1. bookVolume 14 (2021): Edition 2 (December 2021)
Détails du magazine
License
Format
Magazine
eISSN
1338-4309
Première parution
03 Aug 2009
Périodicité
2 fois par an
Langues
Anglais
access type Accès libre

Rapid Public-Private Partnership Deployment in Kazakhstan: Enablers and Implications

Publié en ligne: 02 Dec 2021
Volume & Edition: Volume 14 (2021) - Edition 2 (December 2021)
Pages: 189 - 221
Détails du magazine
License
Format
Magazine
eISSN
1338-4309
Première parution
03 Aug 2009
Périodicité
2 fois par an
Langues
Anglais
Abstract

Public-private partnerships (PPPs) are a relatively new phenomenon in Kazakh-stan – their development began in 2005 in the transport and energy sectors. Initially sluggish growth transformed into rapid PPP deployment from 2016 to 2019 when hundreds of PPPs were launched in many industries (infrastructure, hospitals, schools), which was in sharp contrast to just a handful of PPPs formed prior to 2016. Rapid PPP deployment raised deep concerns whether the government’s supporting schemes and PPP launch procedures are appropriate and whether they may backfire for the government in the form of increasing debt. This paper aims to investigate the enablers and implications of accelerated PPP formation. The study is based on semi-structured in-depth interviews with a range of actors in the field, including PPP operators (railroad, energy company, kindergarten), regional and local governments, national and regional PPP centres, lawyers and private investors, which afforded an opportunity to mitigate bias in opinions. The study has identified three principal enablers: simplified procedures for a PPP launch, pressure exerted on regional governments, and extensive government financial support to PPPs. By making use of agency theory, property rights theory and the value-for-money concept, the paper offers a conceptualisation of rapid PPP growth in Kazakhstan in recent years and argues that growth was disproportionally fast and unintended. Policy implications include a need to re-establish the value-for-money approach to PPP formation, a significant increase in government liabilities to PPPs, and a misconception regarding the role of PPP collaborative governance.

Keywords

Akintoye, A., M. Beck and C. Hardcastle (eds). 2003. Public-Private Partnerships: Managing Risks and Opportunities. Oxford: Blackwell Science.10.1002/9780470690703 Search in Google Scholar

Alam, Q., M. H. Kabir and V. Chaudhri. 2014. “Managing Infrastructure Projects in Australia: A Shift from a Contractual to a Collaborative Public Management Strategy.” Administration and Society 46(4), 422 – 449. Search in Google Scholar

Alchian, A. A. and H. Demsetz. 1973. “The Property Right Paradigm.” Journal of Economic History 33, 16 – 27. Search in Google Scholar

Arrow, K. 1985. “The Economics of Agency.” In J. Pratt and R. Zeckhauser (eds). Principals and Agents: The Structure of Business. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 37 – 51. Search in Google Scholar

Atameken. 2019. PPP Project Financing: Issues and Suggestions to Address them. A presentation. Available at https://forum.kzppp.kz/uploads/calendar/14/file3/3.%20Yakupbayeva%20Yulia.pdf?cache=1573484612 (last accessed 14 May 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Atkinson, R. and J. Flint. 2004. “Snowball Sampling.” In M. S. Lewis-Beck, A. Bryman and L. F. Liao (eds). The SAGE Encyclopaedia of Social Science Research Methods. London: Sage, 245 – 261. Search in Google Scholar

Azizov, A. 2009. “Opportunities for Concessions in the Time of Crisis” [in Russian]. Korporativniy Yurist 5, 1 – 3. Search in Google Scholar

Boardman, A. and A. Vining. 2010. “Assessing the Economic Worth of Public-Private Partnerships.” In G. A. Hodge, C. Greve and A. Boardman (eds). International Handbook on Public-Private Partnerships. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 159 – 186. Search in Google Scholar

Charman, K. and T. Narbaev. 2017. “The Formation and Management of Public-Private Partnerships in Kazakhstan.” In N. Mouraviev and N. Kakabadse (eds). Public-Private Partnerships in Transitional Nations: Policy, Governance and Praxis. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 109 – 126. Search in Google Scholar

Chikanayev, S. 2015. “Kazakhstan.” In B. Werneck and M. Saadi (eds). The Public-Private Partnership Law Review. London: Law Business Research Ltd, 144 – 165. Search in Google Scholar

Chikanayev, S. 2017. “A Public-Private Partnership Agreement as a New Kind of an Agreement in Kazakhstan’s Civil Law and the Problems of its Categorisation” [in Russian]. Kaspiyskiy Obschestvenniy Universitet. Research publications series Adilet 3. Available at https://online.zakon.kz/Document/?doc_id=39697495#pos=36;70 (last accessed 27 January 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Chikanayev, S. 2019a. PPP Boom in Kazakhstan. Available at https://www.mondaq.com/government-contracts-procurement-ppp/876920/ppp-boom-in-kazakhstan (last accessed 27 January 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Chikanayev, S. 2019b. Kazakhstan: Opportunities for PPPs in 2019. Available at https://gratanet.com/storage/specialization_uploaded_files/PofAiQONhK-vDl9KHhgN5Gvgke1berpzSrOlPvjZ7.pdf (last accessed 16 February 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Chikanayev, S. 2019c. “Uncontrolled Growth of ‘Fake’ PPPs in Kazakhstan: What to Expect ?” Islamic Finance News 16(17), 4 – 5. Search in Google Scholar

Coase, R. H. 1960. “The Problem of Social Cost.” Journal of Law and Economics 3, 1 – 44. Search in Google Scholar

Colman, J. 2000. “Examining the Value for Money of Deals under the Private Finance Initiative / Public Private Partnership.” Public Policy and Administration 15(4), 71 – 81. Search in Google Scholar

Creswell, J. W. and C. N. Poth. 2018. Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing among Five Approaches. 4th edn. Los Angeles: Sage. Search in Google Scholar

Delmon, J. 2013. Public-Private Partnership Projects in Infrastructure: An Essential Guide for Policy Makers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Denzin, N. K. and Y. S. Lincoln (eds.). 2008. The Landscape of Qualitative Research. 3rd edn. London: Sage. Search in Google Scholar

Dewulf, G., A. Blanken and M. Bult-Spiering. 2012. Strategic Issues in Public-Private Partnerships. 2nd edn. Chichester: Wiley Blackwell.10.1002/9781119968306 Search in Google Scholar

Fauve, A. 2015. “Global Astana: Nation Branding as a Legitimization Tool for Authoritarian Regimes.” Central Asian Survey 34(1), 110 – 124. Search in Google Scholar

Federal Law #115-FZ of the Russian Federation “On Concessionary Agreements” [in Russian]. 2005. Available at http://www.rg.ru/2005/07/26/koncessii-dok.html (last accessed 29 September 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Firsova, A. A. 2012. Theory and Methodology for Investment in Innovation using Public-Private Partnerships [in Russian]. Saratov: Saratov State University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Flick, U. 2018. An Introduction to Qualitative Research. 6th edn. London: Sage.10.4135/9781529716641 Search in Google Scholar

Flyvbjerg, B. (ed.). 2017. The Oxford Handbook of Megaproject Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198732242.001.0001 Search in Google Scholar

Furstenberg, S. 2018. “State Responses to Reputational Concerns: The Case of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative in Kazakhstan.” Central Asian Survey. doi:10.1080/02634937.2018.1428789.10.1080/02634937.2018.1428789 Search in Google Scholar

Greve, C. and G. Hodge (eds). 2013. Rethinking Public-Private Partnerships: Strategies for Turbulent Times. Abingdon: Routledge.10.4324/9780203108130 Search in Google Scholar

Grimsey, D. and M. K. Lewis. 2004. Public Private Partnerships: The Worldwide Revolution in Infrastructure Provision and Project Finance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.10.4337/9781845423438 Search in Google Scholar

Grossman, S. and O. Hart. 1986. “The Costs and Benefits of Ownership: A Theory of Vertical Integration and Lateral Integration.” Journal of Political Economy 94, 691 – 719. Search in Google Scholar

Hart, O. 1995. Firms, Contracts, and Financial Structure. Oxford: Clarendon Press.10.1093/0198288816.001.0001 Search in Google Scholar

Hart, O. and J. Moore. 1990. “Property Rights and the Nature of the Firm.” Journal of Political Economy 98, 1119 – 1158. Search in Google Scholar

Her Majesty’s Treasury. 2006. Value for Money Assessment Guidance. London: HM Treasury. Search in Google Scholar

Hodge, G. and C. Greve (eds). 2005. The Challenge of Public-Private Partnerships: Learning from International Experience. Place: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.10.4337/9781845428082 Search in Google Scholar

Hodge, G., C. Greve and M. Biygautane. 2018. “Do PPP’s Work ? What and how have we been Learning so Far ?” Public Management Review 20(8), 1105 – 1121. Search in Google Scholar

Hodge, G. A., C. Greve and A. E. Boardman (eds). 2010. International Handbook on Public-Private Partnerships. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.10.4337/9781849804691 Search in Google Scholar

Jensen, M. C. and W. Meckling. 1976. “Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behavior, Agency Costs, and Ownership Structure.” Journal of Financial Economics 3, 305 – 360. Search in Google Scholar

Kabashkin, V. 2010. Public-Private Partnership in the Regions of the Russian Federation [in Russian]. Moscow: Delo. Search in Google Scholar

Kazakhstan’s PPP Center. 2020. Kazakhstan’s Public-Private Partnerships Center. Available at https://kzppp.kz (last accessed 11 June 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Kim, J. and J. T. Mahoney. 2002. “Resource-Based and Property Rights Perspectives on Value Creation: The Case of Oil Field Unitization.” Managerial and Decision Economics 23, 225 – 245. Search in Google Scholar

Kim, J. and J. T. Mahoney. 2005. “Property Rights Theory, Transaction Costs Theory, and Agency Theory: An Organizational Economics Approach to Strategic Management.” Managerial and Decision Economics 26, 223 – 242. Search in Google Scholar

Klijn, E. H. and J. Koppenjan. 2016. “The Impact of Contract Characteristics on the Performance of Public-Private partnerships (PPPs).” Public Money and Management 36(6), 455 – 462. Search in Google Scholar

Klijn, E. H. and G. R. Teisman. 2003. “Institutional and Strategic Barriers to Public-Private Partnership: An Analysis of Dutch Cases.” Public Money and Management 23(3), 137 – 146. Search in Google Scholar

Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Concessions” [in Russian]. 2006. Available at https://ppp-academy.kz/documents3/1 (last accessed 14 February 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Public-Private Partnership” [in Russian]. 2015. Available at https://ppp-academy.kz/documents3/1 (last accessed 14 February 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Levinthal, D. 1988. “A Survey of Agency Models of Organizations.” Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 9(2), 153 – 185. Search in Google Scholar

Libecap, G. D. 1989. Contracting for Property Rights. Place: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511664120 Search in Google Scholar

Mahoney, J. T. 1995. “The Management of Resources and the Resource of Management.” Journal of Business Research 33, 99 – 101. Search in Google Scholar

Mahoney, J. T. 2005. Economic Foundations of Strategy. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Search in Google Scholar

Maslova, S. 2015. “The New Russian Law on PPP: Breakthrough or Throwback ?” European Procurement & Public Private Partnership Law Review 10(4), 298 – 309. Search in Google Scholar

Maslova, S. V. and M. Yu. Sokolov. 2020. “Public-Private Partnership’s Transboundary Projects: Conceptual Features and Practical Aspects of Management” (in Russian). Public Administration Issues 1, 86 – 114. Search in Google Scholar

Maslova, S. and A. Yushkov. 2017. “PPP Development in Russia: Overview of Current Trends and Transport Case Studies.” In N. Mouraviev and N. Kakabadse (eds). Public-Private Partnerships in Transitional Nations: Policy, Governance and Praxis. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 58 – 85. Search in Google Scholar

Matayev, T. 2020. Interview on PPP Development in Kazakhstan: Current Conditions, Trends and the Outlook [in Russian]. 10 June. Interview with the Chairman of Kazakhstan’s PPP Center. Official information resource of the Prime Minister of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Available at https://primeminister.kz/ru/news/interviews/intervyu-o-razvitie-gchp-v-kazahstane-sostoyanie-tendencii-i-perspektivy-1053646 (last accessed 18 January 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Miles, M. and A. Huberman, A. 1994. Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook. 2nd edn. Thousand Oaks: Sage. Search in Google Scholar

Miller, G. J. 1992. Managerial Dilemmas: The Political Economy of Hierarchy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139173742 Search in Google Scholar

Morallos, D. and A. Amekudzi. 2008. “The State of the Practice of Value for Money Analysis in Comparing Public Private Partnerships to Traditional Procurements.” Public Works Management and Policy 13(2), 114 – 125. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. 2012. “What Drives the Employment of Public-Private Partnerships in Kazakhstan and Russia: Value for Money ?” Organizations and Markets in Emerging Economies 3(5), 32 – 57. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2013. “Risk Allocation in a Public-Private Partnership: A Case Study of Construction and Operation of Kindergartens in Kazakhstan.” Journal of Risk Research 17(5), 621 – 640. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2014a. “Public-Private Partnerships in Russia: Dynamics contributing to an Emerging Policy Paradigm.” Policy Studies 35, 79 – 96. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2014b. “Impact of Externalities on Sustainable Development: Evidence from Public-Private Partnerships in Kazakhstan and Russia.” Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society 14(5), 653 – 669. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2015a. “Public-Private Partnership’s Procurement Criteria: The Case of Managing Stakeholders’ Value Creation in Kazakhstan.” Public Management Review 17(6), 769 – 790. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2015b. “Legal and Regulatory Barriers to Effective Public-Private Partnership Governance in Kazakhstan.” International Journal of Public Sector Management 28(3), 181 – 197. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2016. “Conceptualising Public-Private Partnerships: A Critical Appraisal of Approaches to Meanings and Forms.” Society and Business Review 11(2), 155 – 173. Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N. and N. Kakabadse. 2017. Public-Private Partnerships: Policy and Governance Challenges facing Kazakhstan and Russia. Place: Palgrave Macmillan.10.1057/978-1-137-56952-3 Search in Google Scholar

Mouraviev, N., N. Kakabadse and I. Robinson. 2012. “Concessionary Nature of Public-Private Partnerships in Russia and Kazakhstan: A Critical Review.” International Journal of Public Administration 35(6), 410 – 420. Search in Google Scholar

Nazarbayev, N. 2012. Strategy Kazakhstan-2050: New Political Course of the Established State. Strategy 2050 Review and Analytical Portal. Available at https://strategy2050.kz/en/page/multilanguage/ (last accessed 18 January 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Neuman, W. L. 2013. Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches. 7th edn. Harlow: Pearson. Search in Google Scholar

North, D.C. 1990. Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511808678 Search in Google Scholar

O’Nolan, G. and E. Reeves. 2018. “The Nature of Contracting Hazards in Public-Private Partnerships: Evidence from Ireland.” International Journal of Public Administration 41(15), 1205 – 1216. Search in Google Scholar

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. 2008. Public-Private Partnerships: In Pursuit of Risk Sharing and Value for Money. Paris: OECD. Search in Google Scholar

Osborne, S. P. (ed.). 2000. Public-Private Partnerships: Theory and Practice in International Perspective. London: Routledge.10.4324/9780203207116 Search in Google Scholar

Pankratov, A. 2010. Public-Private Partnership in the Modern Practice: Main Theoretical and Practical Problems [in Russian]. Moscow: Ankil. Search in Google Scholar

Patton, M. Q. 2015. Qualitative Research & Evaluation Methods: Integrating Theory and Practice. 4th edn. Place: Sage. Search in Google Scholar

Pejovich, S. 1995. Economic Analysis of Institutions and Systems. Norwell, Mass.: Kluwer Academic.10.1007/978-94-011-6483-2 Search in Google Scholar

Popondopulo, V. F. and N. A. Shevelyova (eds). 2015. Public-Private Partnership in Russia and Foreign Countries: The Legal Aspects [in Russian]. Moscow: Infotropik Media. Search in Google Scholar

PPP Knowledge Lab. 2021. “The Internet Resource.” Available at https://pppknowledgelab.org (last accessed 27 February 2021). Search in Google Scholar

PPP News. 2019. “Askar Mamin Instructed to Intensify PPP Development” [in Russian]. Kazakhstan Public-private Partnership Center, 22 October. Available at https://kzppp.kz/news/askar-mamin-poruchil-aktivizirovaty-razvitie-gchp-19 (last accessed 14 February 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Pratt, J. and R. Zeckhauser (eds). 1985. Principals and Agents: The Structure of Business. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Reeves, E. 2015. “A Review of the PPP Experience in Ireland: Lessons for Comparative Policy Analysis.” Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice 17(5), 1 – 14. Search in Google Scholar

Sadka, E. 2007. “Public-Private Partnerships: A Public Economics Perspective.” CESifo Economic Studies 53(3), 466 – 490. Search in Google Scholar

Shabashevich, M. 2011. “Efficiency of PPP Project Implementation in Russia’s Infrastructure.” In Annual Meeting of the PPP Development Center and Representatives of Regions of the Russian Federation Regarding Implementation of PPP Projects. Available at http://www.pppinrussia.ru/main/publications/articles (last accessed 12 June 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Soloviov, O. 2017. “Legal and Institutional Aspects of Public-Private Partnership in Ukraine: Reality and Prospects.” In N. Mouraviev and N. Kakabadse (eds). Public-Private Partnerships in Transitional Nations: Policy, Governance and Praxis. Newcastle upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 36 – 58. Search in Google Scholar

Steijn, A. J., E. H. Klijn and J. Edelenbos. 2011. “Public Private Partnerships: Added Value by Organizational Form or Management ?” Public Administration 89(4), 1235 – 1252. Search in Google Scholar

Tokayev, K.-J. 2019. Speech of the Head of State at the meeting of the government [in Russian]. Official Site of the President of Kazakhstan, 15 July. Available at http://www.akorda.kz/ru/speeches/internal_political_affairs/in_speeches_and_addresses/vystuplenie-glavy-gosudarstva-k-tokaeva-na-rasshirennom-zasedanii-pravitelstva (last accessed 26 February 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Urio, P. (ed.). 2010. Public-Private Partnerships: Success and Failure Factors for in-Transition Countries. Lanham, MD: University Press of America. Search in Google Scholar

Van Gestel, K., J. Voets and K. Verhoest. 2012. “How Governance of Complex PPPs Affects Performance ?” Public Administration Quarterly 36(2), 140 – 188. Search in Google Scholar

Varnavskiy, V. G. 2011. “Public-Private Partnerships: Selected Issues of Theory and Practice” [in Russian]. Mirovaya Ekonomika i Mezhdunarodnye Otnosheniya 9, 41 – 50. Search in Google Scholar

Varnavskiy, V., A. Klimenko and V. Korolev. 2010. Public-Private Partnerships: Theory and Practice [in Russian]. Moscow: Publishing House of the State University – Higher School of Economics. Search in Google Scholar

Wettenhall, R. 2005. “The Public-Private Interface: Surveying the History.” In G. Hodge and C. Greve (eds). The Challenge of Public-Private Partnerships: Learning from International Experience. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd, 22 – 43. Search in Google Scholar

Yescombe, E. R. 2007. Public-Private Partnerships: Principles of Policy and Finance. Burlington: Butterworth-Heinemann.10.1016/B978-075068054-7.50025-3 Search in Google Scholar

Yeshimova, D. 2019. Interview with the Senior Vice Chairman of Kazakhstan’s PPP Center [in Russian]. Khabar TV channel, 25 October. Available at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMaOSOZRvUM (last accessed 16 January 2021). Search in Google Scholar

Articles recommandés par Trend MD

Planifiez votre conférence à distance avec Sciendo