In December 2019, health authorities in Wuhan, China, identified a cluster of acute respiratory disease of unknown etiology.1 Subsequently the researchers identified a new viral agent, SARS-CoV-2, as responsible for the heart of an international outbreak centred on Hubei. On 30 January 2020, World Health Organization (WHO) confirmed the COVID-19 epidemic as a public health emergency and on 11 March 2020 demarcated the rapid spread of infection as a pandemic in the world.1,2 Globally, at the time of writing (15 September 2020), there have been 29,525,571 confirmed cases of COVID-19, including 934,192 deaths. In Italy, there have been 289,990 confirmed cases, including 35,633 deaths, reported to WHO.2 According to the data reported by the Italian authorities, the fatality rates, related to COVID-19 infection, increase exponentially after the age of 70 years, and the presence of an oncological pathology increases the risk of mortality.3 According to Liang
This document is based upon oncological panel of expert opinions by 9 radiologists, 1 cancer surgeon, and 1 radiotherapist, as well as additional expert in statistic. The panel included members of Italian Society of Radiology and Interventional Radiology (SIRM), including the President, the oncology diagnostic imaging section president-elect and the SIRM board. The panel identified four possible scenarios on how to manage a cancer patient during the COVID-19 pandemic in a radiology unit. The entire panel was convened during a single session using a live audio and video interface. The four scenarios were presented, discussed, and refined. These scenarios are intended to support the management of adults only. Children merit separate consideration and are beyond the scope of this document.
We accorded to the “
The document derived also by a comprehensive literature search. Using the following terms “COVID-19 OR SARS-CoV 2” AND “Cancer Patients” AND “Management” and “Imaging” we found a total of 148 articles published between Dec 1st, 2019 and Sept 15th, 2020. Each article was evaluated for relevance to the primary endpoint and a summary of key findings from relevant articles was created. The panel assessed 39 papers that met the document criteria.7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42,43,44,45,46
Four scenarios can be defined in the radiological management of cancer patient:
Non-COVID-19 cancer patient
Suspected COVID-19 cancer patient
Confirmed COVID-19 cancer patient
Cancer Patients with incidental COVID-19 diagnosis
Although each scenario requires different management, however all should be performed with the intent of avoiding contamination for health workers and other patients.
Patients, with laboratory non confirmed COVID-19 infection by using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) test of nasopharyngeal swab to SARS-CoV-2, are defined as non COVID-19 patients. However, since laboratory tests are not yet used as a screening tool to identify COVID-19 patients, and many people may be asymptomatic or
The healthcare staff should wear N95 mask, avoids direct contact with patient’s secretions, especially oral or respiratory, wear goggles or face shield, wear gloves, wash or disinfect hands before wearing gloves and after removing the gloves. A surgical cap and shoe covers may be added. After each radiological procedure, the community hospital should clean and disinfect with 500 mg/L chlorine-containing disinfectant the radiological equipment used, clean their hands properly, and the room should be opened for appropriate ventilation. The isolation times of the section in which the person has stayed depend on the number of air parts insured for the environment (about 6/h with related 69 minutes of isolation), according to SIRM guidelines (Table 1).7,8,9,10
Recommendations for first scenario – non COVID-19 cancer patient, according to Italian Society of Radiology and Interventional Radiology (SIRM) guidelines10
Patients | Health care staff |
---|---|
Wear | Wear |
• N95 mask [strong recommendation] | • N95 mask [strong recommendation] |
• or surgical mask [weak recommendation] | • goggles or face shield [strong recommendation] |
• gloves [strong recommendation] | |
• surgical cap [weak recommendation] | |
• shoe covers [weak recommendation] | |
Stay away from other people (at least 6 feet of distance) [strong recommendation] | Clean and disinfect with 500 mg/L chlorine-containing disinfectant the radiological equipment used, clean their hands properly, and the room should be opened for appropriate ventilation [strong recommendation] |
Suspected infected patient should be isolated, controlled, and diagnostic confirmation should be as quick as possible. Patients with mild symptoms should remain in home isolation, while patients with severe symptoms should be hospitalized, following the isolation guidelines.7 As for the first scenario, also in this case patient and healthcare staff should follow the same procedures concerning the use of masks, wear goggles or face shield, gloves and the distance of at least 6 feet if possible, avoiding direct contact with respiratory secretions, so as disinfection procedures for radiological equipment and rooms. In this scenario, it asks the radiologist to confirm the diagnosis of COVID-19. COVID-19 diagnosis is made by RT-PCR test, however radiological test is suggested for medical triage of suspected patients with moderate-severe clinical symptoms and with higher pre-test infection probability.8 The reported sensitivity of chest x-ray (CXR) for COVID-19 pneumonia is relatively low in the early phase of the disease and in mild cases (69%).48 Conversely, chest computed tomography (CT) shows greater sensitivity for early pneumonic change, disease progression, and alternative diagnoses; the administration of the intravenous contrast medium, is essential for the diagnosis of pulmonary thromboembolism.9 However, in Italy, to reduce the possibility of the spread of the infection, in accordance with the Italian Society of Radiology and Interventional Radiology (SIRM) guidelines, CXR is the first tool to be used in patients with suspected COVID-19 (see Figure 1 that shown a patchy consolidation and strip-like opacity in a patient with confirmed COVID-19 disease by RT-PCR).10 Since, portable equipment for performing the diagnostic investigation in the patient ‘s isolation room is the element that might favour CXR in selected patients, reducing the risk of COVID-19 infection and eliminating the risk related to the transport route to a CT scanner (Table 2).8
Recommendations for second scenario – suspected COVID-19 cancer patient, according to Italian Society of Radiology and Interventional Radiology (SIRM) guidelines10
Patients | Healthcare staff |
---|---|
Isolated, controlled, and diagnostic confirmation should be as quick as possible | |
Wear • N95 mask [strong recommendation] | Wear • N95 mask [strong recommendation] |
• or surgical mask [weak recommendation] | • goggles or face shield [strong recommendation] |
• gloves [strong recommendation] | |
• surgical cap [weak recommendation] | |
• shoe covers [weak recommendation] | |
Stay away from other people (at least 6 feet of distance) [strong recommendation] | Clean and disinfect with 500 mg/L chlorine-containing disinfectant the radiological equipment used, clean their hands properly, and the room should be opened for appropriate ventilation [strong recommendation] |
Diagnostic tool | |
• Chest radiography (CXR; not very sensitive), with portable equipment in the isolation room [strong recommendation] | |
• Computed tomography (CT; greater sensitivity) for early pneumonic change, disease progression, and alternative diagnoses; | |
the administration of the intravenous contrast medium for the diagnosis of pulmonary thromboembolism |
“
“
Several features should be considered in for imaging methods in the COVID-19 patient. First, daily chest radiographs are not indicated in stable intubated patients with COVID-19, so it is possible also to reduce exposure risk of radiology technicians.8 Second, CT scan is indicated for the evaluation of the stage of infection, for defining complications and for a correct differential diagnosis.8 Third, the chest ultrasound (POCUS – point-of-care ultrasound), performed by the intensivists at the patient’s bed, can also represent a monitoring tool to evaluate the effectiveness of the prono-supination manoeuvres. Systematic application of the POCUS can reduce the use of diagnostic imaging resources, also reducing staff exposure to possible contamination and helping to optimize therapies especially in critically ill patients (Table 3).10,11,12
Recommendations for third scenario - confirmed Covid-19 cancer patient, according to Italian Society of Radiology and Interventional Radiology (SIRM) guidelines10
Patients | Healthcare staff |
---|---|
Isolated and controlled | Medical personnel enter into the isolation area through |
• treated in designated hospitals with isolation and protection conditions [strong recommendation] | designated channels (strongrecommendation] |
Wear | |
• N95 mask (strong recommendation] | |
Wear | • goggles or face shield (strong recommendation] |
• N95 mask [strong recommendation] | • gloves (strong recommendation] |
• or surgical mask [weak recommendation] | • surgical cap (weak recommendation] |
• shoe covers(weak recommendation] | |
Stay away from other people (at least 6 feet of distance) [strong recommendation] | Clean and disinfect with 500 mg/L chlorine-containing disinfectant the radiological equipment used, clean their hands properly, and the room should be opened for appropriate ventilation [strong recommendation] |
Diagnostic tool | |
• daily chest radiographs are not indicated | |
• CT scan is indicated for the evaluation of the stage of | |
infection, for defining complications and for a correct | |
differential diagnosis | |
• The chest ultrasound (POCUS – point-of-care ultrasound) a | |
monitoring tool to evaluate the effectiveness of the prono- | |
supination manoeuvres |
We defined cancer patient with incidental COVID-19 diagnosis, when the diagnosis is random, during examination by staging or follow-up for oncological disease. CT features of COVID-19 infection are non-specific, however, the detection of these in an asymptomatic patient allows to identify that group of asymptomatic patients who can favour the spread of the infection in the community. It is reported that asymptomatic carriers of COVID-19 are 17.9%–33.3% of all infected cases.13,14 The undetected infected patients are responsible for a rapid spread of SARS-CoV2.15 RT-PCR test in this scenario is important to identify an occult infection and limit further transmission within the community. Therefore, although in the cancer patient, especially when undergoing immunotherapy, interstitial pneumonia may be a complication of treatment, in a pandemic phase it is essential to exclude COVID-19 infection, so that the patient, even asymptomatic, must be considered infected before laboratory tests (Table 4).
Fourth scenario -Cancer Patients with incidental COVID-19 diagnosis, according to Italian Society of Radiology and Interventional Radiology (SIRM) guidelines10
Patients | Healthcare staff |
---|---|
Controlled | |
• diagnostic confirmation should be as quick as possible [strong recommendation] | |
Wear | Wear |
• N95 mask [strong recommendation] | • N95 mask [strong recommendation] |
• or surgical mask [weak recommendation] | • goggles or face shield [strong recommendation] |
• gloves [strong recommendation] | |
• surgical cap [weak recommendation] | |
• shoe covers [weak recommendation] | |
Stay away from other people (at least 6 feet of distance) [strong recommendation] | Clean and disinfect with 500 mg/L chlorine-containing disinfectant the radiological equipment used, clean their hands properly, and the room should be opened for appropriate ventilation [strong recommendation] |
Up to day, it is known that the main source of COVID-19 infection are patients during the first week of infection, later the viral load diminishes and in some studies live virus was not isolated past 8th day post infection. Respiratory droplet is the main route of transmission, so as strict contact. Although, several data, as the source of the virus and its ability to spread between people is unknown, however it is clear that it is possible a human-to-human transmission.16
“
COVID-19 infection is particularly aggressive in frail patients, as cancer patients. Therefore, the more suitable management of the cancer patient requires a multidisciplinary assessment, to identify which patients should be treated, as inpatients or outpatients, and which treatments can be procrastinated. It is clear that the role of radiologist is crucial, and, all cancer patients who need an imaging evaluation will still need to be studied, using the most appropriate imaging tools related to the clinical question and taking attention to preserve public health. Therefore, guidelines are necessary in the correct organization of a radiology unit to manage patients with suspected or confirmed COVID-19 infection, and whenever possible, a satellite radiography center with dedicated equipment should be used to decrease the risk of transmission.