<abstract xml:lang="en" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"><p>Wing lengths of nestlings of Great Tit <italic>Parus major</italic>, Blue Tit <italic>P. caeruleus</italic> and Pied Flycatcher <italic>Ficedula hypoleuca</italic> measured by one observer (WK) were compared with the measurements taken concurrently by one of 30 other observers. In total 1321 pairs of measurements were analysed. The differences between the measurers were found to: (1) depend on wing length; (2) vary between distinct wing-length classes and species; (3) be bigger in the case of inexperienced measurers (4) be small, only exceeding ± 1 mm in 7% cases and ± 2 mm in 0.5% cases. Such small measurement errors did not significantly bias the wing-length-based age estimation. The average differences between the age estimates derived from wing length taken by WK and other experienced measurers ranged from -0.3 to +0.3 day for various measurers, species and wing-length classes when 1-3 day-old nestlings (1-5 day-old in Blue Tit) were excluded. For the latter nestlings as well as for inexperienced measurers that range was -0.4-. +0.8 day.</p></abstract>

Wing lengths of nestlings of Great Tit Parus major, Blue Tit P. caeruleus and Pied Flycatcher Ficedula hypoleuca measured by one observer (WK) were compared with the measurements taken concurrently by one of 30 other observers. In total 1321 pairs of measurements were analysed. The differences between the measurers were found to: (1) depend on wing length; (2) vary between distinct wing-length classes and species; (3) be bigger in the case of inexperienced measurers (4) be small, only exceeding ± 1 mm in 7% cases and ± 2 mm in 0.5% cases. Such small measurement errors did not significantly bias the wing-length-based age estimation. The average differences between the age estimates derived from wing length taken by WK and other experienced measurers ranged from -0.3 to +0.3 day for various measurers, species and wing-length classes when 1-3 day-old nestlings (1-5 day-old in Blue Tit) were excluded. For the latter nestlings as well as for inexperienced measurers that range was -0.4-. +0.8 day.

Observer error in measurements of nestling wing length in small passerines

Institute for Ornithology, Polish Academy of Sciences, PL-80-680 Gdańsk 40, Poland

The Ring

{"article-title":"Observer error in measurements of nestling wing length in small passerines"}

Wing lengths of nestlings of Great Tit Parus major, Blue Tit P. caeruleus and Pied Flycatcher Ficedula hypoleuca measured by one observer (WK) were compared...

Observer error in measurements of nestling wing length in small passerines

Publié en ligne: 09 mars 2010

Pages: 79 - 87

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/v10050-008-0066-2

Mots clés
wing length, nestling age, observer error, measurer bias, Great Tit, Blue Tit, Pied Flycatcher,

This content is open access.

Observer error in measurements of nestling wing length in small passerines

Publié en ligne: 09 mars 2010

Pages: 79 - 87

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/v10050-008-0066-2

Mots cléswing length, nestling age, observer error, measurer bias, Great Tit, Blue Tit, Pied Flycatcher,

This content is open access.

Mots clés
wing length, nestling age, observer error, measurer bias, Great Tit, Blue Tit, Pied Flycatcher,