Aggressive Tax Planning in the Post-BEPS Era: Systematic Approach with Analysis and Examples¹

Agresta, Robert A. 2017. “Tax Planning as Business Driver.” Penn State Journal of Law & International Affairs 5 (2): 538–603. Agresta Robert A. 2017 . “Tax Planning as Business Driver.” Penn State Journal of Law & International Affairs 5 ( 2 ): 538 – 603 . Search in Google Scholar

Anderson, Ian et al. 2017. “United Arab Emirates/Gulf Cooperation Council Branch Report.” In International Fiscal Association (ed): Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses, edited by International Fiscal Association, 807–828. International Fiscal Association. Anderson Ian 2017 . “United Arab Emirates/Gulf Cooperation Council Branch Report.” In International Fiscal Association (ed): Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses , edited by International Fiscal Association , 807 – 828 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Arnold, Brian J. 2019. “International Tax Primer 4^th Edition.” Kluwer Law International BV. Arnold Brian J. 2019 . “International Tax Primer 4^th Edition.” Kluwer Law International BV . Search in Google Scholar

Avi-Yonah, and Reuven S. 2007. International Tax as International Law: An Analysis of the International Tax Regime. Cambridge University Press 2007. Avi-Yonah Reuven S. 2007 . International Tax as International Law: An Analysis of the International Tax Regime . Cambridge University Press 2007 . Search in Google Scholar

Avi-Yonah, Reuven S. and Haiyan Xu. 2017. “Evaluating BEPS.” Erasmus Law Review 10 (1): 3–11. Avi-Yonah Reuven S. Haiyan Xu . 2017 . “Evaluating BEPS.” Erasmus Law Review 10 ( 1 ): 3 – 11 . Search in Google Scholar

Brauner, Yariv. 2017. “United States Branch Report”. In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses, edited by International Fiscal Association, 849–869. International Fiscal Association. Brauner Yariv. 2017 . “United States Branch Report” . In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses , edited by International Fiscal Association , 849 – 869 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Burgers, I. J. J. and I. J., Mosquera Valderrama. 2017. “Fairness: A Dire International Tax Standard with No Meaning?” Intertax 45 (12): 767–783. Burgers I. J. J. I. J. Mosquera Valderrama . 2017 . “Fairness: A Dire International Tax Standard with No Meaning?” Intertax 45 ( 12 ): 767 – 783 . Search in Google Scholar

Burkhalter, Natassia. 2017. “Switzerland Branch Report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses, edited by International Fiscal Association, 743–764. International Fiscal Association. Burkhalter Natassia. 2017 . “Switzerland Branch Report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses , edited by International Fiscal Association , 743 – 764 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Christians, Allison and Stephen Shay. 2017. “General report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses, edited by International Fiscal Association, 17–63. International Fiscal Association. Christians Allison Stephen Shay . 2017 . “General report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses , edited by International Fiscal Association , 17 – 63 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Dourado, Ana Paula. 2015. “Aggressive Tax Planning in EU Law and in Light of BEPS: The EC Recommendation on Aggressive Tax Planning and BEPS Action 2 and 6.” Intertax 43 (1): 42–57. Dourado Ana Paula. 2015 . “Aggressive Tax Planning in EU Law and in Light of BEPS: The EC Recommendation on Aggressive Tax Planning and BEPS Action 2 and 6.” Intertax 43 ( 1 ): 42 – 57 . Search in Google Scholar

Dourado, Ana Paula. 2020. “Aggressive tax planning and harmful tax competition.” In Research Handbook on European Union Taxation Law, edited by Christiana HJI Panayi, Werner Haslehner and Edoardo Traversa, 390–409. Edward Elgar Publishing. Dourado Ana Paula. 2020 . “Aggressive tax planning and harmful tax competition.” In Research Handbook on European Union Taxation Law , edited by Christiana HJI Panayi, Werner Haslehner and Edoardo Traversa , 390 – 409 . Edward Elgar Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

Dyreng, Scott D., Michelle Hanlon, and Edward L. Maydew. 2008. “Long-Run Corporate Tax Avoidance.” The Accounting Review 83 (1): 61–82. Dyreng Scott D. Michelle Hanlon Edward L. Maydew . 2008 . “Long-Run Corporate Tax Avoidance.” The Accounting Review 83 ( 1 ): 61 – 82 . Search in Google Scholar

Escribano, Eva. 2017. “Is the OECD/G20 BEPS Initiative Heading in the Right Direction? Some Forgotten (and Uncomfortable) Questions.” Bulletin for International Taxation 71 (5): 250–258. Escribano Eva. 2017 . “Is the OECD/G20 BEPS Initiative Heading in the Right Direction? Some Forgotten (and Uncomfortable) Questions.” Bulletin for International Taxation 71 ( 5 ): 250 – 258 . Search in Google Scholar

Field, Heather M. 2017. “Aggressive Tax Planning & the Ethical Tax Lawyer.” Virginia Tax Review 32 (261): 261–322. Field Heather M. 2017 . “Aggressive Tax Planning & the Ethical Tax Lawyer.” Virginia Tax Review 32 ( 261 ): 261 – 322 . Search in Google Scholar

Government Proposal (HE) 16/2018. Hallituksen esitys hallituk-sen esitys eduskunnalle laiksi asiakkaan valinnanvapaudesta sosiaalija terveydenhuollossa ja eräiksi siihen liittyviksi laeiksi [Government proposal to Parliament for an Act on the Client’s Freedom of Choice in Social and Health Care and Certain Related Acts]. Government Proposal (HE) 16/ 2018 . Hallituksen esitys hallituk-sen esitys eduskunnalle laiksi asiakkaan valinnanvapaudesta sosiaalija terveydenhuollossa ja eräiksi siihen liittyviksi laeiksi [Government proposal to Parliament for an Act on the Client’s Freedom of Choice in Social and Health Care and Certain Related Acts] . Search in Google Scholar

Government Proposal (HE) 150/2018. Hallituksen esitys eduskunnalle korkovähennysrajoitusta koskevan sääntelyn muuttamisesta. [Government proposal to Parliament on amending the regulation on the interest deduction limit]. Government Proposal (HE) 150/ 2018 . Hallituksen esitys eduskunnalle korkovähennysrajoitusta koskevan sääntelyn muuttamisesta. [Government proposal to Parliament on amending the regulation on the interest deduction limit] . Search in Google Scholar

Haslehner, Werner and Katerina Pantazatou. 2022. “Assessment of recent anti-tax avoidance and avoidance measures (ATAD & DAC 6). Publication for the Subcommittee on tax matters (FISC), Policy Department for Economic, Scientific and Quality of Life Policies.” European Parliament. Haslehner Werner Katerina Pantazatou . 2022 . “Assessment of recent anti-tax avoidance and avoidance measures (ATAD & DAC 6). Publication for the Subcommittee on tax matters (FISC), Policy Department for Economic, Scientific and Quality of Life Policies.” European Parliament . Search in Google Scholar

Hey, Johanna and Arne Schnitger. 2022. “General report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 106A: Group Approach and separate entity approach in domestic and international tax law, edited by International Fiscal Association, 15–54. International Fiscal Association. Hey Johanna Arne Schnitger . 2022 . “General report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 106A: Group Approach and separate entity approach in domestic and international tax law , edited by International Fiscal Association , 15 – 54 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Hui Lim, Cher. 2017. “Singapore Branch Report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses, edited by International Fiscal Association, 665–698. International Fiscal Association. Hui Lim Cher. 2017 . “Singapore Branch Report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses , edited by International Fiscal Association , 665 – 698 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Hultqvist, Anders. 1995. Legalitetsprincipen vid inkomstbeskattningen [The principle of legality in income taxation]. Juristför-laget. Hultqvist Anders. 1995 . Legalitetsprincipen vid inkomstbeskattnin-gen [The principle of legality in income taxation]. Juristför-laget . Search in Google Scholar

Hultqvist, Anders. 2017. “Sweden.” In Tax Avoidance Revisited in the EU BEPS Context, edited by Ana Paula Dourado, 669–693. IBFD. Hultqvist Anders. 2017 . “Sweden.” In Tax Avoidance Revisited in the EU BEPS Context , edited by Ana Paula Dourado , 669 – 693 . IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

International Tax Review. 2023. “Norwegian Court of Appeal follows EFTA Court’s lead on the interest deduction limitation rule.” 14 September 2023. available at https://www.internat ionaltaxreview.com/article/2c6ugs6g7ebrhk3r36i2o/local-insights/norwegian-court-of-appeal-follows-efta-courts-lead-on-the-interest-deduction-limitation-rule. International Tax Review . 2023 . “Norwegian Court of Appeal follows EFTA Court’s lead on the interest deduction limitation rule.” 14 September 2023 . available at https://www.internationaltaxreview.com/article/2c6ugs6g7ebrhk3r36i2o/local-insights/norwegian-court-of-appeal-follows-efta-courts-lead-on-the-interest-deduction-limitation-rule . Search in Google Scholar

Itälä, Hannu. 2023. “Kannustinosakkeille jaettavan osingon verotus [Taxation of dividends distributed on incentive shares].” Defensor Legis (3): 501–521. Itälä Hannu. 2023 . “Kannustinosakkeille jaettavan osingon verotus [Taxation of dividends distributed on incentive shares].” Defensor Legis ( 3 ): 501 – 521 . Search in Google Scholar

Itälä, Hannu and Reijo Knuutinen. 2023. “The Implementation of ATAD in Finland.” Intertax 51 (12): 851–869. Itälä Hannu Reijo Knuutinen . 2023 . “The Implementation of ATAD in Finland.” Intertax 51 ( 12 ): 851 – 869 . Search in Google Scholar

Jaakkola, Jussi, Matti Ylönen, and Leevi Saari. 2023. “Imaginary capital migration and the competitive politics of corporate taxation.” New Political Economy 28 (1) 2023: 13–28. Jaakkola Jussi Matti Ylönen Leevi Saari . 2023 . “Imaginary capital migration and the competitive politics of corporate taxation.” New Political Economy 28 ( 1 ) 2023 : 13 – 28 . Search in Google Scholar

Kaunisto, Siru. 2022. Veron kiertämisen tunnistaminen – Oikeuden väärinkäytön kielto VML 28 §:n tulkinnassa. [Identifying tax evasion – Prohibition of abuse of rights in the interpretation of Section 28 of the Taxation Act]. Vaasan yliopisto. Kaunisto Siru. 2022 . Veron kiertämisen tunnistaminen – Oikeuden väärinkäytön kielto VML 28 §:n tulkinnassa. [Identifying tax evasion – Prohibition of abuse of rights in the interpretation of Section 28 of the Taxation Act] . Vaasan yliopisto . Search in Google Scholar

Kingma, Sieb. 2020. “Inclusive Global Tax Governance in the Post-BEPS Era.” IBFD. Kingma Sieb. 2020 . “Inclusive Global Tax Governance in the Post-BEPS Era.” IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

Knuutinen, Reijo. 2009. Muoto ja sisältö vero-oikeudessa – erityis-tarkastelussa rahoitusja sijoitusinstrumentit [Form and content in tax law – special attention to financial and investment instruments]. Suomalainen Lakimiesyhdistys. Knuutinen Reijo. 2009 . Muoto ja sisältö vero-oikeudessa – erityis-tarkastelussa rahoitusja sijoitusinstrumentit [Form and content in tax law – special attention to financial and investment instruments] . Suomalainen Lakimiesyhdistys . Search in Google Scholar

Knuutinen, Reijo. 2014. “Verotus ja yrityksen yhteiskuntavastuu [Taxation and corporate social responsibility].” Lakimiesliiton kustannus. Knuutinen Reijo. 2014 . “Verotus ja yrityksen yhteiskuntavastuu [Taxation and corporate social responsibility].” Lakimiesliiton kustannus . Search in Google Scholar

Knuutinen, Reijo. 2015. “Mitä on ns. aggressiivinen verosuunnit-telu? [What is so-called aggressive tax planning?]” Verotus 1: 5–19. Knuutinen Reijo. 2015 . “Mitä on ns. aggressiivinen verosuunnit-telu? [What is so-called aggressive tax planning?]” Verotus 1 : 5 – 19 . Search in Google Scholar

Knuutinen, Reijo. 2020a. Verosuunnittelun oikeudelliset ja yhteiskunnalliset rajat [Legal and social limits of tax planning]. Alma Talent Oy. Knuutinen Reijo. 2020a . Verosuunnittelun oikeudelliset ja yhteiskunnalliset rajat [Legal and social limits of tax planning] . Alma Talent Oy . Search in Google Scholar

Knuutinen, Reijo. 2020b. “Veron kiertamista koskevien yleis-lausekkeiden historiallinen kehitys, soveltamisedellytykset ja soveltamisen pidakkeet eraiden valtioiden kansallisessa vero oikeudessa [Historical development of general tax avoidance clauses, application conditions and limitations in the national tax law of certain countries].” Lakimies 1: 28–54. Knuutinen Reijo . 2020b . “Veron kiertamista koskevien yleis-lausekkeiden historiallinen kehitys, soveltamisedellytykset ja soveltamisen pidakkeet eraiden valtioiden kansallisessa vero oikeudessa [Historical development of general tax avoidance clauses, application conditions and limitations in the national tax law of certain countries].” Lakimies 1 : 28 – 54 . Search in Google Scholar

Knuutinen, Reijo. 2021. “Veron kiertäminen tutkimuskohteena – tutkimuksen näkökulmia, menetelmiä ja suuntauksia koskeva oikeusvertaileva tarkasteltu [Tax evasion as a research topic – a comparative legal review of research perspectives, methods and trends].” Lakimies (7–8): 1136–1164. Knuutinen Reijo. 2021 . “Veron kiertäminen tutkimuskohteena – tutkimuksen näkökulmia, menetelmiä ja suuntauksia koskeva oikeusvertaileva tarkasteltu [Tax evasion as a research topic – a comparative legal review of research perspectives, methods and trends].” Lakimies ( 7–8 ): 1136 – 1164 . Search in Google Scholar

Korving, J.J.A.M. and C. Wisman. 2021. “ATAD Implementation in the Netherlands.” Intertax 49 (11): 917–937. Korving J.J.A.M. C. Wisman . 2021 . “ATAD Implementation in the Netherlands.” Intertax 49 ( 11 ): 917 – 937 . Search in Google Scholar

KPMG. 2024. “BEPS 2.0: State of play.” 17 January 2024. https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2023/04/beps-2-0-state-of-play-april-2023.pdf. Accessed 9 February 2024. KPMG . 2024 . “BEPS 2.0: State of play.” 17 January 2024 . https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/xx/pdf/2023/04/beps-2-0-state-of-play-april-2023.pdf . Accessed 9 February 2024 . Search in Google Scholar

Kraft, Gerhard. 2018. “Germany”. In Cahiers de droit fiscal international vol. 103a: Anti-avoidance measures of general nature and scope – GAAR and other rules, edited by International Fiscal Association, 339–358. International Fiscal Association. Kraft Gerhard. 2018 . “Germany” . In Cahiers de droit fiscal international vol. 103a: Anti-avoidance measures of general nature and scope – GAAR and other rules , edited by International Fiscal Association , 339 – 358 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Krever, Richard. 2020. “Controlled Foreign Company Legislation: General Report.” In Controlled Foreign Company Legislation, edited by Georg Kofler et al., 3–14. IBFD. Krever Richard. 2020 . “Controlled Foreign Company Legislation: General Report.” In Controlled Foreign Company Legislation , edited by Georg Kofler et al. , 3 – 14 . IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

Kuźniacki, Błażej. 2023. “Aggressive Tax Planning in Light of the Securing the Activity Framework of Enablers Initiative: A Path to Inflation of Anti-Tax Avoidance Rules in the EU Law.” International Tax Studies 6 (1): 1–23. Kuźniacki Błażej. 2023 . “Aggressive Tax Planning in Light of the Securing the Activity Framework of Enablers Initiative: A Path to Inflation of Anti-Tax Avoidance Rules in the EU Law.” International Tax Studies 6 ( 1 ): 1 – 23 . Search in Google Scholar

Matteotti, René. 2023. “General report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international vol. 107a: Sharing and shifting of corporate losses – The new profit shifting? Edited by International Fiscal Association, 17–72. International Fiscal Association. Matteotti René. 2023 . “General report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international vol. 107a: Sharing and shifting of corporate losses – The new profit shifting? Edited by International Fiscal Association , 17 – 72 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Nykänen, Pekka. 2021. “Testamentilla saatujen osakkeiden han-kintamenon pidettiin niiden käypää arvoa - Osakkeet eivät olleet perintöverotuksessa veronalaisia eikä osakkeille ollut vahvistettu perintöverotuksessa arvoa. [The acquisition cost of shares received by will was considered to be their fair value - The shares were not subject to inheritance tax and no value had been established for the shares in inheritance tax].” KHO 2021:120. Edilex and Edita Publishing Oy. Nykänen Pekka. 2021 . “Testamentilla saatujen osakkeiden han-kintamenon pidettiin niiden käypää arvoa - Osakkeet eivät olleet perintöverotuksessa veronalaisia eikä osakkeille ollut vahvistettu perintöverotuksessa arvoa. [The acquisition cost of shares received by will was considered to be their fair value - The shares were not subject to inheritance tax and no value had been established for the shares in inheritance tax].” KHO 2021:120. Edilex and Edita Publishing Oy . Search in Google Scholar

Offermanns, René and Boyke Baldewsing. 2015. “Anti-Base-Erosion Measures for Intra-Group Debt Financing.” In International Tax Structures in the BEPS Era: An Analysis of Anti-Abuse Measures, edited by Madeline Court et al., 79–94. IBFD. Offermanns René Boyke Baldewsing . 2015 . “Anti-Base-Erosion Measures for Intra-Group Debt Financing.” In International Tax Structures in the BEPS Era: An Analysis of Anti-Abuse Measures , edited by Madeline Court et al. , 79 – 94 . IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2006. “Third Meeting of the OECD Forum on Tax Administration, 14–15 September 2006, Final Seoul Declaration.” OECD Publishing. OECD . 2006 . “Third Meeting of the OECD Forum on Tax Administration, 14–15 September 2006, Final Seoul Declaration.” OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2008. Study in the Role of Tax Intermediaries. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2008 . Study in the Role of Tax Intermediaries . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2011. Corporate Loss Utilisation through Aggressive Tax Planning. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2011 . Corporate Loss Utilisation through Aggressive Tax Planning . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2013a. Tax Annex to the St. Petersburg G20 Leaders’ Declaration. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2013a . Tax Annex to the St. Petersburg G20 Leaders’ Declaration . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2013b. Action Plan on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2013b . Action Plan on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2014. Addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy, Action 1; 2014 Deliverable. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2014 . Addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy, Action 1; 2014 Deliverable . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2015a. BEPS Action 1 Final Report: Addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2015a . BEPS Action 1 Final Report: Addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2015b. BEPS Action 2 Final Report: Neutralising the Effects of Hybrid Mismatch Arrangements. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2015b . BEPS Action 2 Final Report: Neutralising the Effects of Hybrid Mismatch Arrangements . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD 2015c. BEPS Action 6 Final Report: Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances. OECD Publishing. OECD 2015c . BEPS Action 6 Final Report: Preventing the Granting of Treaty Benefits in Inappropriate Circumstances . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2015d. BEPS Action 12 Final Report: Mandatory Disclosure Rules. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2015d . BEPS Action 12 Final Report: Mandatory Disclosure Rules . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2020. OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework on BEPS: Progress report July 2019 – July 2020. OECD. OECD . 2020 . OECD/G20 Inclusive Framework on BEPS: Progress report July 2019 – July 2020 . OECD . Search in Google Scholar

OECD. 2021. OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project: Two-Pillar Solution to Address the Tax Challenges Arising from the Digitalisation of the Economy, October 2021. OECD Publishing. OECD . 2021 . OECD/G20 Base Erosion and Profit Shifting Project: Two-Pillar Solution to Address the Tax Challenges Arising from the Digitalisation of the Economy , October 2021 . OECD Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

Pantazatou, Katerina. 2022. “The Implementation of the ATAD in Luxembourg.” Intertax 50 (1): 56–65. Pantazatou Katerina. 2022 . “The Implementation of the ATAD in Luxembourg.” Intertax 50 ( 1 ): 56 – 65 . Search in Google Scholar

Perdelwitz, Andreas. 2018. “Chapter 15: Developing a Common Framework against Tax Avoidance in the European Union.” In the Implementation of Anti-BEPS Rules in the EU: A Comprehensive Study, edited by Pasquale Pistone and Dennis Weber. IBFD. Perdelwitz Andreas. 2018 . “Chapter 15: Developing a Common Framework against Tax Avoidance in the European Union.” In the Implementation of Anti-BEPS Rules in the EU: A Comprehensive Study , edited by Pasquale Pistone and Dennis Weber . IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

Picciotto, Sol, Agustina Gallardo, Jeffery Kadet, Markus Henn, and Maria Villanueva. 2017. “Discussion Paper 18/2017: The G20 and the “Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Project.” Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik. Picciotto Sol Agustina Gallardo Jeffery Kadet Markus Henn Maria Villanueva . 2017 . “Discussion Paper 18/2017: The G20 and the “Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Project.” Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik . Search in Google Scholar

Piantavigna, Paolo. 2017. “Tax Competition and Tax Coordination in Aggressive Tax Planning: A False Dichotomy.” World Tax Journal 9 (4): 477–519. Piantavigna Paolo. 2017 . “Tax Competition and Tax Coordination in Aggressive Tax Planning: A False Dichotomy.” World Tax Journal 9 ( 4 ): 477 – 519 . Search in Google Scholar

Pistone, Pasquale. 2017. “The Meaning of Tax Avoidance and Aggressive Tax Planning in European Union Tax Law: Some Thoughts in Connection with the Reaction to Such Practices by the European Union.” In Tax Avoidance Revisited in the EU BEPS Context, edited by Ana Paula Dourado, 73–100. IBFD. Pistone Pasquale. 2017 . “The Meaning of Tax Avoidance and Aggressive Tax Planning in European Union Tax Law: Some Thoughts in Connection with the Reaction to Such Practices by the European Union.” In Tax Avoidance Revisited in the EU BEPS Context , edited by Ana Paula Dourado , 73 – 100 . IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

Pistone, Pasquale, Jennifer Roeleveld, Johann Hattingh, Nogueira Pinto, Félix João and Craig West. 2019. “Fundamentals of Taxation: An Introduction to Tax Policy, Tax Law and Tax Administration.” IBFD. Pistone Pasquale Jennifer Roeleveld Johann Hattingh Nogueira Pinto Félix João Craig West . 2019 . “Fundamentals of Taxation: An Introduction to Tax Policy, Tax Law and Tax Administration.” IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

Prebble, John. 1994. “Why is tax law incomprehensible?” British Tax Review 4: 380–393. Prebble John. 1994 . “Why is tax law incomprehensible?” British Tax Review 4 : 380 – 393 . Search in Google Scholar

Prebble, John and Shanske, Darien. 2022. “Legal Positivism and Tax Law: Kelsen, Is/Ought and Capital/Revenue; Hart, Open Texture and GAARs”. In Political Philosophy and Taxation: A History from the Enlightenment to the Present, edited by Robert F. van Brederode, 281–303. Springer Nature Singapore Pte, Ltd. Prebble John Shanske Darien. 2022 . “Legal Positivism and Tax Law: Kelsen, Is/Ought and Capital/Revenue; Hart, Open Texture and GAARs” . In Political Philosophy and Taxation: A History from the Enlightenment to the Present , edited by Robert F. van Brederode , 281 – 303 . Springer Nature Singapore Pte, Ltd . Search in Google Scholar

Reimer, Ekkehart. 2017. “Chapter 15: Germany.” In Tax Avoidance Revisited in the EU BEPS Context, edited by Ana Paula Dourado, 343–384. IBFD. Reimer Ekkehart. 2017 . “Chapter 15: Germany.” In Tax Avoidance Revisited in the EU BEPS Context , edited by Ana Paula Dourado , 343 – 384 . IBFD . Search in Google Scholar

Rosander, Ulrika. 2007. “Generalklausul mot skatteflykt [General clause against tax evasion].” JIBS Dissertation Series (040). Jönköping. Rosander Ulrika. 2007 . “Generalklausul mot skatteflykt [General clause against tax evasion].” JIBS Dissertation Series ( 040 ). Jönköping . Search in Google Scholar

Roth, Randall W. 1983. "New Penalty Provisions and Their Effect on Aggressive Tax Planning."Taxes 61 (1): 52–58. Roth Randall W. 1983 . "New Penalty Provisions and Their Effect on Aggressive Tax Planning." Taxes 61 ( 1 ): 52 – 58 . Search in Google Scholar

Rust, Alexander. 2020. “Controlled Foreign Company Rule (Article 7 and 8 ATAD).” In a Guide to the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive, edited by Werner Haslehner, Katerina Pantazatou, Georg Kofler, and Alexander Rust, 174–199. Edward Elgar Publishing. Rust Alexander. 2020 . “Controlled Foreign Company Rule (Article 7 and 8 ATAD).” In a Guide to the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive , edited by Werner Haslehner, Katerina Pantazatou, Georg Kofler, and Alexander Rust , 174 – 199 . Edward Elgar Publishing . Search in Google Scholar

Schizer, David M. 2000. “Sticks and Snakes: Derivatives and Curtailing Aggressive Tax Planning."Southern California Law Review (73): 1339–1406. Schizer David M. 2000 . “Sticks and Snakes: Derivatives and Curtailing Aggressive Tax Planning."Southern California Law Review ( 73 ): 1339 – 1406 . Search in Google Scholar

Schusterreiter, Ricarda. 2017. “Liechtenstein Branch Report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses, edited by International Fiscal Association, 483–496. International Fiscal Association. Schusterreiter Ricarda. 2017 . “Liechtenstein Branch Report.” In Cahiers de droit fiscal international Vol. 102A: Assessing BEPS: origins, standards and responses , edited by International Fiscal Association , 483 – 496 . International Fiscal Association . Search in Google Scholar

Thuronyi, Victor. 1990. ”The Concept of Income.” Tax Law Review 46 (1): 45–105. Thuronyi Victor. 1990 . ”The Concept of Income.” Tax Law Review 46 ( 1 ): 45 – 105 . Search in Google Scholar

Tikka, Kari S. 1972. ”Veron minimoinnista.” Suomalainen Lakimiesyhdistys. Tikka Kari S. 1972 . ”Veron minimoinnista.” Suomalainen Lakimiesyhdistys . Search in Google Scholar

Tikka, Kari S. 1998. ”Legaliteettiperiaatteesta verolain soveltamisessa.” In Juhlakirja – Kaarlo Tuori 50 vuotta, edited by Paul van Aerschot, Paula Ilveskivi and Kirsi Piispanen, 71–80. Helsingin yliopisto. Tikka Kari S. 1998 . ”Legaliteettiperiaatteesta verolain soveltamisessa.” In Juhlakirja – Kaarlo Tuori 50 vuotta , edited by Paul van Aerschot, Paula Ilveskivi and Kirsi Piispanen , 71 – 80 . Helsingin yliopisto . Search in Google Scholar

Tokola, Antti and Martikainen, Tomi. 2021. “Väliyhteisölain on-gelmakohdat – Oikeusvertaileva selvitys lain toimivuudesta ja lakimuutosten vaikutuksista.” Harmaan talouden selvitysyk-sikön selvitys 2/2021. Tokola Antti Martikainen Tomi. 2021 . “Väliyhteisölain on-gelmakohdat – Oikeusvertaileva selvitys lain toimivuudesta ja lakimuutosten vaikutuksista.” Harmaan talouden selvitysyk-sikön selvitys 2/ 2021 . Search in Google Scholar

VM. 2017. ”BEPS-toimenpiteiden taloudellisten vaikutusten arviointiraportti.” Valtiovarainministeriön julkaisu – 26/2017. VM . 2017 . ”BEPS-toimenpiteiden taloudellisten vaikutusten arviointiraportti.” Valtiovarainministeriön julkaisu – 26/ 2017 . Search in Google Scholar

Veikkola, Elisa. 2023. ”Komission ehdotus kuoriyhtiödirektiiviksi – ehdotetun sääntelyn EU-oikeudenmukaisuus.” Edilex (22), available at www.edilex.fi/artikkelit/31128. Veikkola Elisa. 2023 . ”Komission ehdotus kuoriyhtiödirektiiviksi – ehdotetun sääntelyn EU-oikeudenmukaisuus.” Edilex ( 22 ), available at www.edilex.fi/artikkelit/31128 . Search in Google Scholar

Villa, Seppo. 2008. ”KHO 2008:6; Tulon veronalaisuus - Osinkotulo - Erilajiset osakesarjat - Yhtiöjärjestys. Kommentti.” Defensor Legis (2): 297–315. Villa Seppo. 2008 . ”KHO 2008:6; Tulon veronalaisuus - Osinkotulo - Erilajiset osakesarjat - Yhtiöjärjestys. Kommentti.” Defensor Legis ( 2 ): 297 – 315 . Search in Google Scholar