Open Access

Review and evaluation of commercially available wound dressings

, , ,  and   
Dec 31, 2024

Cite
Download Cover

Fig. 1.

Wound healing process with an adequately fitted dressing. (figure based on [4])
Wound healing process with an adequately fitted dressing. (figure based on [4])

Fig. 2

Prospects for the global dressing market (figure based on [5])
Prospects for the global dressing market (figure based on [5])

Fig. 3.

TIMERS concept (figure based on [29])
TIMERS concept (figure based on [29])

Fig. 4.

Scheme of free swell absorptive capacity (figure based on self-analysis)
Scheme of free swell absorptive capacity (figure based on self-analysis)

Fig. 5.

Scheme of moisture vapour transmission rate (figure based on self-analysis)
Scheme of moisture vapour transmission rate (figure based on self-analysis)

Fig. 6.

Mode of action of the hydrogel dressing in the case of- a) dry wounds, b) wounds with exudate (figure based on [34])
Mode of action of the hydrogel dressing in the case of- a) dry wounds, b) wounds with exudate (figure based on [34])

Fig. 7.

Mode of action of the hydrocolloid dressing (figure based on self-analysis)
Mode of action of the hydrocolloid dressing (figure based on self-analysis)

Fig. 8

Mode of action of the a) super absorption dressing and b) superabsorbent polymer (figure based on [36])
Mode of action of the a) super absorption dressing and b) superabsorbent polymer (figure based on [36])

Fig. 9.

Mode of action of the absorption dressing (figure based on self-analysis)
Mode of action of the absorption dressing (figure based on self-analysis)

Fig. 10.

Mode of action of the alginate dressing (figure based on self-analysis)
Mode of action of the alginate dressing (figure based on self-analysis)

Fig. 11.

Mode of action of the foam dressing (figure based on self-analysis)
Mode of action of the foam dressing (figure based on self-analysis)

Fig. 12.

Moisture vapour transmission rate (MVTR) of wound dressing when in contact with vapour
Moisture vapour transmission rate (MVTR) of wound dressing when in contact with vapour

Fig. 13.

Free swell absorptive capacity of dressings
Free swell absorptive capacity of dressings

Type and properties of dressings (table based on [25])

Type Properties
Passive dressing
Foams – Protection against dehydration
Films – Protection against infection and injury
Silicones – For wounds with little exudate and epithelial wounds
Occlusive dressings
Hydrocolloids – Occlusive
– Completely protects the wound from the external environment
Interactive dressings
Alginates – For clean granulation wounds
Hydrocolloids – Protection against dehydration
Hydrogels – Promoting an optimal environment for wound healing
– Actively interacting with the wound surface by filling in tissue defects to stimulate granulation or protecting non-viable tissue to stimulate wound debridement.

Types of dressing and their properties

Type of dressing Company (name of dressing) Type of wound Properties
Hydrogel KIKGEL (Aqua-Gel®) bedsores, diabetic foot, burns

provide adequate moisture to the wound

high volume of MVTR

a moderate volume of free swell absorptive capacity

Hartmann (HydroTac® Transparent Comfort) burns
Lohamann & Rauscher (Suprasorb G) bedsores, ulcers, burns
Derma Sciences (Medihoney® HCS, Medihoney® HCS with adhesive border) bedsores, ulcers
Hydrocolloid Convatec (Granuflex™ Extra Thin, Granuflex™, Granuflex™ Signal, Granuflex™ Bordered) bedsores, ulcers, burns

create a moist environment that enhances wound healing

low volume of MVTR, low volume of free swell absorptive capacity

Hartmann (Hydrocoll®, Hydrocoll® Thin) bedsores, ulcers, burns
TZMO (Medisorb H) bedsores, ulcers, burns
Superabsorbent Hartmann (Zetuvit® Plus) bedsores, ulcers

minimise adhesion to the wound and effectively manage exudate

a moderate volume of MVTR

high volume of free swell absorptive capacity

Mölnlycke (Mextra Superabsorbent®) bedsores, ulcers
Lohmann & Rauscher (Vliwasorb® Pro, Vliwasorb® Adhesive) bedsores, ulcers, burns, postoperative
Advancis Medica (Eclypse Adherent) bedsores, ulcers
Abigo Medical (Sorbact® Superabsorbent) bedsores, ulcers
Convatec (ConvaMax™ Superabsorber) bedsores, ulcers
Absorbent Lohmann & Rauscher (Vliwaktiv®) bedsores, ulcers, burns

absorb wound exudate and provide a relatively dry wound environment high volume of MVTR

high volume of free swell absorptive capacity

Zarys (Elastopor Steril) postoperative, little to no exudate
Abigo Medical (Sorbact® Absorbtion Dressing) ulcers, postoperative, infected
Coloplast (Biatain® Super Adhesive) burns, ulcers, postoperative
Lohmann & Rauscher (Vliwazell®) heavy exudate
Calcium alginate Hartmann (Sorbalgon®) bedsores, ulcers, burns

generate moderate to profuse exudate and require additional support to keep them in place

high volume of MVTR

a moderate volume of free swell absorptive capacity

TZMO (Medisorb A) bedsores, diabetic foot, ulcers
Convatec (Kaltostat™) ulcers, bleeding heavily
Lohmann & Rauscher (Suprasorb® A) bedsores
Foam TZMO (Medisorb P Plus Adhesive) bedsores, burns

create a moist environment that promotes wound healing

high volume of MVTR

high volume of free swell absorptive capacity

Mölnlycke (Mepilex® Border EM, Mepilex® EM, Mepilex® Border) bedsores, diabetic foot, burns, ulcers
Convatec (Aquacel™ Foam, Aquacel™ Foam Non Adhesive, Foam Lite™) bedsores, diabetic foot, burns, ulcers
Smith & Nephew (Allevyn Adhesive) bedsores, diabetic foot, burns, ulcers
Coloplast (Biatain® Non Adhesive) bedsores, diabetic foot, burns, ulcers
Abigo Medical (Sorbact® Foam) infected
Lohmann & Rauscher (Suprasorb® P, Suprasorb® P Sensitive Border) bedsores, ulcers, burns
Hartmann (HydroTac, HydroTac® Transparent Comfort) bedsores

Mechanical properties of dressings

Type of dressings Max. strength, direction 1 (N) Elongation at max. strength, direction 1 (%) Max. strength, direction 2 (N) Elongation at max. strength, direction 2 (%)
Hydrogels 12.2 ± 2.6 629 ± 412 15.0 ± 5.5 498 ± 285
Hydrocolloids 19.4 ± 6.4 1653 ± 616 18.4 ± 6.2 1659 ± 593
Superabsorbents 61.8 ± 26.6 51 ± 37 43.1 ± 13.5 102 ± 48
Absorbents 62.2 ± 42.5 48 ± 26 60.7 ± 47.8 69 ± 26
Alginates 16.7 ± 6.9 22 ± 9 7.4 ± 3.5 35 ± 12
Foams 17.9 ± 7.3 769 ± 249 18.5 ± 7.5 762 ± 229