<abstract xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml"><p>This paper critiques the representationalist account of qualia, focussing on the Representational Naturalism presented by Fred Dretske in <italic>Naturalizing the Mind.</italic> After laying out Dretske’s theory of qualia and making clear its externalist consequences, I argue that Dretske’s definition is either too liberal or runs into problems defending its requirements, in particular ‘naturalness’ and ‘mentalness.’ I go on to show that Dretske’s account of qualia falls foul of the argument from misperception in such a way that Dretske must either admit that his kind of qualia have nothing at all to do with what mental life subjectively feels like, or that veridical perception involves qualia and misperception does not.</p></abstract>

This paper critiques the representationalist account of qualia, focussing on the Representational Naturalism presented by Fred Dretske in Naturalizing the Mind. After laying out Dretske’s theory of qualia and making clear its externalist consequences, I argue that Dretske’s definition is either too liberal or runs into problems defending its requirements, in particular ‘naturalness’ and ‘mentalness.’ I go on to show that Dretske’s account of qualia falls foul of the argument from misperception in such a way that Dretske must either admit that his kind of qualia have nothing at all to do with what mental life subjectively feels like, or that veridical perception involves qualia and misperception does not.

What is it Like to See a Bat? a Critique of Dretske’s Representationalist Theory of Qualia

Disputatio

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 3.0 License.

This paper critiques the representationalist account of qualia, focussing on the Representational Naturalism presented by Fred Dretske in Naturalizing the...

What is it Like to See a Bat? a Critique of Dretske’s Representationalist Theory of Qualia

Publié en ligne: 31 déc. 2018

Pages: 151 - 177

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2478/disp-2005-0003

© 2005 Andrew Bailey, published by Sciendo

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 3.0 License.