1. bookVolume 3 (2021): Issue 1 (June 2021)
Zeitschriftendaten
License
Format
Zeitschrift
Erstveröffentlichung
30 May 2019
Erscheinungsweise
1 Hefte pro Jahr
Sprachen
Englisch
access type Open Access

Scare-quoting climate: The rapid rise of climate denial in the Swedish far-right media ecosystem

Online veröffentlicht: 06 Jul 2021
Seitenbereich: 79 - 95
Zeitschriftendaten
License
Format
Zeitschrift
Erstveröffentlichung
30 May 2019
Erscheinungsweise
1 Hefte pro Jahr
Sprachen
Englisch
Introduction

The climate crisis is recognised as the defining issue of our time. Overwhelming scientific evidence has shown for three decades that rising temperatures will affect the living conditions for all life on earth (Stoddard et al., In press). However, it took until 2018 before it was extensively discussed in the growingly influential far-right media ecosystem in Sweden. As a response to increasing coverage in legacy media – both in Sweden and abroad (Nacu-Schmidt et al., 2020; Vi-skogen & Retriever, 2019, 2020) – climate change became an important issue also for the far right. But, as we show in this study, instead of taking it seriously, a discourse was created where climate change was put into ironic quotation marks, and anyone demanding action was ridiculed.

In this article, we examine the climate change discourse on three far-right media sites during the years 2018–2019. The sites are Fria Tider, Samhällsnytt, and Nya Tider, which all reach between 6 and 11 per cent of Sweden's population (Newman et al., 2020). First, we provide a background on the climate change contrarian movement in the US and discuss how denialism has spread to the European far right. We then describe the Swedish media system, comparing it with Benkler and colleagues’ (2018) idea of how the far-right media ecosystem can be understood in terms of the propaganda feedback loop, before we account for the studied media sites. We situate our qualitative reading in the critical discourse analysis (CDA) tradition of Norman Fairclough (2010) and use Stanley Cohen's (2001) schema of denial to analyse the discourse. After presenting our empirical findings, we end with a discussion and point towards further research.

Climate change denial and a changing Swedish media system

The strategy of denouncing climate change as a hoax has roots back to the late-1980s as a tactic by extractive companies such as Exxon Mobil (Boykoff, 2011; Oreskes & Conway, 2011). In the US – and to some extent in Canada and Australia – the collaboration between fossil fuel interests and conservative think tanks in questioning climate science has been revealed in an array of studies (e.g., Brulle, 2014; Farrell, 2016; Jacques & Knox, 2016; McCright & Dunlap, 2003; Young & Coutinho, 2013). They show how what Riley Dunlap and Aaron McCright (2011) named the “climate change denial machine” was highly funded, and how it manufactured and pushed contrarian arguments into what Benkler and colleagues (2018) recently named the right-wing media ecosystem. The current sharp ideological divide between Republicans and Democrats in the US on climate science has not always existed. It is partly a function of strategic lobbyism by fossil fuel interests and conservative think tanks, which has taken advantage of, and fuelled, a growing rift during the last 30 years. In Europe, recent research shows that contrarian think tanks have been active in spreading denial since the mid-1990s, and that they have increased their output in recent years (Almiron et al., 2020; Ekberg & Pressfeldt, 2021). In the UK, which has a polarised media system, climate change denial has been prominent in opinion pieces in the right-wing media (Painter & Ashe, 2012).

Since 2000, concern over climate change has generally increased in Sweden (Rönnerstrand, 2019). There was a consensus in legacy media around the science of climate change until 2006, when a marked upturn in reporting accompanied the creation of a more organised climate change denial movement in the form of the Climate Realists (formerly the Stockholm Initiative) (Anshelm & Hultman, 2014). This influenced the far-right party, the Sweden Democrats (SD), who started spreading doubt about climate science in the parliament in 2013 (Hultman et al., 2019). Since entering the parliament in 2010, SD has enjoyed increased electoral support in every election, winning votes from both the Social Democrats and the Moderates (liberal-conservative), as well as engaging an electorate that previously did not vote. In the last election, in 2018, the party received 17.5 per cent of the vote (Aylott & Bolin, 2019). The Sweden Democrats’ main focus is immigration, and they position themselves as the only opposition party, claiming the other seven parties “are all the same” (Rydgren & van der Meiden, 2019).

The legacy, or traditional, news media in Sweden is characterised by two large public service broadcasters in television and radio and four national and several local newspapers. The media is self-regulated through the Code of Ethics for Press, Radio and Television in Sweden, and a system of public press subsidies is designed to secure a pluralistic media system. While the legacy media outlets position themselves both to the left and right politically in their opinion pieces, they all adhere to what Benkler and colleagues (2018: 77) characterise as professional truth-seeking norms in a “reality-check dynamic”:

Outlets compete on the truth and freshness of their news, and the search for scoops and sensationalism is in tension with the internal norms and the fact that other outlets will try to build their own credibility and audience in part by policing them if they get it wrong.

The reality-check dynamic might be one of the reasons why the consensus around climate science continued in Swedish legacy media even after the formation of the Climate Realists and the rise of SD. But even if climate change was not denied, it was arguably under-reported. After the climate summit in 2009, interest dropped, and it was only in 2018 and 2019 that it again reached the same levels, when the heatwave, drought, and unprecedented wildfires in the summer of 2018 – together with Greta Thunberg's school strike movement the following autumn – marked an increase in reporting on climate (Vi-skogen & Retreiver, 2019, 2020).

During the last decade, far-right anti-immigration alternative media has become an increasingly influential phenomena in Sweden and abroad (Haller et al., 2019; Nygaard, 2019; Ylä-Anttila et al., 2019).

The term “alternative media” has traditionally been used for media initiatives on the left side of the political spectrum. Holt and colleagues (2019) argue that an umbrella definition of alternative media is needed to connect present research with the previous body of literature. The essence is that alternative media perceive itself in opposition to a hegemonic media discourse “corrupted by, dependent on and uncritical of the establishment” (Holt et al., 2019: 861). Nygaard (2019) and Holt (2018) distinguish “immigration-critical alternative media” but this term does not capture the ideological questions that affect their reporting on climate change. A similar term is “counter-media” (Ylä-Anttila et al., 2019), which highlights the oppositional character but misses the ideological dimension. Instead, we use the term far-right alternative media, but we acknowledge that the this is a broad characterisation that includes ideological variance.

Sweden has been singled out in both national and international far-right media as the case that allegedly proves that a progressive welfare state is not compatible with open borders (Mulhall, 2020; Titley, 2019). Leading up to the national election in Sweden in 2018, far-right alternative media increased in visibility on social media platforms, with Samhällsnytt being especially successful in engaging readership through Facebook (Larsson, 2019; Sandberg & Ihlebæck, 2019). Parallel to the way SD position themselves as the opposition, these sites claim that legacy media, and especially the public broadcasters, echoes the voice of the political elites, rather than being a watchdog (Holt, 2019). SD supporters are also the least trustful of the public service broadcasters and legacy media (Andersson, 2020). The media sites in our study reach between 6–11 per cent of the Swedish online population (Newman et al., 2020), and until recently, none of them had signed on to the self-regulatory Code of Ethics for media.

Changes in the public press subsidy system in 2020, making digital media eligible for subsidies if they follow professional norms, led to Samhällsnytt and Nya tider signing up to the ethical code. It remains to be seen how this might affect their reporting.

The sites are part of a far-right media ecosystem that can be characterised by what Benkler and colleagues (2018) call the identity-confirming propaganda feedback loop. Actors in this loop police each other not by truthfulness, but by ideology. Anyone perceived to be stepping out of line is exposed.

An empirically noted, but so far under-studied, subject is how opposition to climate change has become a core feature of the European far right (Forchtner & Kølvraa, 2015; Forchtner et al., 2018; Jeffries, 2017; Lockwood, 2018). Most studies focusing on these themes analyse the rhetoric of politicians or political parties (e.g., Forchtner, 2019; Schaller & Carius, 2019) and show how far-right anti-immigration parties such as Alternative for Deutschland, SD, and the Austrian FPÖ, to different degrees, have opposed climate change mitigation policies and spread doubt about the science. Some studies show how far-right media can send mixed messages, opposing climate change action while still being supportive of local environmental issues such as the German forest (Forchtner & Özvatan, 2019). Others have, via surveys, shown a strong correlation between climate change denialism and nationalism (Kulin et al., 2021); conspiracy theories (Lewandowsky et al., 2015); distrust in public service media (Jylhä et al., 2020); and opposition to feminism and immigration (Jylhä & Hellmer, 2020; Krange et al., 2018). The latter is also seen in a study of online groups in Germany (Kaiser & Puschmann, 2017).

Little research has been done regarding climate change on far-right media, and no peer-reviewed studies focus on how the Swedish far-right media ecosystem report on climate change. In a corpus collected for a study on far-right media in 2016 – which included all the sites in this study

Samhällsnytt was included in the shape of its predecessor Avpixlat.

– neither environment nor climate change were covered at all (Holt, 2016). The issue of climate change is thus new in the reporting of the far-right media ecosystem. The yearly Reuters Institute Digital News Report shows an increasing reach for these sites, and the latest report also shows that the Swedish population is nearly as polarised as the US regarding opinions on climate change (Newman et al., 2020). Increasingly diverging opinions have also been noted in studies by the SOM-institute at the University of Gothenburg (Rönnerstrand, 2019). These two phenomena, a grow-ingly influential far-right media system, and signs of an increasing divide regarding the need for action on climate change is disconcerting in a country that sees itself – and is often seen globally – as an environmental leader.

Corpus and method

In order to explore how the Swedish far-right media ecosystem reported on climate change during 2018–2019, we focused on three media sites.

Nyheter Idag is the alternative media site with the largest reach. Having been part of the ethical code since 2014, however, it can be argued that it has an in-between position between the far-right media ecosystem and the legacy media. Therefore, it has been left out of the present study.

Fria Tider [Free Times] has the second-biggest reach of the Swedish online far-right alternative media sites. It reaches 11 per cent of the online population, and 27 per cent say they trust it as a news source (Newman et al., 2020). The Swedish Media Council has described the site as publishing “obviously racist, xenophobic and Islamophobic” material (Statens medieråd, 2013: 60). In our corpus, Fria Tider is the site with the most articles about climate change (n = 292), and it is a topic that has become increasingly prominent during the two years (see Figure 1).

Samhällsnytt [Community/Society News] is the third-biggest of the far-right alternative media, reaching 9 per cent of the Swedish online population. The site claims to be independent of SD, but it is run by an organisation started by the party and has editorials written by SD politicians. In its coverage, clear racist stereotypes are often used. In our corpus, it has the second-highest number of articles (n = 251), and as with Fria Tider, the issue became more prominent over time (see Figure 1).

Nya Tider [New Times] has both an online and a print edition. It comes out twice weekly and reaches 6 per cent of the Swedish online population (Newman et al. 2020). According to official subscription figures, it has 6,700 subscribers. Nya Tider started in 2012 and has, as a printed newspaper, been eligible for public press subsidies. It now receives roughly EUR 490,000 annually (Mediestödsnämnden, 2020). In our corpus, it stands out as the only site that reported on climate change already in early 2018, but reporting did not increase during the studied period (see Figure 1). It is the site with the least number of articles (n = 47).

Figure 1

Number of articles per month, by publication

The corpus was collected through a search in the Nordic digital press archive Retriever, conducted in March 2020. By using the search string “klimat* OR uppvärmning OR *greta*” [“climate* OR warming OR *greta*”], we received a total of 750 articles from the three sites. The reason to include “*greta*” was to not miss any reporting about climate activist Greta Thunberg. One could argue that this makes any article count meaningless, as there would be no articles written about Thunberg before she started her strike. Conducting the search without “*greta*”, however, still resulted in 733 articles, meaning the term had limited effect on the number of articles, but the few included might provide insight into how the far-right media ecosystem reacted to the activist's rise to fame. After removing 152 articles not related to climate change (mainly about the “political climate” or “the climate of debate”), two duplicates, three articles that had been removed from the sites, and three articles on Nya Tider where a large part of the text was behind a paywall, the corpus was reduced to 590 articles. Nya Tider operates a soft paywall, and if articles behind the wall were available in print, we accessed these through the archives at the Royal Library.

We see discourse as “being socially constitutive as well as socially conditioned” (Fairclough & Wodak, 1997: 258), and as such, discourses of climate change are shaped by – and help shape – societal responses to greenhouse gas emissions and rising temperatures. Discourses are also elements of social processes. Building on the work of Norman Fairclough, we see the “order of discourse” as the semiotic aspect of a relatively stable and established social practice situated in wider social structures. The order of discourse consists of genres (“ways of acting”), styles (“ways of being”), and discourses (“ways of representing”) (Fairclough, 2010: 74–75). The far-right media ecosystem can be seen as a social practice, and its order of discourse is thus made up of genres (e.g., news reporting, columns), styles (e.g., authoritarian, claiming to be corrective of legacy media) and discourses (e.g., nativist, anti-immigration/racist, anti-establishment). As we see in the article count, the discourse of climate change has recently been added, and in the remainder of the article, we are mainly concerned with how this is done. As we are locating our research at “the order of discourse-level”, we do a qualitative reading of a relatively large corpus, rather than a line-by-line analysis of a few selected texts.

To connect the discourse of climate change in the far-right media ecosystem with previous work on climate change denial, we follow Stanley Cohen's (2001) classification scheme (for previous use in climate research, see, e.g., Björnberg et al., 2017; Norgaard, 2011). Cohen suggests there are three different answers to the question of what is denied. The first is literal denial – to say that something is not happening; in the climate context, these are arguments about the earth not heating up or that it is not caused by humans. The second is interpretive denial – reinterpreting the meaning of what is happening in a way that it loses significance; for example, to claim that global warming is positive. The third is implicatory denial; this is not about denying the knowledge, but rather its moral, political, and psychological implications and how individuals, institutions, or states do not act despite knowing they should. Cohen (2001: 103) stresses that different types of denial often appear simultaneously, as their relationship is “ideological, rather than logical”.

Combining a toolkit from CDA with Cohen's scheme, we have closely examined all articles in our corpus twice, asking two questions:

What types of perceived climate change knowledge are used?

This relates to the sources of information. We examine if the far-right media ecosystem is informed by the established science or by the climate change countermovement, and what tropes of denial might be used.

What strategies are used to spread information and disinformation?

Disinformation spreads easily in a system characterised by the propaganda feedback loop. Here we look at semiotic aspects, such as meaning-making metaphors and keywords, and at different political strategies.

Scare-quoting climate: Denial as background knowledge

The climate change discourse on the right-wing media ecosystem is dominated by literal and interpretative denial. Nya Tider is the site that most explicitly engages with, and denies, climate science, and it did so even before the topic rose to prominence on the other two sites. This can be highlighted by two articles, leading up to and following an international climate change contrarian conference held outside Gothenburg in February 2018, organised by the Swedish climate denial network Klimatsans [Climate Sense/Reason] (Björklund, 2018a, 2018b). The lead-up article states the following:

Climate threat-sceptics have identified a series of basic problems with climate science as it is presented by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Among these are deviations from the scientific method, the accuracy of climate models, modelling of the carbon cycle and questionable data adjustments, which will be discussed at the conference.

(Björklund, 2018a)

All quotes from the empirical material are translated by Kjell Vowles.

Another example of how Nya Tider is part of the literal denial movement is when a prominent member of the movement starts contributing for the site, writing, among other articles, a favourable review of a book by the contrarian American blogger Marc Morano at Climate Depot (Tornvall, 2018). The Morano review is an example of literal and interpretive denial arguments being used in the same text, claiming “it is not more carbon dioxide heating the atmosphere, it is warmer oceans gassing out more carbon dioxide – with a positive effect on vegetation and yields”. Here climate change is seen as not anthropocentric (literal denial) and increasing amounts of carbon dioxide will be positive (interpretative denial).

While Nya Tider engages with contrarian climate science, the idea of climate change as a hoax becomes taken-for-granted, background knowledge on Samhällsnytt and Fria Tider (for previous research on background knowledge in CDA, see Fairclough, 2010: 31–36). These sites seldom discuss the actual science of climate change, and when they do, it is often with a link to the contrarian YouTube channel SwebbTV. This can be exemplified in an article on Fria Tider about the meeting between Thunberg and UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres (Fria Tider, 2018c). In the article, there is a short recap and a link to a SwebbTV interview with the well-known climate contrarian Lars Bern (Ekberg & Pressfeldt, 2021), who claims climate change is a hoax pushed by globalists aiming to create supra-national governance. With this reference, the meeting between Thunberg and Guterres is ridiculed. When climate science is discussed more in-depth, mainly in opinion pieces, common denialist tropes of religion, globalism, and a threat to free speech are used (e.g., R. Malm, 2018; Dagerlind, 2019; Tullberg, 2019; for previous research on these tropes, see, e.g., Anshelm & Hultman, 2014).

The literal denial on SwebbTV helps create the background knowledge that Fria Tider and Samhällsnytt lean on. In the discourse on these sites, the IPCC is considered an unscientific, politically correct organisation producing alarmist reports, while SwebbTV is seen to produce in-depth interviews with prominent climate scientists exposing the truth about climate hysteria (e.g., Fria Tider, 2018d; R. Malm, 2019). A similar role is served by a non-peer-reviewed manuscript about climate change by two Finnish scientists (Kauppinen & Malmi, 2019), which was uploaded to arXiv, an open archive for scholarly articles. The manuscript claimed there was no anthropogenic cause for global warming and was widely circulated on denialist blogs, despite the fact that its findings had been thoroughly dismissed (see, e.g., Climate Feedback, 2019). Fria Tider reference it several times in short sentences (e.g., Fria Tider, 2019c) to provide fodder for the background knowledge of climate change as a hoax.

The argument about climate change as a hoax is a clear contrast to legacy media where climate science is taken as real. The reinterpretation of climate change as hoax is marked in Fria Tider's and Samhällsnytt's reporting by the use of quotation marks and terms such as “so-called” or “alleged” (e.g., Nilsson, 2018; Samhällsnytt, 2018). In this way, “climate” and associated terms such as “climate activism” and “greenhouse gas emission” become semiotically important keywords, as discussed in previous scholarship (Boréus & Seiler Brylla, 2018). We first find this practice in July 2018, when several wildfires were raging in Sweden, in a response to an opinion piece in the Swedish national tabloid Expressen, which connects the fires with climate change and the carbon-intensive lifestyles of white men. Ridiculing the connection, Fria Tider wrote that Expressen claimed “it is elderly white men who deny so-called climate change” (Fria Tider, 2018a). After this, the use of quotation marks and the term so-called to denote climate change became modus operandi for Fria Tider and important for Samhällsnytt. Fria Tider used these 146 times in 116 articles (e.g., Fria Tider, 2018b, 2019b, 2019d). To create antagonisms towards climate change policy, it is often juxtaposed to welfare and security, which are perceived to be serious and worthy of attention (e.g., Fria Tider, 2019e).

This denotation of climate change becomes a core discoursal feature on the right-wing media ecosystem. In dialectical relation to the mainstream media discourse, where climate is seen as a serious issue, the keywords here are distanced to provoke ridicule and irony. The quotation marks are used in two related but slightly different ways. The first is to pick out specific words from a longer quotation. An example is when Samhällsnytt comments on a news item on SVT, saying that “the state-television uses the word ‘climate’ as many as eight times in its article” (Kristoffersson, 2019c). Here, the quotation marks around climate references what was said on SVT and is thus a factually correct statement, but by singling out one word from its wider context, it is given an ironic meaning. Formally, this technique is similar to irony in legacy media, which can signal critical distance while staying truthful to the objective, official facts (Glasser & Ettema, 1993).

The second way to use quotation marks is the so-called scare quotes. Scare quotes do not refer to someone else's words, but signal that the word has a different meaning than its literal interpretation. This is a way of quoting that the German philologist Victor Klemperer acknowledged in the language of the Third Reich, commenting that the “excessive use of what I would call ironic quotation marks […] does not restrict itself to quoting, but questions instead the truth of what is quoted and declares the quoted content a lie” (Klemperer, 1947, cited in Vandergriff, 2012). The use of scare quotes has been noted in recent scholarship on the present far-right in regard to refugees (Kreis, 2017), and in passing in connection to the climate (Forchtner et al., 2018). It was also used by the Sweden Democrats who put climate in scare quotes in their 2016 budget (Hultman et al., 2019). In our corpus, scare-quoting is used extensively, one example is when Fria Tider refers to the former Swedish Minister of Environment and Climate Isabella Lövin as “‘Minister of climate’ Isabella Lövin” (Fria Tider, 2019a). By scare-quoting her official title, Fria Tider implies that Isabella Lövin is a fraudulent politician. It is an echo of the way scare quotes were used by the far right nearly a century ago, when Klemperer noticed how “Chamberlain and Churchill and Roosevelt are always only ‘statesmen’ in ironic inverted commas, Einstein is a ‘research scientist’, Rathenau a ‘German’ and Heine a ‘German writer’” (Klemperer, 2000, cited in Vandergriff, 2012).

Oppositional strategies: Averting blame and attacking political elites

One way of opposing action on climate is to avert the blame. The claim that the actions of a small country like Sweden are negligible in a global context is a form of implicatory denial that is repeatedly used, for example, in an opinion piece claiming that “even if we closed Sweden completely our reduced carbon dioxide emissions would be eaten up in a few weeks by China's rising emissions. Sweden is responsible for 1 permille of the global emissions of greenhouse gases” (R. Malm, 2019). This is a framing of the problem implying that nothing can be done nationally. As part of the Global North, Sweden has a large historic carbon footprint, and is obliged by the Paris Agreement to cut its emissions faster (Anderson et al., 2020), so by pointing the finger of blame elsewhere, the moral and political implications are being denied.

Another strategy is to attack anyone promoting action on climate change, which is done mainly in two different ways. The first is by portraying politicians and other climate change leaders as a greedy, hypocritical elite. An example is when Fria Tider (2019f) reported on a study which shows that celebrities are the most frequent flyers (Gössling, 2019). While still scare-quoting climate change, Fria Tider quoted the scientist in a sincere manner to legitimate its own anti-establishment rhetoric. The portrayed elite is often depicted with unflattering images. One article about how the former president of the European Commission Jean-Claude Juncker uses a private jet, is noteworthy for the picture collage (Kristoffersson, 2019a). Two images are pasted together, one showing a luxury airplane seat with a bottle of champagne, the other an extreme close-up of Juncker laughing with an open mouth, with the nose being a central part of the image. Another article uses a similar collage, where a picture of new Volvo cars is pasted next to an extreme close-up of Swedish Prime Minister Stefan Löfven (Kristoffersson, 2019b). The prime minister is laughing with an open mouth with no interaction between Stefan Löfven and the camera. It is worth noting that the exact same image of Stefan Löfven has appeared several times on Klimatupplysningen, a denialist blog run by the Climate Realists (e.g., Welander, 2018). These repetitive images resemble caricatures, similar to the antisemitic images common in pre-second world war Europe.

The second type of attack is the spreading of conspiracy theories. This is most clearly articulated in Nya Tider, which picked up and articulated a conspiracy theory linking Greta Thunberg to George Soros. In April 2019, Nya Tider posted an article in English titled “George Soros behind Greta Thunberg” (Persson, 2019), which was illustrated with a manipulated photo where Soros's face was pasted over Greta Thunberg's. The article was shared more than 36,000 times in social media, according to Nya Tider's own statistics, and in our corpus, we see the conspiracy theory spread to both Samhällsnytt and Fria Tider (Fria Tider, 2019g; Westlund, 2019). In connection with Greta Thunberg's speech at the UN Climate Action Summit in New York in September 2019, it also gained international traction and was circling in the propaganda feedback loop of the international far-right media ecosystem (Dave et al., 2020). This time, it was illustrated with another fake image, where Soros's face had been pasted over Al Gore's, in a photo where Gore is standing next to Greta Thunberg.

Discussion

The climate change discourse on the Swedish far-right media ecosystem in the years 2018–2019 can be summed up as being antagonistic towards action on climate change. As we have seen, climate change became a prominent issue for Samhällsnytt and Fria Tider during these years, especially after the climate change justice movement gained increasing visibility with Greta Thunberg's school strike. In early 2018, it was a topic seldom reported, and it could be argued that the far-right media ecosystem was agnostic about climate change: it was a topic that didn’t deserve their attention. But when it became increasingly visible in legacy media, it could no longer be ignored. The agnostic attitude turned antagonistic: by using scare quotes and creating a discourse where climate change was perceived of as a hoax, as well as spreading conspiracy theories, using anti-establishment rhetoric and imagery and pointing the finger of blame elsewhere, the right-wing media ecosystem went on the attack.

Turning to our research questions, we can see the following:

It is mainly Nya Tider who discusses the science of climate change and engages with the international contrarian movement by covering conferences and reviewing books. On Fria Tider and Samhällsnytt, the idea of climate change as a hoax becomes taken-for-granted background knowledge that only occasionally needs to be justified through references to contrarian material.

The far-media ecosystem uses the strategies of scare-quoting climate, recircling conspiracy theories, and using anti-establishment rhetoric to oppose any action on climate change. These strategies are based on the literal denial of climate change, but implicatory denial is used to avert blame. The propaganda feedback helps to propel and amplify these strategies.

One point of note is that very few articles – and only from Nya Tider – take an eco-fascist stance. It has been suggested that positions on climate change might be changing within the European far right. As the consequences of rising temperatures are felt, the argument is that denialism will be untenable, and far-right actors will move to green nationalism or even eco-fascism (Dyett & Thomas, 2019). Our study shows this is not inevitable. When climate change is discussed more broadly in society, it can instead fuel an angry backlash among actors opposing action.

On the basis of our results, we suggest that further studies are needed of You-Tube material (SwebbTV in the case of Sweden), since many sites refer to such material, as well as the ideological underpinnings to the hostility against Greta Thunberg and other activists, researchers, and politicians taking action based on climate science. A third suggestion is to study the international dimensions of the far-right media ecosystem; for example, Russia has substantial and reciprocal relations with the European far right, not least regarding media initiatives (Shekhovtsov, 2018).

Sweden is often touted, both nationally and internationally, as a climate-progressive country, but the Swedish climate law does not, for example, comply with the Paris Agreement (Anderson et al., 2020). On a societal level, this constitutes a form of implicatory denial, to accept the facts but not act accordingly, but we know little about how this might interact with the discourses of the far right to create inertia. A final suggestion for further research is then to investigate how the climate denial discourse in the far-right media ecosystem connects to climate discourse in legacy media.

Figure 1

Number of articles per month, by publication
Number of articles per month, by publication

Almiron, N., Boykoff, M., Narberhaus, M., & Heras, F. (2020). Dominant counter-frames in influential climate contrarian European think tanks. Climatic Change, 162(4), 2003–2020. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-020-02820-4 AlmironN. BoykoffM. NarberhausM. HerasF. 2020 Dominant counter-frames in influential climate contrarian European think tanks Climatic Change 162 4 2003 2020 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-020-02820-4 Search in Google Scholar

Anderson, K., Broderick, J. F., & Stoddard, I. (2020). A factor of two: How the mitigation plans of ‘climate progressive’ nations fall far short of Paris-compliant pathways. Climate Policy, 20(10), 1290–1304. https://doi.org/10.1080/14693062.2020.1728209 AndersonK. BroderickJ. F. StoddardI. 2020 A factor of two: How the mitigation plans of ‘climate progressive’ nations fall far short of Paris-compliant pathways Climate Policy 20 10 1290 1304 https://doi.org/10.1080/14693062.2020.1728209 Search in Google Scholar

Andersson, U. (2020). Hur står sig svenska mediers förtroendekapital? [What is the trust in Swedish media?]. In U. Andersson, A. Carlander, & P. Öhberg (Eds.), Regntunga skyar [Rainheavy skies]. SOM Institutet, University of Gothenburg. AnderssonU. 2020 Hur står sig svenska mediers förtroendekapital? [What is the trust in Swedish media?] In AnderssonU. CarlanderA. ÖhbergP. (Eds.), Regntunga skyar [Rainheavy skies] SOM Institutet, University of Gothenburg Search in Google Scholar

Anshelm, J., & Hultman, M. (2014). A green fatwā? Climate change as a threat to the masculinity of industrial modernity. NORMA, 9(2), 84–96. https://doi.org/10.1080/18902138.2014.908627 AnshelmJ. HultmanM. 2014 A green fatwā? Climate change as a threat to the masculinity of industrial modernity NORMA 9 2 84 96 https://doi.org/10.1080/18902138.2014.908627 Search in Google Scholar

Aylott, N., & Bolin, N. (2019). A party system in flux: The Swedish parliamentary election of September 2018. West European Politics, 42(7), 1504–1515. https://doi.org/10.1080/01402382.2019.1583885 AylottN. BolinN. 2019 A party system in flux: The Swedish parliamentary election of September 2018 West European Politics 42 7 1504 1515 https://doi.org/10.1080/01402382.2019.1583885 Search in Google Scholar

Benkler, Y., Farris, R., & Roberts, H. (2018). Network propaganda. Oxford University Press. BenklerY. FarrisR. RobertsH. 2018 Network propaganda Oxford University Press Search in Google Scholar

Björnberg, K. E., Karlsson, M., Gilek, M., & Hansson, S. O. (2017). Climate and environmental science denial: A review of the scientific literature published in 1990–2015. Journal of Cleaner Production, 167, 229–241. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.08.066 BjörnbergK. E. KarlssonM. GilekM. HanssonS. O. 2017 Climate and environmental science denial: A review of the scientific literature published in 1990–2015 Journal of Cleaner Production 167 229 241 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.08.066 Search in Google Scholar

Boréus, K., & Seiler Brylla, C. (2018). Kritisk diskursanalys. In K. Boréus, & G. Bergström (Eds.), Textens mening och makt: Metodbok i samhällsvetenskaplig text- och diskursanalys [The text's meaning and power: Methodology in text- and discourse analysis in the social sciences]. (pp. 305–351). Studentlitteratur. BoréusK. Seiler BryllaC. 2018 Kritisk diskursanalys In BoréusK. BergströmG. (Eds.), Textens mening och makt: Metodbok i samhällsvetenskaplig text- och diskursanalys [The text's meaning and power: Methodology in text- and discourse analysis in the social sciences] 305 351 Studentlitteratur Search in Google Scholar

Boykoff, M. T. (2011). Who speaks for the climate? Making sense of media reporting on climate change. Cambridge University Press. BoykoffM. T. 2011 Who speaks for the climate? Making sense of media reporting on climate change Cambridge University Press Search in Google Scholar

Brulle, R. J. (2014). Institutionalizing delay: Foundation funding and the creation of U.S. climate change counter-movement organizations. Climatic Change, 122(4), 681–694. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-013-1018-7 BrulleR. J. 2014 Institutionalizing delay: Foundation funding and the creation of U.S. climate change counter-movement organizations Climatic Change 122 4 681 694 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10584-013-1018-7 Search in Google Scholar

Climate Feedback. (2019, July 12). Non-peer-reviewed manuscript falsely claims natural cloud changes can explain global warming [blog post]. https://climatefeedback.org/claimreview/non-peer-reviewed-manuscript-falsely-claims-natural-cloud-changes-can-explain-global-warming/ Climate Feedback 2019 July 12 Non-peer-reviewed manuscript falsely claims natural cloud changes can explain global warming [blog post] https://climatefeedback.org/claimreview/non-peer-reviewed-manuscript-falsely-claims-natural-cloud-changes-can-explain-global-warming/ Search in Google Scholar

Cohen, S. (2001). States of denial: Knowing about atrocities and suffering. Cambridge: Polity Press. CohenS. 2001 States of denial: Knowing about atrocities and suffering Cambridge Polity Press Search in Google Scholar

Dave, A., Ndulue, E. B., & Schwartz-Henderson, L. (2020). Targeting Greta Thunberg: A case study in online mis/disinformation [Policy paper, nr 11]. German Marshall Fund of the United States. DaveA. NdulueE. B. Schwartz-HendersonL. 2020 Targeting Greta Thunberg: A case study in online mis/disinformation [Policy paper, nr 11]. German Marshall Fund of the United States Search in Google Scholar

Dunlap, R. E., & McCright, A. M. (2011). Organized climate change denial. In J. S. Dryzek, R. B. Norgaard, & D. Schlossberg (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of climate change and society (pp. 144–160). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199566600.001.0001 DunlapR. E. McCrightA. M. 2011 Organized climate change denial In DryzekJ. S. NorgaardR. B. SchlossbergD. (Eds.), The Oxford handbook of climate change and society 144 160 Oxford University Press https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199566600.001.0001 Search in Google Scholar

Dyett, J., & Thomas, C. (2019). Overpopulation discourse: Patriarchy, racism, and the specter of ecofascism. Perspectives on Global Development and Technology, 18(1–2), 205–224. https://doi.org/10.1163/15691497-12341514 DyettJ. ThomasC. 2019 Overpopulation discourse: Patriarchy, racism, and the specter of ecofascism Perspectives on Global Development and Technology 18 1–2 205 224 https://doi.org/10.1163/15691497-12341514 Search in Google Scholar

Ekberg, K., & Pressfeldt, V. (2021, February 17). Draft paper: Market governance, obstruction, and denial: Neoliberal environmental thought and policy in Sweden, 1988–2015 [Workshop presentation]. The Ecology of Economic Thought: Online workshop, Harvard University and Uppsala University, online. EkbergK. PressfeldtV. 2021 February 17 Draft paper: Market governance, obstruction, and denial: Neoliberal environmental thought and policy in Sweden, 1988–2015 [Workshop presentation]. The Ecology of Economic Thought: Online workshop, Harvard University and Uppsala University, online. Search in Google Scholar

Fairclough, N. (2010). Critical discourse analysis: The critical study of language (2nd ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315834368 FaircloughN. 2010 Critical discourse analysis: The critical study of language 2nd ed. Routledge https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315834368 Search in Google Scholar

Fairclough, N., & Wodak, R. (1997). Critical discourse analysis. In T. A. van Dijk (Ed.), Discourse as social interaction (Reprint) (pp. 258–284). Sage. FaircloughN. WodakR. 1997 Critical discourse analysis In van DijkT. A. (Ed.), Discourse as social interaction (Reprint) 258 284 Sage Search in Google Scholar

Farrell, J. (2016). Network structure and influence of the climate change counter-movement. Nature Climate Change, 6(4), 370–374. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate2875 FarrellJ. 2016 Network structure and influence of the climate change counter-movement Nature Climate Change 6 4 370 374 https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate2875 Search in Google Scholar

Forchtner, B. (Ed.). (2019). The far right and the environment: Politics, discourse and communication. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351104043 ForchtnerB. (Ed.). 2019 The far right and the environment: Politics, discourse and communication Routledge https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351104043 Search in Google Scholar

Forchtner, B., & Kølvraa, C. (2015). The nature of nationalism: Populist radical right parties on countryside and climate. Nature and Culture, 10(2), 199–224. https://doi.org/10.3167/nc.2015.100204 ForchtnerB. KølvraaC. 2015 The nature of nationalism: Populist radical right parties on countryside and climate Nature and Culture 10 2 199 224 https://doi.org/10.3167/nc.2015.100204 Search in Google Scholar

Forchtner, B., Kroneder, A., & Wetzel, D. (2018). Being skeptical? Exploring far-right climate-change communication in Germany. Environmental Communication, 12(5), 589–604. https://doi.org/10.1080/17524032.2018.1470546 ForchtnerB. KronederA. WetzelD. 2018 Being skeptical? Exploring far-right climate-change communication in Germany Environmental Communication 12 5 589 604 https://doi.org/10.1080/17524032.2018.1470546 Search in Google Scholar

Forchtner, B., & Özvatan, Ö. (2019). Beyond the ‘German forest’ – Environmental communication by the far right in Germany. In B. Forchtner (Ed.), The far right and the environment: Politics, discourse and communication (pp. 216–236). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351104043 ForchtnerB. ÖzvatanÖ. 2019 Beyond the ‘German forest’ – Environmental communication by the far right in Germany In ForchtnerB. (Ed.), The far right and the environment: Politics, discourse and communication 216 236 Routledge https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351104043 Search in Google Scholar

Glasser, T. L., & Ettema, J. S. (1993). When the facts don’t speak for themselves: A study of the use of irony in daily journalism. Critical Studies in Mass Communication, 10(4), 322–338. https://doi.org/10.1080/15295039309366874 GlasserT. L. EttemaJ. S. 1993 When the facts don’t speak for themselves: A study of the use of irony in daily journalism Critical Studies in Mass Communication 10 4 322 338 https://doi.org/10.1080/15295039309366874 Search in Google Scholar

Gössling, S. (2019). Celebrities, air travel, and social norms. Annals of Tourism Research, 79, 102775. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2019.102775 GösslingS. 2019 Celebrities, air travel, and social norms Annals of Tourism Research 79 102775. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annals.2019.102775 Search in Google Scholar

Haller, A., Holt, K., & de la Brosse, R. (2019). The ‘other’ alternatives: Political right-wing alternative media. Journal of Alternative and Community Media, 4(1), 1–6. https://doi.org/10.1386/joacm_00039_2 HallerA. HoltK. de la BrosseR. 2019 The ‘other’ alternatives: Political right-wing alternative media Journal of Alternative and Community Media 4 1 1 6 https://doi.org/10.1386/joacm_00039_2 Search in Google Scholar

Holt, K. (2016). Skilda verkligheter? “Internets undervegetation” vs “PK-maffian” [Different realities? “Internet's undergrowth” vs “the PK-maffia”]. In L. Truedsson (Ed.), Migrationen i medierna: Men det får en väl inte prata om? [Migration in the media: But you can’t talk about that, can you?]. The Institute for Media Studies. HoltK. 2016 Skilda verkligheter? “Internets undervegetation” vs “PK-maffian” [Different realities? “Internet's undergrowth” vs “the PK-maffia”] In TruedssonL. (Ed.), Migrationen i medierna: Men det får en väl inte prata om? [Migration in the media: But you can’t talk about that, can you?] The Institute for Media Studies Search in Google Scholar

Holt, K. (2018). Alternative media and the notion of anti-systemness: Towards an analytical framework. Media and Communication, 6(4), 49–57. https://doi.org/10.17645/mac.v6i4.1467 HoltK. 2018 Alternative media and the notion of anti-systemness: Towards an analytical framework Media and Communication 6 4 49 57 https://doi.org/10.17645/mac.v6i4.1467 Search in Google Scholar

Holt, K. (2019). Right-wing alternative media (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429454691 HoltK. 2019 Right-wing alternative media 1st ed. Routledge https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429454691 Search in Google Scholar

Holt, K., Figenschou, T. U., & Frischlich, L. (2019). Key Dimensions of Alternative News Media. Digital Journalism, 7(7), 860–869. https://doi.org/10.1080/21670811.2019.1625715 HoltK. FigenschouT. U. FrischlichL. 2019 Key Dimensions of Alternative News Media Digital Journalism 7 7 860 869 https://doi.org/10.1080/21670811.2019.1625715 Search in Google Scholar

Hultman, M., Björk, A., & Viinikka, T. (2019). Far-right and climate change denial. Denouncing environmental challenges via anti-establishment rhetoric, marketing of doubts, industrial/breadwinner masculinities, enactments and ethno-nationalism. In B. Forchtner (Ed.), The far right and the environment: Politics, discourse and communication (pp. 122–136). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351104043 HultmanM. BjörkA. ViinikkaT. 2019 Far-right and climate change denial. Denouncing environmental challenges via anti-establishment rhetoric, marketing of doubts, industrial/breadwinner masculinities, enactments and ethno-nationalism In ForchtnerB. (Ed.), The far right and the environment: Politics, discourse and communication 122 136 Routledge https://doi.org/10.4324/9781351104043 Search in Google Scholar

Jacques, P. J., & Knox, C. C. (2016). Hurricanes and hegemony: A qualitative analysis of micro-level climate change denial discourses. Environmental Politics, 25(5), 831–852. https://doi.org/10.1080/09644016.2016.1189233 JacquesP. J. KnoxC. C. 2016 Hurricanes and hegemony: A qualitative analysis of micro-level climate change denial discourses Environmental Politics 25 5 831 852 https://doi.org/10.1080/09644016.2016.1189233 Search in Google Scholar

Jeffries, E. (2017). Nationalist advance. Nature Climate Change, 7(7), 469–471. https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3334 JeffriesE. 2017 Nationalist advance Nature Climate Change 7 7 469 471 https://doi.org/10.1038/nclimate3334 Search in Google Scholar

Jylhä, K. M., & Hellmer, K. (2020). Right-wing populism and climate change denial: The roles of exclusionary and anti-egalitarian preferences, conservative ideology, and antiestablishment attitudes. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, 20(1), 315–335. https://doi.org/10.1111/asap.12203 JylhäK. M. HellmerK. 2020 Right-wing populism and climate change denial: The roles of exclusionary and anti-egalitarian preferences, conservative ideology, and antiestablishment attitudes Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 20 1 315 335 https://doi.org/10.1111/asap.12203 Search in Google Scholar

Jylhä, K. M., Strimling, P., & Rydgren, J. (2020). Climate change denial among radical right-wing supporters. Sustainability, 12(23), 10226 (15pp). https://doi.org/10.3390/su122310226 JylhäK. M. StrimlingP. RydgrenJ. 2020 Climate change denial among radical right-wing supporters Sustainability 12 23 10226 (15pp). https://doi.org/10.3390/su122310226 Search in Google Scholar

Kaiser, J., & Puschmann, C. (2017). Alliance of antagonism: Counterpublics and polarization in online climate change communication. Communication and the Public, 2(4), 371–387. https://doi.org/10.1177/2057047317732350 KaiserJ. PuschmannC. 2017 Alliance of antagonism: Counterpublics and polarization in online climate change communication Communication and the Public 2 4 371 387 https://doi.org/10.1177/2057047317732350 Search in Google Scholar

Kauppinen, J., & Malmi, P. (2019). No experimental evidence for the significant anthropogenic climate change. ArXiv:1907.00165 [Physics]. http://arxiv.org/abs/1907.00165 KauppinenJ. MalmiP. 2019 No experimental evidence for the significant anthropogenic climate change ArXiv:1907.00165 [Physics] http://arxiv.org/abs/1907.00165 Search in Google Scholar

Klemperer, V. (1947). LTI – Notizbuch eines Philologen. Stuttgart: Reclam [A philologist's notebook]. Reclam. KlempererV. 1947 LTI – Notizbuch eines Philologen. Stuttgart: Reclam [A philologist's notebook] Reclam Search in Google Scholar

Klemperer, V. (2000). The language of the Third Reich: LTI – Lingua Tertii Imperii: A philologist's notebook (M. Brady, Trans.). The Athlone Press. KlempererV. 2000 The language of the Third Reich: LTI – Lingua Tertii Imperii: A philologist's notebook BradyM. Trans. The Athlone Press Search in Google Scholar

Krange, O., Kaltenborn, B. P., & Hultman, M. (2018). Cool dudes in Norway: Climate change denial among conservative Norwegian men. Environmental Sociology, 5(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1080/23251042.2018.1488516 KrangeO. KaltenbornB. P. HultmanM. 2018 Cool dudes in Norway: Climate change denial among conservative Norwegian men Environmental Sociology 5 1 1 11 https://doi.org/10.1080/23251042.2018.1488516 Search in Google Scholar

Kreis, R. (2017). #refugeesnotwelcome: Anti-refugee discourse on Twitter. Discourse & Communication, 11(5), 498–514. https://doi.org/10.1177/1750481317714121 KreisR. 2017 #refugeesnotwelcome: Anti-refugee discourse on Twitter Discourse & Communication 11 5 498 514 https://doi.org/10.1177/1750481317714121 Search in Google Scholar

Kulin, J., Johansson Sevä, I., & Dunlap, R. E. (2021, March 23). Nationalist ideology, rightwing populism, and public views about climate change in Europe. Environmental Politics, 1–24. Latest Articles. https://doi.org/10.1080/09644016.2021.1898879 KulinJ. Johansson SeväI. DunlapR. E. 2021 March 23 Nationalist ideology, rightwing populism, and public views about climate change in Europe Environmental Politics 1 24 Latest Articles. https://doi.org/10.1080/09644016.2021.1898879 Search in Google Scholar

Larsson, A. O. (2019). Right-wingers on the rise online: Insights from the 2018 Swedish elections. New Media & Society, 22(12), 2108–217. https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444819887700 LarssonA. O. 2019 Right-wingers on the rise online: Insights from the 2018 Swedish elections New Media & Society 22 12 2108 217 https://doi.org/10.1177/1461444819887700 Search in Google Scholar

Lewandowsky, S., Cook, J., Oberauer, K., Brophy, S., Lloyd, E. A., & Marriott, M. (2015). Recurrent fury: Conspiratorial discourse in the blogosphere triggered by research on the role of conspiracist ideation in climate denial. Journal of Social and Political Psychology, 3(1), 142–178. https://doi.org/10.5964/jspp.v3i1.443 LewandowskyS. CookJ. OberauerK. BrophyS. LloydE. A. MarriottM. 2015 Recurrent fury: Conspiratorial discourse in the blogosphere triggered by research on the role of conspiracist ideation in climate denial Journal of Social and Political Psychology 3 1 142 178 https://doi.org/10.5964/jspp.v3i1.443 Search in Google Scholar

Lockwood, M. (2018). Right-wing populism and the climate change agenda: Exploring the linkages. Environmental Politics, 27(4), 712–732. https://doi.org/10.1080/09644016.2018.1458411 LockwoodM. 2018 Right-wing populism and the climate change agenda: Exploring the linkages Environmental Politics 27 4 712 732 https://doi.org/10.1080/09644016.2018.1458411 Search in Google Scholar

McCright, A. M., & Dunlap, R. E. (2003). Defeating Kyoto: The conservative movement's impact on U.S. climate change policy. Social Problems, 50(3), 348–373. https://doi.org/10.1525/sp.2003.50.3.348 McCrightA. M. DunlapR. E. 2003 Defeating Kyoto: The conservative movement's impact on U.S. climate change policy Social Problems 50 3 348 373 https://doi.org/10.1525/sp.2003.50.3.348 Search in Google Scholar

Mediestödsnämnden. (2020). Beviljade driftsstöd 2020 [ Granted operation subsidies 2020]. https://www.mprt.se Mediestödsnämnden 2020 Beviljade driftsstöd 2020 [ Granted operation subsidies 2020] https://www.mprt.se Search in Google Scholar

Mulhall, J. (2020). Det internationella alt-right och Sverige [The international alt-right and Sweden]. In M. Ranstrorp, & F. Ahlin (Eds.), Från Nordiska motståndsrörelsen till alternativhögern – En studie om den svenska radikalnationalistiska miljön [From the Nordic resistance movement to the alternative right – A study about the Swedish radical nationalist milieu]. (pp. 380–402). Försvarshögskolan. MulhallJ. 2020 Det internationella alt-right och Sverige [The international alt-right and Sweden] In RanstrorpM. AhlinF. (Eds.), Från Nordiska motståndsrörelsen till alternativhögern – En studie om den svenska radikalnationalistiska miljön [From the Nordic resistance movement to the alternative right – A study about the Swedish radical nationalist milieu] 380 402 Försvarshögskolan Search in Google Scholar

Nacu-Schmidt, A., Boykoff, M., & Katzung, J. (2020). A review of media coverage of climate change and global warming in 2019. Media and Climate Change Observatory. https://scholar.colorado.edu/concern/articles/qn59q4937 Nacu-SchmidtA. BoykoffM. KatzungJ. 2020 A review of media coverage of climate change and global warming in 2019 Media and Climate Change Observatory https://scholar.colorado.edu/concern/articles/qn59q4937 Search in Google Scholar

Newman, N., Fletcher, R., Schulz, A., Simge, A., & Nielsen, R. K. (2020). Reuters Institute digital news report 2020. Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, University of Oxford. https://www.digitalnewsreport.org NewmanN. FletcherR. SchulzA. SimgeA. NielsenR. K. 2020 Reuters Institute digital news report 2020 Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, University of Oxford https://www.digitalnewsreport.org Search in Google Scholar

Norgaard, K. M. (2011). Living in Denial. The MIT Press. NorgaardK. M. 2011 Living in Denial The MIT Press Search in Google Scholar

Nygaard, S. (2019). The appearance of objectivity: How immigration-critical alternative media report the news. Journalism Practice, 13(10), 1147–1163. https://doi.org/10.1080/17512786.2019.1577697 NygaardS. 2019 The appearance of objectivity: How immigration-critical alternative media report the news Journalism Practice 13 10 1147 1163 https://doi.org/10.1080/17512786.2019.1577697 Search in Google Scholar

Oreskes, N., & Conway, E. (2011). Merchants of doubt: How a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming. Bloomsbury. OreskesN. ConwayE. 2011 Merchants of doubt: How a handful of scientists obscured the truth on issues from tobacco smoke to global warming Bloomsbury Search in Google Scholar

Painter, J., & Ashe, T. (2012). Cross-national comparison of the presence of climate scepticism in the print media in six countries, 2007–10. Environmental Research Letters, 7(4), 044005 (8pp). https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/7/4/044005 PainterJ. AsheT. 2012 Cross-national comparison of the presence of climate scepticism in the print media in six countries, 2007–10 Environmental Research Letters 7 4 044005 (8pp). https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/7/4/044005 Search in Google Scholar

Rydgren, J., & van der Meiden, S. (2019). The radical right and the end of Swedish exceptionalism. European Political Science, 18(3), 439–455. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41304-018-0159-6 RydgrenJ. van der MeidenS. 2019 The radical right and the end of Swedish exceptionalism European Political Science 18 3 439 455 https://doi.org/10.1057/s41304-018-0159-6 Search in Google Scholar

Rönnerstrand, B. (2019). Dystopiernas kamp: Svenskarnas syn på klimatförändringar och antibiotikaresistens i jämförelse [Battle of the dystopias: Comparing Swedes’ opinion on climate change and antibiotic resistance]. In U. Andersson, P. Öhberg, B. Rönnerstrand, & A. Bergström (Eds.), Storm och stiltje [Storm and lull]. SOM Institute, University of Gothenburg. RönnerstrandB. 2019 Dystopiernas kamp: Svenskarnas syn på klimatförändringar och antibiotikaresistens i jämförelse [Battle of the dystopias: Comparing Swedes’ opinion on climate change and antibiotic resistance] In AnderssonU. ÖhbergP. RönnerstrandB. BergströmA. (Eds.), Storm och stiltje [Storm and lull] SOM Institute, University of Gothenburg Search in Google Scholar

Sandberg, L. A. C., & Ihlebæck, K. A. (2019). Start sharing the news: Exploring the link between right-wing alternative media and social media during the Swedish 2018 election. Statsvetenskaplig Tidskrift, 121(3), 421–440. https://journals.lub.lu.se/st/article/download/19816/17898 SandbergL. A. C. IhlebæckK. A. 2019 Start sharing the news: Exploring the link between right-wing alternative media and social media during the Swedish 2018 election Statsvetenskaplig Tidskrift 121 3 421 440 https://journals.lub.lu.se/st/article/download/19816/17898 Search in Google Scholar

Schaller, S., & Carius, A. (2019). Convenient truths: Mapping climate agendas of right-wing populist parties in Europe. Adelphi. SchallerS. CariusA. 2019 Convenient truths: Mapping climate agendas of right-wing populist parties in Europe Adelphi Search in Google Scholar

Shekhovtsov, A. (2018). Russia and the Western far right: Tango noir. Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315560991 ShekhovtsovA. 2018 Russia and the Western far right: Tango noir Routledge https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315560991 Search in Google Scholar

Statens medieråd. (2013). Våldsbejakande och antidemokratiska budskap på internet [Violent and anti-democratic messages on the Internet]. Swedish Media Council. Statens medieråd 2013 Våldsbejakande och antidemokratiska budskap på internet [Violent and anti-democratic messages on the Internet] Swedish Media Council Search in Google Scholar

Stoddard, I., Anderson, K., Capstick, S., Carton, W., Depledge, J., Facer, K., Gough, C., Hache, F., Hoolohan, C., Hultman, M., Hällström, N., Klinsky, S., Kuchler, M., Lövbrand, E., Nasiritousi, N., Peters, G. P., Sokona, Y., Stirling, A., Stilwell, M., Spash, C., & Williams, M. (In press). Three decades of climate mitigation: Why haven’t we bent the emissions curve? Annual Review of Environment and Resources, 46. StoddardI. AndersonK. CapstickS. CartonW. DepledgeJ. FacerK. GoughC. HacheF. HoolohanC. HultmanM. HällströmN. KlinskyS. KuchlerM. LövbrandE. NasiritousiN. PetersG. P. SokonaY. StirlingA. StilwellM. SpashC. WilliamsM. (In press) Three decades of climate mitigation: Why haven’t we bent the emissions curve? Annual Review of Environment and Resources 46 Search in Google Scholar

Titley, G. (2019). Taboo news about Sweden: The transnational assemblage of a racialized spatial imaginary. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 39(11/12), 1010–1023. https://doi.org/10.1108/IJSSP-02-2019-0029 TitleyG. 2019 Taboo news about Sweden: The transnational assemblage of a racialized spatial imaginary International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 39 11/12 1010 1023 https://doi.org/10.1108/IJSSP-02-2019-0029 Search in Google Scholar

Vandergriff, I. (2012). Taking a stance on stance: Metastancing as legitimation. Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis Across Disciplines, 6(1), 53–75. https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/fass/journals/cadaad/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Volume-6_Vandergriff.pdf VandergriffI. 2012 Taking a stance on stance: Metastancing as legitimation Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis Across Disciplines 6 1 53 75 https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/fass/journals/cadaad/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/Volume-6_Vandergriff.pdf Search in Google Scholar

Vi-skogen, & Retriever. (2019). Varmare klimat—Iskall nyhet? 2019 [Warmer climate – ice-cold news 2019]. Vi-skogen Retriever. Vi-skogen, & Retriever 2019 Varmare klimat—Iskall nyhet? 2019 [Warmer climate – ice-cold news 2019] Vi-skogen Retriever Search in Google Scholar

Vi-skogen, & Retriever. (2020). Varmare klimat—Iskall nyhet? 2020 [Warmer climate – ice-cold news 2019]. Vi-skogen Retriever. Vi-skogen, & Retriever 2020 Varmare klimat—Iskall nyhet? 2020 [Warmer climate – ice-cold news 2019] Vi-skogen Retriever Search in Google Scholar

Ylä-Anttila, T., Bauvois, G., & Pyrhönen, N. (2019). Politicization of migration in the countermedia style: A computational and qualitative analysis of populist discourse. Discourse, Context & Media, 32, 100326 (8pp). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dcm.2019.100326 Ylä-AnttilaT. BauvoisG. PyrhönenN. 2019 Politicization of migration in the countermedia style: A computational and qualitative analysis of populist discourse Discourse, Context & Media 32 100326 (8pp). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.dcm.2019.100326 Search in Google Scholar

Young, N., & Coutinho, A. (2013). Government, anti-reflexivity, and the construction of public ignorance about climate change: Australia and Canada compared. Global Environmental Politics, 13(2), 89–108. https://doi.org/10.1162/GLEP_a_00168 YoungN. CoutinhoA. 2013 Government, anti-reflexivity, and the construction of public ignorance about climate change: Australia and Canada compared Global Environmental Politics 13 2 89 108 https://doi.org/10.1162/GLEP_a_00168 Search in Google Scholar

Björklund, P. (2018a, February 2). Klimatkonferens i Göteborg [Climate conference in Gothenburg]. Nya Tider. https://www.nyatider.nu/klimatkonferens-i-goteborg/ BjörklundP. 2018a February 2 Klimatkonferens i Göteborg [Climate conference in Gothenburg] Nya Tider https://www.nyatider.nu/klimatkonferens-i-goteborg/ Search in Google Scholar

Björklund, P. (2018b, March 10). Nya rön på klimatkonferens: Solens klimatpåverkan allt tydligare, koldioxid ingen fara [New findings at climate conference: The sun's influence on climate increasingly apparent, carbon dioxide no problem]. Nya Tider. https://www.nyatider.nu/solens-klimatpaverkan-allt-tydligare-koldioxid-ingen-fara/ BjörklundP. 2018b March 10 Nya rön på klimatkonferens: Solens klimatpåverkan allt tydligare, koldioxid ingen fara [New findings at climate conference: The sun's influence on climate increasingly apparent, carbon dioxide no problem] Nya Tider https://www.nyatider.nu/solens-klimatpaverkan-allt-tydligare-koldioxid-ingen-fara/ Search in Google Scholar

Dagerlind, M. (2019, April 26). Den millennialistiska klimatsekten – vänsterelitens folkförakt i nya kläder. [The millennial climate sect – the left-elite's contempt for the people in new clothes]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/den-millennialistiska-klimatsekten-vansterelitens-folkforakt-i-nya-klader/ DagerlindM. 2019 April 26 Den millennialistiska klimatsekten – vänsterelitens folkförakt i nya kläder. [The millennial climate sect – the left-elite's contempt for the people in new clothes] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/den-millennialistiska-klimatsekten-vansterelitens-folkforakt-i-nya-klader/ Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2018a, July 20). Expressen-chefen skyller skogsbränderna på ‘äldre vita män’ [The Expressen-boss blames forest fires on ‘elderly white men’]. Fria Tider. http://www.friatider.se/expressens-vice-kulturchef-skyller-skogsbr-nderna-p-ldre-vita-m-n Fria Tider 2018a July 20 Expressen-chefen skyller skogsbränderna på ‘äldre vita män’ [The Expressen-boss blames forest fires on ‘elderly white men’] Fria Tider http://www.friatider.se/expressens-vice-kulturchef-skyller-skogsbr-nderna-p-ldre-vita-m-n Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2018b, August 7). Fake news om ‘klimatförändringar’ spreds till 2,5 miljarder människor [Fake news about ‘climate change’ was spread to 2.5 million people]. Fria Tider. http://www.friatider.se/fake-news-om-klimatf-r-ndringar-spreds-till-25-miljarder-m-nniskor Fria Tider 2018b August 7 Fake news om ‘klimatförändringar’ spreds till 2,5 miljarder människor [Fake news about ‘climate change’ was spread to 2.5 million people] Fria Tider http://www.friatider.se/fake-news-om-klimatf-r-ndringar-spreds-till-25-miljarder-m-nniskor Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2018c, November 30). Greta Thunberg ska träffa FN:s generalsekreterare [Greta Thunberg will meet the General Secretary of the UN]. Fria Tider. http://www.friatider.se/greta-thunberg-ska-tr-ffa-fns-generalsekreterare Fria Tider 2018c November 30 Greta Thunberg ska träffa FN:s generalsekreterare [Greta Thunberg will meet the General Secretary of the UN] Fria Tider http://www.friatider.se/greta-thunberg-ska-tr-ffa-fns-generalsekreterare Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2018d, December 13). Klimathysteri kan kosta Norge 7.000 miljarder [Climate hysteria can cost Norway 7,000 billion]. Fria Tider. http://www.friatider.se/klimathysteri-kan-kosta-norge-7000-miljarder Fria Tider 2018d December 13 Klimathysteri kan kosta Norge 7.000 miljarder [Climate hysteria can cost Norway 7,000 billion] Fria Tider http://www.friatider.se/klimathysteri-kan-kosta-norge-7000-miljarder Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019a, April 13). Lövins plan: Införa så radikal klimatpolitik att ‘resten av världen blir avundsjuk på Sverige’ [Lövin's plan: Introduce such climate politics that the ‘rest of the world becomes jealous of Sweden’]. Fria Tider. http://www.friatider.se/l-vins-plan-inf-ra-s-radikal-klimatpolitik-att-resten-av-v-rlden-blir-avundsjuk-p-sverige Fria Tider 2019a April 13 Lövins plan: Införa så radikal klimatpolitik att ‘resten av världen blir avundsjuk på Sverige’ [Lövin's plan: Introduce such climate politics that the ‘rest of the world becomes jealous of Sweden’] Fria Tider http://www.friatider.se/l-vins-plan-inf-ra-s-radikal-klimatpolitik-att-resten-av-v-rlden-blir-avundsjuk-p-sverige Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019b, May 31). Dansk journalist vill polisanmäla Gretas mamma [Danish journalist wants to report Greta's mom to the police]. Fria Tider. http://www.friatider.se/dansk-journalist-vill-polisanm-la-gretas-mamma Fria Tider 2019b May 31 Dansk journalist vill polisanmäla Gretas mamma [Danish journalist wants to report Greta's mom to the police] Fria Tider http://www.friatider.se/dansk-journalist-vill-polisanm-la-gretas-mamma Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019c, July 25). Greta kräver att vuxna ska skolka från jobbet [Greta demands that adults go AWOL from work]. Fria Tider. https://www.friatider.se/greta-kr-ver-att-alla-vuxna-slutar-jobba Fria Tider 2019c July 25 Greta kräver att vuxna ska skolka från jobbet [Greta demands that adults go AWOL from work] Fria Tider https://www.friatider.se/greta-kr-ver-att-alla-vuxna-slutar-jobba Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019d, September 10). ‘Tomma ord’ – hård kritik mot Löfvens regeringsförklaring [‘Empty words’ – hard critique against Löfven's statement of goverment policy]. Fria Tider. https://www.friatider.se/tomma-ord-h-rd-kritik-mot-l-fvens-regeringsf-rklaring Fria Tider 2019d September 10 ‘Tomma ord’ – hård kritik mot Löfvens regeringsförklaring [‘Empty words’ – hard critique against Löfven's statement of goverment policy] Fria Tider https://www.friatider.se/tomma-ord-h-rd-kritik-mot-l-fvens-regeringsf-rklaring Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019e, September 20). Löfven: Samhället kan gå sönder – av ‘klimatförändringar’ [Löfven: Society can break – because of ‘climate change’]. Fria Tider. https://www.friatider.se/l-fven-samh-llet-kan-g-s-nder-av-klimatf-r-ndringar Fria Tider 2019e September 20 Löfven: Samhället kan gå sönder – av ‘klimatförändringar’ [Löfven: Society can break – because of ‘climate change’] Fria Tider https://www.friatider.se/l-fven-samh-llet-kan-g-s-nder-av-klimatf-r-ndringar Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019f, October 22). Globala eliten flyger tusen gånger mer än genomsnittet [The global elite fly more than a thousand times the average]. Fria Tider. https://www.friatider.se/globala-eliten-flyger-tusen-g-nger-mer-n-genomsnittet Fria Tider 2019f October 22 Globala eliten flyger tusen gånger mer än genomsnittet [The global elite fly more than a thousand times the average] Fria Tider https://www.friatider.se/globala-eliten-flyger-tusen-g-nger-mer-n-genomsnittet Search in Google Scholar

Fria Tider. (2019g, December 3). Greta skriver i Soros-tidning: ‘Rasismen’ måste bekämpas [Greta writes in Soros-newspaper: ‘Racism’ must be fought]. Fria Tider. https://www.friatider.se/greta-skriver-i-soros-tidning-rasismen-m-ste-bek-mpas Fria Tider 2019g December 3 Greta skriver i Soros-tidning: ‘Rasismen’ måste bekämpas [Greta writes in Soros-newspaper: ‘Racism’ must be fought] Fria Tider https://www.friatider.se/greta-skriver-i-soros-tidning-rasismen-m-ste-bek-mpas Search in Google Scholar

Kristoffersson, S. (2019a, January 6). Jean-Claude Juncker flög privat för miljoner – kräver att EU-medborgarna blir mer klimatsmarta [Jean-Claude Juncker flew privately for millions – demands that EU citizens become more climate smart]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/jean-claude-juncker-flog-privat-for-miljoner-kraver-att-eu-medborgarna-blir-mer-klimatsmarta/ KristofferssonS. 2019a January 6 Jean-Claude Juncker flög privat för miljoner – kräver att EU-medborgarna blir mer klimatsmarta [Jean-Claude Juncker flew privately for millions – demands that EU citizens become more climate smart] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/jean-claude-juncker-flog-privat-for-miljoner-kraver-att-eu-medborgarna-blir-mer-klimatsmarta/ Search in Google Scholar

Kristoffersson, S. (2019b, January 19). Nya regeringen vill förbjuda försäljning av bensin- och dieselbilar [The new government wants to ban sales of petrol and diesel cars]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/nya-regeringen-vill-forbjuda-forsaljning-av-bensin-och-dieselbilar-fran-2030/ KristofferssonS. 2019b January 19 Nya regeringen vill förbjuda försäljning av bensin- och dieselbilar [The new government wants to ban sales of petrol and diesel cars] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/nya-regeringen-vill-forbjuda-forsaljning-av-bensin-och-dieselbilar-fran-2030/ Search in Google Scholar

Kristoffersson, S. (2019c, September 21). Göteborg tvingar elever till köttfria och ‘klimatsmarta’ måltider [Gothenburg forces pupils to meat-free and ‘climate smart’ meals]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/goteborg-tvingar-elever-till-kottfria-och-klimatsmarta-maltider/ KristofferssonS. 2019c September 21 Göteborg tvingar elever till köttfria och ‘klimatsmarta’ måltider [Gothenburg forces pupils to meat-free and ‘climate smart’ meals] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/goteborg-tvingar-elever-till-kottfria-och-klimatsmarta-maltider/ Search in Google Scholar

Malm, R. (2018, December 14). Klimat eller väder? [Climate or weather?] Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/klimat-eller-vader/ MalmR. 2018 December 14 Klimat eller väder? [Climate or weather?] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/klimat-eller-vader/ Search in Google Scholar

Malm, R. (2019, September 14). Rolf Malm: Mannen bakom klimatlarmen fälld som bedragare [Rolf Malm: The man behind the climate alarms convicted as a charlatan]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/mannen-bakom-klimatlarmen-falld-som-bedragare/ MalmR. 2019 September 14 Rolf Malm: Mannen bakom klimatlarmen fälld som bedragare [Rolf Malm: The man behind the climate alarms convicted as a charlatan] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/mannen-bakom-klimatlarmen-falld-som-bedragare/ Search in Google Scholar

Nilsson, A. (2018, November 6). Dagens Nyheter bjuder in till ‘Klimatkväll’ med ärkebiskopen och klimatpsykolog [Dagens Nyheter to host a ‘Climate evening’ with the archbishop and climate psychologist]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/dagens-nyheter-bjuder-in-till-klimatkvall-med-arkebiskopen-och-klimatpsykolog/ NilssonA. 2018 November 6 Dagens Nyheter bjuder in till ‘Klimatkväll’ med ärkebiskopen och klimatpsykolog [Dagens Nyheter to host a ‘Climate evening’ with the archbishop and climate psychologist] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/dagens-nyheter-bjuder-in-till-klimatkvall-med-arkebiskopen-och-klimatpsykolog/ Search in Google Scholar

Persson, J. (2019, April 24). George Soros behind Greta Thunberg. Nya tider. https://www.nyatider.nu/the-global-network-behind-greta-thunberg/ PerssonJ. 2019 April 24 George Soros behind Greta Thunberg Nya tider https://www.nyatider.nu/the-global-network-behind-greta-thunberg/ Search in Google Scholar

Samhällsnytt. (2018, November 16). Forskare erkänner avgörande fel i studie om hur snabbt haven värms upp [Scientists admit critical error in study regarding how quickly the ocean heats up]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/forskare-erkanner-avgorande-fel-i-studie-om-hur-snabbt-haven-varms-upp/ Samhällsnytt 2018 November 16 Forskare erkänner avgörande fel i studie om hur snabbt haven värms upp [Scientists admit critical error in study regarding how quickly the ocean heats up] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/forskare-erkanner-avgorande-fel-i-studie-om-hur-snabbt-haven-varms-upp/ Search in Google Scholar

Tornvall, T. (2018, August 25). Kritiska klimatböcker varnar för bisarra överdrifter [Critical climate books warn against bizarre overstatements]. Nya tider. https://www.nyatider.nu/kritiska-klimat-bocker-varnar-for-bisarra-overdrifter/ TornvallT. 2018 August 25 Kritiska klimatböcker varnar för bisarra överdrifter [Critical climate books warn against bizarre overstatements] Nya tider https://www.nyatider.nu/kritiska-klimat-bocker-varnar-for-bisarra-overdrifter/ Search in Google Scholar

Tullberg, J. (2019, April 5). Hot—Verkliga eller fiktiva? [Threats – Real or imagined?] Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/hot-verkliga-eller-fiktiva/ TullbergJ. 2019 April 5 Hot—Verkliga eller fiktiva? [Threats – Real or imagined?] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/hot-verkliga-eller-fiktiva/ Search in Google Scholar

Welander, P. (2018, August 30). Regeringen Löfven slösar bort sex miljoner kronor på att kartlägga klimathotskeptiker [The Löfven government wastes six million Swedish kronor to map climate-threat sceptics]. Klimatupplysningen [blog]. http://www.klimatupplysningen.se/2018/08/30/regeringen-lofven-slosar-bort-sex-miljoner-kronor-pa-att-kartlagga-klimathotskeptiker/ WelanderP. 2018 August 30 Regeringen Löfven slösar bort sex miljoner kronor på att kartlägga klimathotskeptiker [The Löfven government wastes six million Swedish kronor to map climate-threat sceptics] Klimatupplysningen [blog]. http://www.klimatupplysningen.se/2018/08/30/regeringen-lofven-slosar-bort-sex-miljoner-kronor-pa-att-kartlagga-klimathotskeptiker/ Search in Google Scholar

Westlund, H. (2019, October 18). Klimat-Greta flydde från intervju med kritiska frågor [Climate – Greta fled interview with critical questions]. Samhällsnytt. https://samnytt.se/klimat-greta-flydde-fran-intervju-med-kritiska-fragor/ WestlundH. 2019 October 18 Klimat-Greta flydde från intervju med kritiska frågor [Climate – Greta fled interview with critical questions] Samhällsnytt https://samnytt.se/klimat-greta-flydde-fran-intervju-med-kritiska-fragor/ Search in Google Scholar

Recommended articles from Trend MD

Plan your remote conference with Sciendo