activity are also registered in the Vistula Lagoon. As in the Gulf of Gdańsk, changes in the number of taxa were recorded in the superficial sediments of all DAZs. In this case, however, the influence of this phenomenon is much smaller (Table 5).
Changes in species composition in anthropogenic taphocoenoses of the Vistula Lagoon Arrow ↓ indicates a decrease in the number of genera/taxa, whereas arrow ↑ indicates an increase in the number of genera/taxa in relation to the older Post-Littorina diatom flora (Witak 2010).
DAZ
ZW 1-IV
ZW 10-IV
ZW 14-IV
ZW 4-IV
ZW 11- IV
ZW 15-III
ZW 8-IV
ZW 12-IV
Number of genera
↓3
↓2
↑2
↓2
↑1
↓5
0
↑3
Number taxa
↓7
↓25
↓37
↓9
↓4
↓10
↓9
↑10
Some spatial differences in the extent of this process are observed in the Vistula Lagoon. The number of species is lower in the subsurface sediments in the vicinity of Krynica Morska, whereas the value is higher near Piaski. The species composition was generally slightly poorer in the central and SW parts of the lagoon. A larger number of taxa that disappeared was noted in diatom taphocoenoses of sediments retrieved near Tolkmicko and Frombork. It seems that the difference between the central and southern part of the lagoon resulted from differences in preservation. The diatom floras of DAZ ZW 4-IV, DAZ ZW 11-IV and DAZ ZW 15-III were much less preserved than in DAZ ZW 10-IV and DAZ ZW 14-IV.
The closure of the Nogat river discharge has caused a significant reduction in the abundance of typical freshwater plankton species, e.g.
The abundance of eutraphentic pollution-tolerant taxa was recorded in all diatom taphocoenoses. The benthic flora was dominated by
The environmental change associated with the progressive anthropopressure was registered in the near-bottom sediments of the Gulf of Gdańsk and the Vistula Lagoon. The anthropogenic diatom assemblage of the Gulf of Gdańsk was characterized by a significant decrease in the floristic diversity, the larger number and abundance of eutraphentic and pollution-tolerant taxa, representing both benthic and small-sized planktic forms. The degree of changes in the structure of subfossil assemblages is directly related to the distance from the mouth of the Vistula River. The process of intense eutrophication is also recorded in the Vistula Lagoon. Due to the local factors, the SW and NE regions of the Polish part of the basin are the most polluted ones. The strong reduction in the Nogat river water inflow caused a more intense input of the open sea waters and, as a consequence, the lagoon became more saline. More intense exchange with the Baltic Sea could contribute to the improvement of the environmental condition of the Vistula Lagoon.