From top-down to people-centred urban recovery: a Beirut case study

Al-Harithy, H & Yassine, B 2023, ‘The co-production of a shared community space in Al-Khodor, Karantina, in the aftermath of the Beirut port blast’, Land 2023, vol. 12, no.7. Al-HarithyH YassineB 2023 ‘The co-production of a shared community space in Al-Khodor, Karantina, in the aftermath of the Beirut port blast’ Land 2023 12 7 Search in Google Scholar

Al-Harithy, H, Yassine, B, Bazzi, M, Cheaitli, A, El Chamaa, M, Ghaddar, A, Haddad, W, El-Jazzar, Ch, Tarhini S, Gosen, C & Shayya, R 2021, ‘Descriptive memory’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina, ed. A El-Tayeb, Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/196~BUL_Karantina_Descriptive_Memory-compressed-22-7-24.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Al-HarithyH YassineB BazziM CheaitliA El ChamaaM GhaddarA HaddadW El-JazzarCh TarhiniS GosenC ShayyaR 2021 ‘Descriptive memory’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina ed El-TayebA Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/196~BUL_Karantina_Descriptive_Memory-compressed-22-7-24.pdf>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Al-Harithy, H, Yassine, B, Bazzi, M, Cheaitli, A, El Chamaa, M, Ghaddar, A, Haddad, W, El-Jazzar, Ch, Tarhini S, Gosen, C & Shayya, R 2022a, ‘Strategic Diagnosis’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina, ed. A El-Tayeb, Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/191~BUL_Karantina_Strategic_Diagnosis-compressed.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Al-HarithyH YassineB BazziM CheaitliA El ChamaaM GhaddarA HaddadW El-JazzarCh TarhiniS GosenC ShayyaR 2022a ‘Strategic Diagnosis’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina ed. El-TayebA Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/191~BUL_Karantina_Strategic_Diagnosis-compressed.pdf>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Al-Harithy, H, Yassine, B, Bazzi, M, Cheaitli, A, El Chamaa, M, Ghaddar, A, Haddad, W, El-Jazzar, Ch, Tarhini S, Gosen, C & Shayya, R 2022b, ‘Strategic Framework’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina, ed. A El-Tayeb, Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/430~3-BUL_Karantina_Strategic_Framework-min.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Al-HarithyH YassineB BazziM CheaitliA El ChamaaM GhaddarA HaddadW El-JazzarCh TarhiniS GosenC ShayyaR 2022b ‘Strategic Framework’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina ed. El-TayebA Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/430~3-BUL_Karantina_Strategic_Framework-min.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Al-Harithy, H, Yassine, B, Bazzi, M, Cheaitli, A, El Chamaa, M, Ghaddar, A, Haddad, W, El-Jazzar, Ch, Tarhini S, Gosen, C & Shayya, R 2022c, ‘Action plans’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina, ed. A El-Tayeb, Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/523~4-BUL_Karantina_Action_Plans-min.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Al-HarithyH YassineB BazziM CheaitliA El ChamaaM GhaddarA HaddadW El-JazzarCh TarhiniS GosenC ShayyaR 2022c ‘Action plans’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina ed. El-TayebA Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/523~4-BUL_Karantina_Action_Plans-min.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Al-Harithy, H, Yassine, B, Bazzi, M, Cheaitli, A, El Chamaa, M, Ghaddar, A, Haddad, W, El-Jazzar, Ch, Tarhini S, Gosen, C & Shayya, R 2023, ‘Monitoring and indicator systems’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina, ed. A El-Tayeb, Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/917~Indicator-systems-draft-3.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Al-HarithyH YassineB BazziM CheaitliA El ChamaaM GhaddarA HaddadW El-JazzarCh TarhiniS GosenC ShayyaR 2023 ‘Monitoring and indicator systems’ in An Urban Recovery Strategy for Post-Blast Karantina ed. El-TayebA Beirut Urban Lab Report. Available from: <http://api.beiruturbanlab.com/content/uploads/articles/917~Indicator-systems-draft-3.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Al-Harithy, H & Yassine, B 2024, ‘A people-centered urban recovery strategy for Karantina (Beirut, Lebanon) in the aftermath of the Beirut port blast’, Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Natural Hazard Science 2024. Available from: <https://oxfordre.com/>. [28 October 2024]. Al-HarithyH YassineB 2024 ‘A people-centered urban recovery strategy for Karantina (Beirut, Lebanon) in the aftermath of the Beirut port blast’ Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Natural Hazard Science 2024 Available from: <https://oxfordre.com/>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Badescu, G 2017, ‘Post-war reconstruction in contested cities: Comparing urban outcomes in Sarajevo and Beirut’, in Urban Geopolitics, eds J Rokem & C Boano, Routledge, London, pp. 17–31 BadescuG 2017 ‘Post-war reconstruction in contested cities: Comparing urban outcomes in Sarajevo and Beirut’, in Urban Geopolitics eds RokemJ BoanoC Routledge London 17 31 Search in Google Scholar

Baecker, D 2013, ‘Mapping a city onto itself: A note on the reconstruction of Beirut Central District’, SSRN Electronic Journal, article number 2229687. Available from: <https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2229687>. [28 October 2024]. BaeckerD 2013 ‘Mapping a city onto itself: A note on the reconstruction of Beirut Central District’ SSRN Electronic Journal article number 2229687. Available from: <https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2229687>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Beirut Urban Lab 2023a, The Mar Mikhael Square Project. Beirut. Available from: <https://beiruturbanlab.com/en/Details/1931>. [28 October 2024]. Beirut Urban Lab 2023a The Mar Mikhael Square Project Beirut Available from: <https://beiruturbanlab.com/en/Details/1931>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Beirut Urban Lab 2023b, Petition to Support the Public Square Project at the intersections of rue Gouraud, Armenia, and Pasteur in Gemmayze/Mar Mikhael. Beirut. Available from: <https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSewYmNttIPKkOxh7SwMZgg3miHZ5k8STibGpNfcHpWgdkakHQ/viewform>. [28 October 2024]. Beirut Urban Lab 2023b Petition to Support the Public Square Project at the intersections of rue Gouraud, Armenia, and Pasteur in Gemmayze/Mar Mikhael Beirut Available from: <https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSewYmNttIPKkOxh7SwMZgg3miHZ5k8STibGpNfcHpWgdkakHQ/viewform>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Beirut Urban Lab & ACTED 2021, Mar Mikhael urban Snapshot, Working document. Beirut. Available from: <https://www.acted.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/urban-snapshot-mar-mikhael-2021-06-02-final.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Beirut Urban Lab & ACTED 2021 Mar Mikhael urban Snapshot Working document. Beirut. Available from: <https://www.acted.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/urban-snapshot-mar-mikhael-2021-06-02-final.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Beirut Urban Lab, URBI, Beirut Heritage Initiative & Live Love Lebanon 2021, Al-Masar al-Akhdar. Beirut. Available from: <https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/1ac6e923b079489b88c5a74a89f27bf6>. [28 October 2024]. Beirut Urban Lab, URBI, Beirut Heritage Initiative & Live Love Lebanon 2021 Al-Masar al-Akhdar Beirut Available from: <https://experience.arcgis.com/experience/1ac6e923b079489b88c5a74a89f27bf6>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

El Khoury, R & Ardizzola, P 2021, ‘From the Port City of Beirut to Beirut Central District: Narratives of destruction and reconstructions’, SPOOL, vol.8, no.1, pp. 5–22. El KhouryR ArdizzolaP 2021 ‘From the Port City of Beirut to Beirut Central District: Narratives of destruction and reconstructions’ SPOOL 8 1 5 22 Search in Google Scholar

Fawaz, M & Harb, M 2020, Is Lebanon becoming another “Republic of the NGOs”? Beirut. Available from: <https://beiruturbanlab.com/en/Details/697/is-lebanon-becoming-another-republic-for-ngos>. [28 October 2024]. FawazM HarbM 2020 Is Lebanon becoming another “Republic of the NGOs”? Beirut Available from: <https://beiruturbanlab.com/en/Details/697/is-lebanon-becoming-another-republic-for-ngos>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Hadžimuhamedović, A 2018, ‘Culture-based urban resilience: post-war recovery of Sarajevo’, UNESCO, World Heritage Convention. Sarajevo. Available from: <https://www.academia.edu/40157140/Culture_based_urban_resilience_post_war_recovery_of_Sarajevo>. [28 October 2024]. HadžimuhamedovićA 2018 ‘Culture-based urban resilience: post-war recovery of Sarajevo’ UNESCO, World Heritage Convention Sarajevo Available from: <https://www.academia.edu/40157140/Culture_based_urban_resilience_post_war_recovery_of_Sarajevo>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Jabri, L 2023, ‘Mobilizing ordinary people for the sake of the environment: Challenges of urban activists within clientelistic conditions in Lebanon’, Les Cahiers de la recherche architecturale urbaine et paysagère, vol. 2023, no.17, pp. 40–67. Available from: <https://journals.openedition.org/craup/12116?lang=en>. [28 October 2024]. JabriL 2023 ‘Mobilizing ordinary people for the sake of the environment: Challenges of urban activists within clientelistic conditions in Lebanon’ Les Cahiers de la recherche architecturale urbaine et paysagère 2023 17 40 67 Available from: <https://journals.openedition.org/craup/12116?lang=en>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Kellett, P & El-Masri, S 2001, ‘Post-war reconstruction. Participatory approaches to rebuilding the damaged villages of Lebanon: a case study of al-Burjain’, Habitat International, vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 535–557. KellettP El-MasriS 2001 ‘Post-war reconstruction. Participatory approaches to rebuilding the damaged villages of Lebanon: a case study of al-Burjain’ Habitat International 25 4 535 557 Search in Google Scholar

Khalaf, S & Khoury, P 1993, Recovering Beirut. Urban design and post-war reconstruction, Brill Publisher, Leiden. KhalafS KhouryP 1993 Recovering Beirut. Urban design and post-war reconstruction Brill Publisher Leiden Search in Google Scholar

Khodor, A & Mrad, EA 2022, ‘Beirut Port reconstruction. An integral participatory urban strategy - Phase 1’, Project Brief & Planning Directives report. Beirut. Available from: <https://www.academia.edu/80681565/Beirut_Port_Reconstruction_Integrated_Participatory_Urban_Strategy_Phase_1_Project_Brief_and_Planning_Directives_report>. [28 October 2024]. KhodorA MradEA 2022 ‘Beirut Port reconstruction. An integral participatory urban strategy - Phase 1’ Project Brief & Planning Directives report Beirut Available from: <https://www.academia.edu/80681565/Beirut_Port_Reconstruction_Integrated_Participatory_Urban_Strategy_Phase_1_Project_Brief_and_Planning_Directives_report>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Van der Krabben, E, Piyush, T & Jyoti, S 2020, ‘Land use management strategies for equitable infrastructure and urban development: Overview of strategies and tools’, ADBI Working Paper Series, no. 1191. Tokyo. Available from: <https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/648256/adbi-wp1191.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Van der KrabbenE PiyushT JyotiS 2020 ‘Land use management strategies for equitable infrastructure and urban development: Overview of strategies and tools’ ADBI Working Paper Series 1191 Tokyo Available from: <https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/648256/adbi-wp1191.pdf>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Mango, T 2004, Solidere: The battle for Beirut’s Central District. Master thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. MangoT 2004 Solidere: The battle for Beirut’s Central District Master thesis Massachusetts Institute of Technology Search in Google Scholar

Pilav, A 2018, ‘Collective documenting of extreme urban transformations evidence of urban resilience during the war in Sarajevo (1992–1996)’ in Architecture and Resilience: Interdisciplinary Dialogues, eds K Trogal, I Bauman, R Lawrence & D Petrescu, Routhledge, London, pp. 17–31. PilavA 2018 ‘Collective documenting of extreme urban transformations evidence of urban resilience during the war in Sarajevo (1992–1996)’ in Architecture and Resilience: Interdisciplinary Dialogues eds TrogalK BaumanI LawrenceR PetrescuD Routhledge London 17 31 Search in Google Scholar

Piplas, H, Klumper, H & Brillembourg, A (eds) 2019, City action lab – integrated urban toolbox for post-socialist Central and Eastern European cities, Zurich: ETH Zurich, Chair of Architecture and Urban Design; Network City and Landscape. PiplasH KlumperH BrillembourgA (eds) 2019 City action lab – integrated urban toolbox for post-socialist Central and Eastern European cities Zurich ETH Zurich, Chair of Architecture and Urban Design; Network City and Landscape Search in Google Scholar

Ragab, T 2011, ‘The crisis of cultural identity in rehabilitating historic Beirut-downtown’, Cities, vol. 28, no.1, pp.107–114. RagabT 2011 ‘The crisis of cultural identity in rehabilitating historic Beirut-downtown’ Cities 28 1 107 114 Search in Google Scholar

Ragette, F 1983, Beirut of tomorrow: Planning for reconstruction, American University of Beirut Press, Beirut. RagetteF 1983 Beirut of tomorrow: Planning for reconstruction American University of Beirut Press Beirut Search in Google Scholar

Sanderson, D 2023, ‘Identifying opportunities to build resilience in urban disaster recovery’ in Integrative Approaches in Urban Sustainability - Architectural Design, Technological Innovations and Social Dynamics in Global Contexts, eds A Amjad, A Almssad, I Yitmen, M Wallhagen & YF Yang, Sustainable Development, Intech Open, pp. 45–57 SandersonD 2023 ‘Identifying opportunities to build resilience in urban disaster recovery’ in Integrative Approaches in Urban Sustainability - Architectural Design, Technological Innovations and Social Dynamics in Global Contexts eds AmjadA AlmssadA YitmenI WallhagenM YangYF Sustainable Development, Intech Open 45 57 Search in Google Scholar

Schilderman, T 2010, ‘Putting people at the centre of reconstruction’ in Building Back Better, Rugby, Practical Action Publishing Ltd, pp. 7–37. SchildermanT 2010 ‘Putting people at the centre of reconstruction’ in Building Back Better Rugby, Practical Action Publishing Ltd 7 37 Search in Google Scholar

Solidere 2014, Solidere annual report. The Lebanese company for the development of Beirut Central District. Available from: <https://www.solidere.com/sites/default/files/attached/solidere_consolidated_fs_2014.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Solidere 2014 Solidere annual report. The Lebanese company for the development of Beirut Central District Available from: <https://www.solidere.com/sites/default/files/attached/solidere_consolidated_fs_2014.pdf>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Solidere 2004, Beirut City Center. developing the finest city center in the Middle East. Available from: <https://www.solidere.com/sites/default/files/attached/cr-brochure.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Solidere 2004 Beirut City Center. developing the finest city center in the Middle East Available from: <https://www.solidere.com/sites/default/files/attached/cr-brochure.pdf>. [28 October 2024]. Search in Google Scholar

Stop the Highway, Build the Fouad Boutros Park 2014a, An obsolete plan from the 1950’s. March 2, 2014: blog. Available from: <https://stopthehighway.wordpress.com/thehekmeh-turk-fouad-boutros-project/an-obsolete-plan-from-the-1950s/>. [28 October 2024]. Stop the Highway, Build the Fouad Boutros Park 2014a An obsolete plan from the 1950’s March 2, 2014: blog. Available from: <https://stopthehighway.wordpress.com/thehekmeh-turk-fouad-boutros-project/an-obsolete-plan-from-the-1950s/>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Stop the Highway, Build the Fouad Boutros Park 2014b, The petition. February 24, 2014: blog. Available from: <https://stopthehighway.wordpress.com/the-petition/>. [28 October 2024]. Stop the Highway, Build the Fouad Boutros Park 2014b The petition February 24, 2014: blog. Available from: <https://stopthehighway.wordpress.com/the-petition/>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Verdeil, É 2005, ‘Plans for an unplanned city: Beirut (1950–2000)’, Worldview. Perspectives on Architecture and Urbanism from around the World. Available from: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280757236_Plans_for_an_unplanned_city_Beirut_1950-2000>. [28 October 2024]. VerdeilÉ 2005 ‘Plans for an unplanned city: Beirut (1950–2000)’ Worldview. Perspectives on Architecture and Urbanism from around the World Available from: <https://www.researchgate.net/publication/280757236_Plans_for_an_unplanned_city_Beirut_1950-2000>. [28 October 2024] Search in Google Scholar

Interview A – anonymous, historian, online, February 2023 Interview A – anonymous, historian online February 2023 Search in Google Scholar

Interview B – anonymous, urban planner, Beirut, July 2023 and 2024 Interview B – anonymous, urban planner Beirut July 2023 and 2024 Search in Google Scholar

Interview C – anonymous, taxi driver, Beirut, August 2023 Interview C – anonymous, taxi driver Beirut August 2023 Search in Google Scholar

Interview D – anonymous, architect and urban planner, Beirut, July 2023 Interview D – anonymous, architect and urban planner Beirut July 2023 Search in Google Scholar

Interview E – anonymous, researcher and urban planner, Beirut, July 2023 Interview E – anonymous, researcher and urban planner Beirut July 2023 Search in Google Scholar