Accès libre

Corporate bonds or bank loans? The choice of funding sources and information disclosure of Polish listed companies

À propos de cet article

Citez

Definition of dependent variables (definitions of all variables available on request)

VariableDefinition
y1LSubstitutability of bonds and bank loans—binary variable takes the value 1 if a firm issued bonds in the year t (and did not borrow from bank) and 0, if the firm borrowed in a year t (but did not issue bonds)
y2LComplementariness of bonds and bank loans—binary variable takes the value 1 if a firm issued bonds in the year t, while contracting a bank loan at the same time; and 0, if the firm contracted a loan in the same year or issued bonds (but did not issue those kinds of debt together in the same year)
y3LBond issue—binary variable takes the value 1 if a firm issued bonds in the year t and 0—otherwise
y4LBank loans—binary variable takes the value 1 if a company borrowed a bank loan in the year covered by the analysis; and 0, if the company did not borrow a bank loan that year
ysubWeak form of substitutability of bonds and bank loans—binary variable takes the value 1 if a firm issued bonds in the year t; and 0, if the firm borrowed only a bank loan in that year t
y1pThe size of the bond issue/total assets
y2pInflow of bank loan/total assets

Results of panel analysis of determinants of corporate bonds issue

y1pFEREAMGLSFEREAMGLS
y4l−0.0816*** (0.0119)−0.0709*** (0.0103)−0.0422*** (0.0038)−0.0819*** (0.0119)−0.0714*** (0.0103)−0.0425*** (0.0039)
Risk−0.0094 (0.0822)0.0894 (0.0742)0.0608* (0.0347)−0.0250 (0.0823)0.0806 (0.0741)0.0592* (0.0346)
Leverage0.0368*** (0.0142)0.0277** (0.0113)0.0114** (0.0056)0.0357** (0.0143)0.0256** (0.0115)0.0102* (0.0055)
dum_zscore0.0209## (0.0139)0.0266** (0.0118)0.0063* (0.0035)0.0219## (0.0139)0.0260** (0.0118)0.0060* (0.0035)
Debt0.0165*** (0.0014)0.0129*** (0.0012)0.0070*** (0.0005)0.0167*** (0.0014)0.0130*** (0.0016)0.0070*** (0.0005)
Growth−0.0015** (0.0007)0.0004 (0.0007)0.0009# (0.0007)−0.0013** (0.0007)0.0004 (0.0007)0.0009# (0.0007)
Tangibility0.0913** (0.0418)−0.0057 (0.0195)−0.0050 (0.0045)0.0836** (0.0418)−0.0076 (0.0196)−0.0055 (0.0047)
subs_inv0.0037*** (0.0013)0.0007 (0.0010)−0.0002 (0.0003)0.0037*** (0.0013)0.0007 (0.0010)−0.0001 (0.0003)
Rating_20.0135*** (0.0050)0.0030 (0.0044)−0.0002 (0.0016)
Rating_3−0.0081** (0.0034)−0.0030 (0.0027)−0.0006 (0.0008)
public_debt_t1−0.0137* (0.0082)0.0024 (0.0075)0.0125*** (0.0030)−0.0133## (0.0082)0.0019 (0.0075)0.0120*** (0.0030)
fin_pressures0.00001 (0.0003)−0.0002 (0.0002)−0.0002*** (0.00003)−0.00002 (0.0003)−0.0003 (0.0002)−0.0002*** (0.00004)
_cons−0.0511*** (0.0135)−0.0117# (0.0105)−0.0026# (0.0023)−0.0310** (0.0148)−0.0041 (0.0121)−0.0011 (0.0035)
Number of observations761761761761761761
Number of groups208208208208208208
R2 within group0.26040.21640.25840.2182
R2 between groups0.02510.10690.03070.1072
R2 overall0.09080.15000.09630.1507
corr(u_i, Xb)−0.4480−0.4384
F(11,542) test17.35***17.17***
F(207,542) test that all u_i=02.84***2.82***
Wald test151.47***369.16***152.42***361.24***
Sargan–Hansen test of over-identifying restrictions127.022***124.156***
Hausmann test109.98***107.86***
Breusch–Pagan Lagrangian multiplier test for random effects54.87***55.84***
Wooldridge test for autocorrelation in panel data3.7283.756
0.05500.0541
Modified Wald test for groupwise heteroscedasticity in fixed-effect regression model−208***−208***

Results of panel analysis of determinants of bank loans borrowings

y2pFEREAMGLSFEREAMGLSFEREAMGLS
y1l−0.1449*** (0.0239)−0.1196*** (0.0206)−0.0757*** (0.0053)−0.1416*** (0.0240)−0.1172*** (0.0206)−0.0750*** (0.0052)−0.1422*** (0.0238)−0.1181*** (0.0206)−0.0779*** (0.0052)
Risk0.0303 (0.1552)−0.0347 (0.1295)0.0190 (0.0340)0.0313 (0.1555)−0.0146 (0.1295)0.0233 (0.0328)−0.0042 (0.1555)−0.0535 (0.1309)0.0057 (0.0341)
Leverage−0.0712** (0.0282)−0.0017 (0.0186)0.0048 (0.0076)−0.0743*** (0.0283)−0.0031 (0.0192)−0.0002 (0.0084)−0.0775*** (0.0281)−0.0113 (0.0191)−0.0019 (0.0074)
market_to_ book1.04e-06 (2.18e-06)1.33e-06 (1.41e-06)6.23e-07 (5.36e-07)6.42e-07 (2.22e-06)1.34e-06 (1.43e-06)7.08e-07# (5.26e-07)1.82e-07 (2.19e-06)9.06e-07 (1.43e-06)2.57e-07 (5.17e-07)
roa−0.2597** (0.1205)0.0618 (0.0998)−0.0538** (0.0269)−0.2364** (0.1212)0.0729 (0.1017)−0.0533* (0.0279)−0.2332* (0.1198)0.0990 (0.1005)−0.0238 (0.0256)
dum_zscore0.0154 (0.0294)−0.0146 (0.0218)−0.0026 (0.0053)0.0174 (0.0296)−0.0136 (0.0219)−0.0033 (0.0052)0.0239 (0.0295)−0.0138 (0.0218)−0.0059# (0.0051)
Debt0.0148*** (0.0020)0.0123*** (0.0015)0.0090*** (0.0004)0.0145*** (0.0020)0.0120*** (0.0015)0.0088*** (0.0004)0.0148*** (0.0020)0.0122*** (0.0015)0.0091*** (0.0004)
Growth0.0017# (0.0013)0.0013 (0.0012)0.0014*** (0.0003)0.0017# (0.0013)0.0013 (0.0012)0.0013*** (0.0003)0.0021## (0.0013)0.0014 (0.0012)0.0015*** (0.0003)
Tangibility−0.1092 (0.0792)−0.0104 (0.0317)0.0129## (0.0084)−0.1066 (0.0793)−0.0144 (0.0321)0.0132## (0.0083)−0.1246## (0.0793)−0.0213 (0.0319)0.0200*** (0.0080)
oper_risk1.17e-07 (1.26e-07)1.76e-09 (3.63e-08)6.63e-09 (1.65e-08)1.11e-07 (1.26e-07)9.22e-10 (3.65e-08)6.34e-09 (1.70e-08)1.13e-07 (1.26e-07)5.15e-09 (3.65e-08)8.36e-09 (1.55e-08)
long_debt0.0279 (0.0265)0.0086 (0.0193)−0.0006 (0.0047)0.0338 (0.0271)0.0105 (0.0196)0.0007 (0.0047)0.0417## (0.0268)0.0153 (0.0195)0.0035 (0.0046)
subs_inv−0.0042* (0.0024)−0.0021# (0.0016)−0.0012** (0.0005)−0.0040* (0.0024)−0.0019# (0.0017)−0.0013** (0.0005)−0.0041* (0.0024)−0.0019# (0.0016)−0.0012*** (0.0005)
Rollover_debt−1.65e-09 (2.51e-09)−1.41e-09 (2.33e-09)−1.13e-09** (5.41e-10)−1.68e-09 (2.52e-09)−1.36e-09 (2.34e-09)−1.13e-09** (5.56e-10)−1.71e-09 (2.51e-09)−1.38e-09 (2.33e-09)−1.2e-09** (5.94e-10)
Age−0.0083## (0.0053)−0.0064*** (0.0017)−0.0030*** (0.0005)−0.0082## (0.0053)−0.0063*** (0.0017)−0.0031*** (0.0005)−0.0098* (0.0053)−0.0065*** (0.0017)−0.0036*** (0.0005)
public debt_t1−0.0151 (0.0157)−0.0076 (0.0131)−0.0042 (0.0036)−0.0180 (0.0157)−0.0093 (0.0132)−0.0044 (0.0035)−0.0168 (0.0155)−0.0111 (0.0131)−0.0091*** (0.0034)
rating_2−0.0116# (0.0096)−0.0126* (0.0076)−0.0070*** (0.0022)
rating_3−0.0044 (0.0067)0.0004 (0.0048)0.0007 (0.0013)
rating_10.0558*** (0.0240)0.0294* (0.0169)0.0142*** (0.0043)
_cons0.0917* (0.0535)0.0563** (0.0271)0.0243*** (0.0071)0.0931* (0.0550)0.0503* (0.0286)0.0220*** (0.0074)0.0861* (0.0529)0.0478* (0.0270)0.0245*** (0.0069)
No of observations of groups761761752761761752761761752
208208199208208199208208199
R2 within group0.15730.12790.15560.12660.16340.1329
R2 between groups0.03020.12220.02930.11650.02980.1156
R2 overall0.07780.12480.07650.12100.07770.1237
corr(u_i, Xb)−0.3248−0.3204−0.3511
F(16,537)6.26***6.19***6.56***
F-test that all u_i=0
F(207, 537)1.81***1.82***1.85***
Wald test chi-squared106.02***631.16***102.91***629.24***106.37***808.66***
Sargan–Hansen test of over-identifying restrictions
chi-squared43.653***43.550***45.921***
Hausman test of over-identifying restrictions
chi-squared (13)41.77***41.59***43.76***
Breusch–Pagan Lagrangian multiplier test for random effects
chibar2(01)28.32***28.89***29.69***
Wooldridge test for autocorrelation in panel data
F(1,187)−208***−208***−208***
Modified Wald test for groupwise heteroscedasticity in fixed-effect regression model
chi-squared (211)8.755***8.610***8.505***

Corporate bonds used by companies listed on WSE and outflows in the period 1999–2014

Numbers of companies1999200020012002200320042005200620072008200920102011201220132014
Bonds issue24171418171818213537465984919775
Bank loans without issue bonds23384637424043574963697279887776
Liquidity support by bond issue684754681411192539364038
Financial investments20151416121310162528304448525641
Tangible investments22161316161517203033394859686354

Logistics analysis of the choice between corporate bonds and bank loans

VariableModel 1 y1LModel 2 y2LModel 3 y3LModel 4 ysubModel 5 y4L Bank loans
SubstitutabilityComplementarinessBond issueWeak substitutability
Coeffdy/dxCoeffdy/dxCoeffdy/dxCoeffdy/dxCoeffdy/dx
acc_policy−9.068*** (3.57)−1.889* (1.11)2.799** (1.35)0.606* (0.33)
disc_income10.812** (5.05)2.252* (1.29)−4.351** (1.85)−0.657** (0.28)−4.448*** (1.77)−1.106*** (0.44)
disc_balance−7.960* (4.59)−1.658# (1.20)4.452** (1.83)0.673** (0.27)5.596*** (1.85)1.392*** (0.46)
Risk−67.295** (31.71)−14.018# (10.15)−6.727 (5.39)−1.456 (1.22)−13.154* (7.90)−1.987* (1.21)−10.947## (7.15)−2.722## (1.77)
Bankruptcy−0.927** (0.48)−0.193*** (0.07)−0.027** (0.01)−0.004** (0.002)−0.104** (0.05)−0.026** (0.01)0.042** (0.02)0.009** (0.004)
dum bankrupt9.047*** (3.00)0.366 (0.30)−5.381# (3.94)−0.387** (0.16)
Debt0.542** (0.23)0.113# (0.09)1.367*** (0.22)0.296*** (0.08)0.574*** (0.09)0.087*** (0.01)0.473*** (0.10)0.117*** (0.02)0.538*** (0.06)0.111*** (0.02)
Growth0.068 (0.36)0.014 (0.07)0.093 (0.12)0.020 (0.03)0.011 (0.06)0.002 (0.01)0.022 (0.06)0.005 (0.01)0.092 (0.18)0.019 (0.04)
Tangibility−2.819* (1.74)−0.587# (0.45)−0.080 (0.84)−0.017 (0.18)−0.969# (0.77)−0.146# (0.11)−0.872 (0.76)−0.217 (0.19)0.805 (0.95)0.166 (0.19)
oper_risk4.76e−06*** (1.86e−06)9.91e−07* (0.00)−2.03e-06*** (5.69e-07)−4.20e-07*** (0.00)
subs_inv−0.343*** (0.13)−0.071* (0.04)
Maintain liquidity−0.091*** (0.04)−0.019## (0.01)0.070** (0.04)0.015* (0.01)0.035** (0.016)0.005** (0.002)
Rating1.960** (0.83)0.408## (0.27)−0.575** (0.28)−0.124* (0.07)−0.242 (0.24)−0.060 (0.06)−0.249 (0.23)−0.051 (0.05)
Size−1.26*** (0.23)−0.273*** (0.08)−0.218** (0.10)−0.045** (0.02)
fin_pressures0.003* (0.002)0.0004* (0.0002)0.004# (0.003)0.001# (0.001)
riskdisclosure1.039 (1.01)0.216 (0.23)−0.682* (0.37)−0.103* (0.05)−0.498# (0.37)−0.124# (0.09)1.072*** (0.33)0.221*** (0.07)
public_debt_t11.185*** (0.35)0.259*** (0.09)1.348*** (0.32)0.224*** (0.06)1.578*** (0.31)0.375*** (0.07)
Auditor−1.591* (0.97)−0.328# (0.25)−1.400*** (0.39)−0.203*** (0.05)−1.041*** (0.39)−0.252*** (0.09)
freefloat−4.413** (2.23)−0.919# (0.65)−1.167# (0.84)−0.176# (0.13)
tax_shield0.558# (0.40)0.116## (0.07)0.020 (0.02)0.003 (0.002)
Age−0.062## (0.04)−0.009## (0.01)−0.063* (0.04)−0.016* (0.01)
rollover_debt2.023** (0.93)0.421* (0.22)
Liquidity−0.019 (0.02)−0.003 (0.002)
real_estate−0.336* (0.18)−0.051* (0.03)
tax_saving−0.233# (0.16)−0.050 (0.05)
long_debt−0.760# (0.58)−0.164 (0.13)
_cons−4.804## (3.36)1.021 (1.62)−4.372*** (1.34)−4.728*** (1.52)−1.236 (1.12)
Pr(y) (predict)0.7040.3170.1850.4630.708
Correct classif88.50%82.46%81.49%76.21%88.08%
LR87.3***139.6***188.96***112.1***205.9***
Adjusted count R2:0.6670.4780.5190.2260.634
Pearsonchi-squared (94)67.0chi-squared (255)255.3chi-squared (317)261.6chi-squared (255)247.5chi-squared (335)335.5
Prob.0.9840.4820.9900.6200.483
LR chi-squared (2)87.57***139.58***188.96***112.42***207.95***
Log likelihood−29.03−101.25−128.79−129.93−113.09
Pseudo R20.6010.4080.4230.3020.479
_hat1.046*** (0.24)0.999*** (0.15)1.001*** (0.12)1.012*** (0.13)1.035*** (0.13)
hatsq0.034 (0.05)−0.001 (0.06)0.002 (0.05)0.039 (0.07)−0.077 (0.05)
cons−0.063 (0.37)0.001 (0.20)−0.003 (0.18)−0.056 (0.18)0.234 (0.26)

Results of panel analysis of determinants of bonds issues in the period 1999–2014

VariableRE random effectsPrais––Winsten regression
y2p−0.0276* (0.0150)−0.0378 (0.0316)
Size−0.0077*** (0.0022)−0.0070*** (0.0026)
Leverage0.0250*** (0.0088)0.0308*** (0.0088)
market_to_book8.00e-07## (5.51e-07)7.48e-07 *** (2.10e-07)
dum_zscore0.0148** (0.0067)0.0216** (0.0101)
Debt0.0085*** (0.0007)0.0093*** (0.0004)
Tangibility−0.0582*** (0.0159)−0.0574*** (0.0151)
Liquidity0.0001 (0.0001)0.0001*** (0.00003)
tang_investment0.0016# (0.0012)0.0017# (0.0013)
subs_inv0.0029*** (0.0007)0.0024*** (0.0009)
Maintainliquidity0.0001** (0.00004)0.0001# (0.0001)
tax_shield0.0012*** (0.0004)
Age−0.0019** (0.0008)−0.0020* (0.0012)
public_debt_t10.0319*** (0.0062)0.0219# (0.0157)
Growth−3.91e-06*** (1.38e-06)
_cons0.0641*** (0.0204)0.0534*** (0.0146)
Number of observations2154
Number of groups223
Obs. per group: minimum3
  Average9.6592
  Maximum16
R20.1250
Wald chi-squared (14)297.01***4712.70***
Modified Wald test for groupwise heteroscedasticity in fixed-effect regression modelchi-squared (223) = 7.5e+05***
Wooldridge test for autocorrelationF(1, 222) = 6.437**
Breusch and Pagan Lagrangian multiplier test for random effectschibar2(01) = 499.87***