Seasonally adjusted series of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and its breakdown in underlying categories or domains are generally not consistent with each other. Statistical differences between the total GDP and the sum of the underlying domains arise for two reasons. If series are expressed in constant prices, differences arise due to the process of chain linking. These differences increase if, in addition, a univariate seasonal adjustment, with for instance X-13ARIMA-SEATS, is applied to each series separately. In this article, we propose to model the series for total GDP and its breakdown in underlying domains in a multivariate structural time series model, with the restriction that the sum over the different time series components for the domains are equal to the corresponding values for the total GDP. In the proposed procedure, this approach is applied as a pretreatment to remove outliers, level shifts, seasonal breaks and calendar effects, while obeying the aforementioned consistency restrictions. Subsequently, X-13ARIMA-SEATS is used for seasonal adjustment. This reduces inconsistencies remarkably. Remaining inconsistencies due to seasonal adjustment are removed with a benchmarking procedure.
Keywords
- Seasonal adjustment
- discrepancies
- Kalman filter
- multivariate structural time series models
- X-13ARIMA-SEATS
- benchmarking
Some Thoughts on Official Statistics and its Future (with discussion) Total Process Error: An Approach for Assessing and Monitoring the Quality of Multisource Processes Data Fusion for Joining Income and Consumtion Information using Different Donor-Recipient Distance Metrics Improving the Output Quality of Official Statistics Based on Machine Learning Algorithms If They Don’t Understand the Question, They Don’t answer. Language Mismatch in Face-to-Face Interviews Improved Assessment of the Accuracy of Record Linkage via an Extended MaCSim Approach Assessing Residual Seasonality in the U.S. National Income and Product Accounts Aggregates Book Review Spatial Sampling Design to Improve the Efficiency of the Estimation of the Critical Parameters of the SARS-CoV-2 Epidemic In Memory of Dr. Lars Lyberg Remembering a Giant in Survey Research 1944–2021 Rejoinder: Measuring Inflation under Pandemic Conditions Data Collection Expert Prior Elicitation in Survey Design: Two Case Studies Iterative Kernel Density Estimation Applied to Grouped Data: Estimating Poverty and Inequality Indicators from the German Microcensus