Source of variation | Germination percentage | Germination rate |
---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 |
Cellul-N | 53.3abc | 10.6abcdef |
CTS-N | 45.3abcdef | 8.2cdefg |
CT-N | 46.6abcdef | 8.4bcdefg |
20 mT + 1 min | 50.6abcd | 8.1cdefg |
20 mT + 10 min | 41.3bcdef | 7g |
20 mT + 20 min | 45.3abcdef | 7.78efg |
30 mT + 1 min | 44bcdef | 8.3bcdefg |
30 mT + 10 min | 48abcde | 8.32bcdefg |
30 mT + 20 min | 53.3abc | 11.2abcd |
40 mT + 1 min | 49.3abcd | 8defg |
40 mT + 10 min | 47.6abcde | 8.9abcdefg |
40 mT + 20 min | 60a | 10.93abcdef |
CT-N + 20 mT + 1 min | 46.6abcdef | 9.94abcdefg |
CT-N + 20 mT + 10 min | 56ab | 9.84abcdefg |
CT-N + 20 mT + 20 min | 52abc | 9.58abcdefg |
CT-N + 30 mT + 1 min | 42.6bcdef | 12a |
CT-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 33.3de | 10.1abcdefg |
CT-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 33.3de | 8.3bcdefg |
CT-N + 40 mT + 1 min | 44bcdef | 9.8abcdefg |
CT-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 48abcde | 10.6abcdef |
CT-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 44bcdef | 8.65bcdefg |
Cellul-N + 20 mT + 1 min | 32f | 7.16g |
Cellul-N + 20 mT + 10 min | 56ab | 11.4abc |
Cellul-N + 20 mT + 20 min | 49.3abcd | 11.25abcd |
Cellul-N + 30 mT + 1 min | 40cdef | 9.46abcdefg |
Cellul-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 50.6abcd | 9.86abcdefg |
Cellul-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 38.6cdef | 8.69bcdefg |
Cellul-N + 40 mT + 1 min | 50.6abcd | 10.9abcdef |
Cellul-N + 40 mT + 10 min | 38.6cdef | 8.49bcdefg |
Cellul-N + 40 mT + 20 min | 44bcdef | 8.64bcdefg |
CTS-N + 20 mT + 1 min | 42.6bcdef | 8.93abcdefg |
CTS-N + 20 mT + 10 min | 45.3abcdef | 11.54ab |
CTS-N + 20 mT + 20 min | 48abcde | 11abcde |
CTS-N + 30 mT + 1 min | 49.3abcd | 8.08bcdef |
CTS-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 48abcde | 7.65def |
CTS-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 36def | 9.3abcdefg |
CTS-N + 40 mT + 1 min | 50.6abcd | 8.4abcdefg |
CTS-N + 40 mT + 10 min | 52abc | 9.76abcdefg |
CTS-N + 40 mT + 20 min | 45.3abcdef | 8.7bcdefg |
Ctr | 42.6bcdef | 7.8efg |
Source of variation | Length of the stem | Collar diameter | Fresh weight of the radicle | Fresh weight of the stem | Radicle dry weight | Stem dry weight | Number of leaves | Leaf area | Length of the radicle |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Cellul-N | 65a | 3.56abc | 0.166efg | 0.353cdefgh | 0.025ef | 0.069fghi | 166.6ghijkl | 2783.3fghijkl | 64.15cdef |
CTS-N | 61a | 3.83ab | 0.186def | 0.37cdefg | 0.033ef | 0.063hijk | 168ghijk | 2912efghijkl | 63.8cdef |
CT-N | 60.3a | 3.41abc | 0.103fgh | 0.256hi | 0.026ef | 0.065ghij | 157.3ghijkl | 2193.3ijkl | 64cdef |
20 mT + 1 min | 34.5fghij | 3.65abc | 0.053h | 0.236i | 0.011f | 0.035mn | 127.3jklm | 2037.3jkl | 24kl |
20 mT + 10 min | 34.16hij | 3.84ab | 0.076gh | 0.246hi | 0.007f | 0.036lmn | 119.6lm | 2057.3jkl | 28.16kl |
20 mT + 20 min | 35.3efghij | 4.08a | 0.073gh | 0.276fghi | 0.014f | 0.043klmn | 196cdefgh | 3822abcdefgh | 30.3ghijkl |
30 mT + 1 min | 36.1efghij | 3.97ab | 0.076gh | 0.25hi | 0.0327ef | 0.041klmn | 172.6ghijk | 3005.3defghijkl | 29.3kl |
30 mT + 10 min | 34.3ghij | 3.56abc | 0.073gh | 0.236i | 0.009f | 0.047jklmn | 188efghi | 3276cdefghijk | 28.5kl |
30 mT + 20 min | 38.3cdefghi | 3.67abc | 0.12fgh | 0.28fghi | 0.034ef | 0.06hijk | 215.6bcdefg | 4628abc | 57.5efgh |
40 mT + 1 min | 35.3efghij | 3.71abc | 0.12fgh | 0.306defghi | 0.022ef | 0.055ijklm | 143ijklm | 2763.3fghijkl | 43.16ghijkl |
40 mT + 10 min | 36.16efghij | 3.43abc | 0.123fgh | 0.306defghi | 0.025ef | 0.057hijkl | 163.6ghijkl | 3384bcdefghij | 50.5fghi |
40 mT + 20 min | 38.6cdefghi | 3.26abc | 0.093fgh | 0.296efghi | 0.020ef | 0.056ijklm | 175fghij | 3146.6defghijkl | 43.3ghijkl |
CT-N + 20 mT + 1 min | 39.5cdefgh | 3.86ab | 0.166efg | 0.4cde | 0.042cdef | 0.074fghi | 156.3ghijkl | 2810.6fghijkl | 40hijkl |
CT-N + 20 mT + 10 min | 40.3cdefgh | 3.56abc | 0.12fh | 0.38cdef | 0.022ef | 0.07fghi | 148.6ghijkl | 2875.3efghi | 35.8igkjll |
CT-N + 20 mT + 20 min | 41cdefgh | 3.6abc | 0.163efg | 0.393cde | 0.034ef | 0.077fghi | 175fghij | 3500abcdefghi | 43ghijkl |
CT-N + 30 mT + 1 min | 30.5ij | 2.96c | 0.11fgh | 0.263ghi | 0.027ef | 0.031n | 100.3m | 1962kl | 28.8kl |
CT-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 35.5efghij | 3.29abc | 0.11fgh | 0.316defghi | 0.032ef | 0.062hijk | 126.6jklm | 1849.3l | 39.8hijkl |
CT-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 35.5efghij | 2.95c | 0.17efg | 0.373cdefg | 0.035def | 0.069fghi | 173.6ghij | 3332bcdefghijk | 50.6fghi |
CT-N + 40 mT + 1 min | 40.6cdefgh | 3.34abc | 0.16efg | 0.416cde | 0.035def | 0.079fghi | 224abcde | 3730abcdefgh | 49.8fghij |
CT-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 41.1bcdefg | 3.51abc | 0.183def | 0.416de | 0.03ef | 0.069fghi | 235.3abcde | 4073.3abcdefg | 50.6fghi |
CT-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 42.8bcdefg | 3.71abc | 0.16efg | 0.41cde | 0.026ef | 0.072fghi | 222abcde | 3523.3abcdefghi | 42.5hijkl |
Cellul-N + 20 mT + 1 min | 45bcd | 3.72abc | 0.366c | 0.6a | 0.063abcde | 0.113bc | 223abcde | 4138.6abcdef | 62.3cdefg |
Cellul-N + 20 mT + 10 min | 43bcdef | 3.52abc | 0.58a | 0.596a | 0.102a | 0.131ab | 249.3ab | 4800.6a | 87.6ab |
Cellul-N + 20 mT + 20 min | 46.5bc | 3.9ab | 0.463a | 0.633a | 0.082abc | 0.134a | 265a | 4610abc | 76.3abcd |
Cellul-N + 30 mT + 1 min | 43.8bcde | 3.85ab | 0.443bc | 0.55ab | 0.077abcd | 0.126ab | 237.6abcd | 4127.3abcdef | 91.8a |
Cellul-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 45.8bcd | 3.71ab | 0.386bc | 0.616a | 0.085ab | 0.117abc | 242.6abc | 4544abc | 80.1abcd |
Cellul-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 43bcdef | 3.83ab | 0.266d | 0.556ab | 0.062abcde | 0.102cd | 241abcd | 4680.6ab | 52efghi |
Cellul-N + 40 mT + 1 min | 40.3cdefgh | 3.4abc | 0.373bc | 0.543ab | 0.064abcde | 0.099cde | 225.6abcde | 4356.6abcd | 71.6bcde |
Cellul-N + 40 mT + 10 min | 41.8bcdefgh | 3.65abc | 0.19def | 0.456bc | 0.04def | 0.086defg | 193.6defg | 3649abcdefgh | 47.1fghijk |
Cellul-N + 40 mT + 20 min | 41.8bcdefgh | 3.91ab | 0.233de | 0.466bc | 0.0513bcdef | 0.089def | 189efghi | 3532.6abcdefgh | 59defgh |
CTS-N + 20 mT + 1 min | 39.5cdefgh | 3.86ab | 0.166efg | 0.4cde | 0.042cdef | 0.074fghi | 155ghijkl | 2784fghijkl | 41.1hijkl |
CTS-N + 20 mT + 10 min | 37.6defghi | 3.35abc | 0.12fh | 0.38cdef | 0.082abc | 0.07fghi | 138.6jklm | 2675.3ghijkl | 35ijkl |
CTS-N + 20 mT + 20 min | 38.6cdefghi | 3.5abc | 0.156efg | 0.393cde | 0.033ef | 0.076fghi | 164ghijkl | 3280cdefghijk | 40.5kl |
CTS-N + 30 mT + 1 min | 29j | 2.96c | 0.079gh | 0.263ghi | 0.014f | 0.043klmn | 101.3m | 1982kl | 30.3ghijkl |
CTS-N + 30 mT + 10 min | 35.8efghij | 3.29abc | 0.11fgh | 0.316defghi | 0.032ef | 0.062hijk | 125klm | 2428hijkl | 41.1hijkl |
CTS-N + 30 mT + 20 min | 35.5efghij | 2.95c | 0.17efg | 0.373cdeefg | 0.035def | 0.069fghi | 173.6ghij | 3332bcdefghijk | 51.6fghi |
CTS-N + 40 mT + 1 min | 40.6cdefgh | 3.39abc | 0.16efg | 0.416cde | 0.035def | 0.076fghi | 224abcde | 3730abcdefgh | 50.8fghi |
CTS-N + 40 mT + 10 min | 41cdefgh | 3.51abc | 0.183def | 0.416cde | 0.03ef | 0.069fghi | 235.3abcde | 4073.3abcdefg | 47.1fghijk |
CTS-N + 40 mT + 20 min | 43bcdef | 3.71abc | 0.16efg | 0.41e | 0.026ef | 0.072fghi | 220.6abcef | 4246.6abcde | 41.6hijkl |
Ctr | 49.3b | 3.14bc | 0.146efg | 0.31defghi | 0.027ef | 0.058hijk | 158.6ghijkl | 2538.6hijkl | 50.3fghi |
Source of variation | Degree of freedom | Germination percentage | Germination speed | Number of leaves | Leaf area | Length of the radicle | Length of the stem |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nano | 3 | 0.889 |
8.6 |
46.6 |
33 |
49.2 |
55.6 |
Magnetic | 2 | 3.18 |
1.54 |
22.3 |
6.4 |
0.03 |
8.7 |
Time | 2 | 1.39 |
0.78 |
3.6 |
2.96 |
0.05 |
1.7 |
Nano × magnetic | 6 | 1.8 |
1.07 |
20 |
6.09 |
3.9* | 5.3 |
Nano + magnetic × time | 6 | 0.58 |
1.38 |
0.97 |
0.94 |
1.83 |
0.35 |
Magnetic × time | 4 | 2.46 |
2.34 |
3.2 |
1.7 |
1.53 |
1.02 |
Nano × magnetic × time | 12 | 1.26 |
1.37 |
1.35 |
0.7 |
4.08 |
0.41 |
Source of variation | collar diameter | fresh weight of radicle | fresh weight of the stem | radicle dry weight | stem dry weight | ||
Nano | 5.76 |
130.07 |
85.3 |
20.7 |
118.4 |
||
Magnetic | 2.14 |
7.64 |
5.2 |
3.6 |
10.5 |
||
Time | 0.127 |
0.17ns | 0.45ns | 0.7ns | 1.01ns | ||
Nano × magnetic | 2.28ns | 11.05 |
5.7 |
1.56ns | 8.9 |
||
Nano + magnetic × time | 0.15ns | 2.34 |
0.32ns | 0.61ns | 0.96ns | ||
Magnetic × time | 0.95 |
1.46ns | 1.6ns | 0.94 |
2.3 |
||
Nano × magnetic × time | 0.18ns | 5.01 |
0.65ns | 0.92ns | 2.48 |