1. bookVolumen 16 (2022): Edición 1 (April 2022)
Detalles de la revista
License
Formato
Revista
eISSN
2183-3311
Primera edición
15 Dec 2016
Calendario de la edición
1 tiempo por año
Idiomas
Inglés
access type Acceso abierto

Game Board or Abacus? Greek Counter Culture Revisited

Publicado en línea: 26 Apr 2022
Volumen & Edición: Volumen 16 (2022) - Edición 1 (April 2022)
Páginas: 251 - 307
Detalles de la revista
License
Formato
Revista
eISSN
2183-3311
Primera edición
15 Dec 2016
Calendario de la edición
1 tiempo por año
Idiomas
Inglés
Abstract

A late 5th century BC funerary altar from the necropolis of Krannon (Central Greece) depicts a bearded man and a boy on either side of a board with five lines carved on a block. The fact that the man is seated and the horizontal position of the board reveal important information about Greek education and the history of Greek numeracy. This paper analyses the iconography of the relief, the link between the Five Lines game (Pente grammai) and abaci, examines the possible identification of the man as a “pebble arithmetician”, of the boy as a student, and suggests a new reconstruction of the reckoning system operated on an abacus composed of five horizontal lines. A special practical function is proposed for the half-circle at one end of the abacus. This five lines pattern and the related material, especially counters, are considered from a wider perspective, a system of cultural practices associated with boards and counters throughout the Greek world.

Keywords

Ambrosini L. 2011. Le gemme etrusche con iscrizioni, Pisa. Search in Google Scholar

Asper M. 2009. “The two cultures of mathematics in ancient Greece”, E. Robson – J. Stedall (eds), The Oxford Handbook of the History of Mathematics, Oxford, 107-132. Search in Google Scholar

Baldoni V. 2017. “Achille e Aiace che giocano ai dadi: vecchie ipotesi e nuove letture”, ArchCl 68, 419-432. Search in Google Scholar

Barnard F.P. 1916. The Casting-Counter and the Counting-Board, A Chapter in the History of Numismatics and Early Arithmetic, London. Search in Google Scholar

Batziou-Efstathiou A. – Karagounis D. 2013. Ancient Krannon, Athens. Search in Google Scholar

Beazley J.D. 1963. Attic Vase Paintings in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, III, Oxford. Search in Google Scholar

Becker A. 2007. “The Royal Game of Ur”, I.L. Finkel (ed.), Ancient Board Games in Perspective: Papers from the 1990 British Museum Colloquium, with Additional Contributions, London, 11-15. Search in Google Scholar

Becq de Fouquières L. 1869. Les jeux des Anciens, Paris. Search in Google Scholar

Berger E. 1970. Das Basler Arztrelief: Studien zum griechischen Grab- und Votivrelief um 500 v. Chr. und zur vorhippokratischen Medizin, Basel. Search in Google Scholar

Beta S. 2020. “Studiare la lingua e la letteratura greca divertendosi: gli indovinelli greci nelle scuole di Bisanzio”, V. Dasen – M. Vespa (eds), Bons ou mauvais jeux ? Pratiques ludiques et sociabilité, Pallas 114, 23-42. Search in Google Scholar

Beta S. 2021. “From Homer to John Eugenicus: the long journey of riddles through Greek and Byzantine literatures”, V. Dasen – M. Vespa (eds), Play and Games in Classical Antiquity: Definition, Transmission, Reception, Collection Jeu/Play/Spiel 2, Liège, 301-313. Search in Google Scholar

Bogaert R. 1968. Banques et banquiers dans les cités grecques, Leiden. Search in Google Scholar

Bosnakis D. 2012. ΕΝΘΕΤΤΑΛΙΖΕΣΘΑΙ. Τεχνοτροπία και ιδεολογία των θεσσαλικών επιτυμβίων αναγλύφων, Αθήνα. Search in Google Scholar

Bouvier D. 2020. “Un coup de dés jamais n’abolira l’Iliade”, D. Bouvier – V. Dasen (eds), Héraclite : Le temps est un enfant qui joue, Collection Jeu/Play/Spiel 1, Liège, 173-194. Search in Google Scholar

Bradley K. 1998. The sentimental education of the Roman child: the role of pet-keeping, Latomus 57, 3, 523-557. Search in Google Scholar

Buchholz H.-G. 1987. “Brettspielende Helden”, S. Laser (ed.), Sport und Spiel. Archaeologia Homerica, vol. 3, Teil T, Göttingen, 126-184. Search in Google Scholar

Bundrick S. D. 2017. “Altars, astragaloi, Achilles: picturing divination on Athenian vases”, S. Blakely (ed.), Gods, Objects, and Ritual Practice, Atlanta, 53-74. Search in Google Scholar

Burkhalter F. 2014, “Change et changeurs en Égypte ptolémaïque aux IIIe et IIe s. av. J.-C.”, BCH 138, 2, 563-581. Search in Google Scholar

Casevitz M. 2021. “Sur les termes de jeu : compléments d’histoire des mots”, Kentron 36, 209-212.10.4000/kentron.5247 Search in Google Scholar

Chamay J. – Schärlig A. 1998. “Représentation d’une table de calcul”, AK 41, 52-55. Search in Google Scholar

Chankowski-Sablé V. 2014. “Les modalités du change des monnaies à Délos d’après les comptes des hiéropes”, BCH 138, 2, 535-547. Search in Google Scholar

Chemillier M. –Jacquet D. – Randrianary V. – Zabalia M. 2007. “Aspects mathématiques et cognitifs de la divination sikidy à Madagascar”, L’Homme 181, 7-39.10.4000/lhomme.21826 Search in Google Scholar

Chidiroglou M. – Schädler U. – Schierup S. 2022, in press. “Pente grammai: new Attic miniature clay boardgames”, Th. Daniaux – V. Dasen (eds), Locus Ludi : Quoi de neuf sur la culture ludique antique ? Pallas. Search in Google Scholar

Dasen V. 2015. “Achille et Ajax : quand l’agôn s’allie à l’alea”, L’esprit du sport. Entre jeu, don et démesure, Revue du M.A.U.S.S. 45, 81-98. Search in Google Scholar

Dasen V. 2018. “À la redécouverte de la culture ludique antique”, V. Dasen (dir.), Dossier Jeux et jouets dans l’Antiquité, Archeologia 571, 30-43. Search in Google Scholar

Dasen V. 2020. ‘La royauté de l’enfant. À propos d’Héraclite et de pratiques ludiques enfantines en Grèce ancienne’, D. Bouvier – V. Dasen (eds), Héraclite : Le temps est un enfant qui joue, Collection Jeu/ Play/Spiel 1, Liège, 97-123. Search in Google Scholar

Donati J. C. 2010. “Marks of state ownership and the Greek agora at Corinth”, AJA 114, 1, 3-26. Search in Google Scholar

Doyen Ch. 2014. “Pratiques comptables en Grèce hellénistique”, Comptabilités [Open Access] 6. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/comptabilites/1465 Search in Google Scholar

Finkel I.L. 1995. “Board games and fortune telling: a case from antiquity”, A.J. de Voogt (ed.), New Approaches to Board Games Research: Asian Origins and Future Perspectives, Leiden, 64-72. Search in Google Scholar

Frontisi-Ducroux F. 2013. “À propos de l’autel : le bomos, un capteur graphique”, J.-M. Luce (ed.), Texte et image dans l’Antiquité, Pallas 93, 81-95. Search in Google Scholar

Gavin J. – Genequand Ph. 2021. Énigmes mathématiques au temps de Charlemagne, Lausanne. Search in Google Scholar

Gavin J. – Schärlig A. 2014. Sur les doigts jusqu’à 9999, Lausanne. Search in Google Scholar

Gavin J. – Schärlig A. 2018. La distributivité dans les multiplications des anciens Grecs : une question de langue ?, Quadrature 107, 27-29. Search in Google Scholar

Gerhard E. 1843. Etruskische und Kampanische Vasenbilder des Königlichen Museums zu Berlin, Berlin. Search in Google Scholar

Gerleigner G. 2020. “ΑΘΕΝΑΙΑ/ΑΙΑΣ”, M. Aberson – F. Dell’Oro – M. de Vaan – A. Viredaz (eds), [vøːrtər]. Mélanges de linguistique, de philologie et d’histoire ancienne offerts à Rudolf Wachter (Cahiers de l’ILSL 60), Lausanne, 33–39. Search in Google Scholar

Grandolini S. 2006. “Sugli epigrammi aritmetici nell’Anthologia Palatina: riflessi letterari ed aspetti di vita quotidiana nell’insegnamento dell’aritmetica”, Giornale Italiano di Filologia 58 341-353.10.1484/J.GIF.5.102035 Search in Google Scholar

Hamayon R. 2021. Jouer, une autre façon d’agir. Étude anthropologique à partir d’exemples sibériens, Paris. Search in Google Scholar

Huffmann C. 2020. s.v. “Archytas”, E. N. Zalta (ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2020 Edition): Open access: https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2020/entries/archytas Search in Google Scholar

Ignatiadou D. 2019. “Luxury board games for the Northern Greek elite”, V. Dasen – U. Schädler (eds), Jouer dans l’Antiquité. Identité et multiculturalité, Archimède. Archéologie et histoire ancienne 6, 144-159. Search in Google Scholar

Immerwahr H. R. 1986. “An archaic abacus from the sanctuary of Aphaia (Aegina, Aphaia Tempel IX)”, AA 195-204. Search in Google Scholar

Kidd S. 2017a. “Pente Grammai and the Holy Line”, BGSJ 11. Open access: https://www.degruyter.com/downloadpdf/j/bgs.2017.11.issue-1/bgs-2017-0004/bgs-2017-0004.pdf10.1515/bgs-2017-0004 Search in Google Scholar

Kidd S. 2017b. “How to gamble in Greek: The meaning of kubeia”, JHS 137, 119-134. Search in Google Scholar

Knoepfler D. 2000. Décrets érétriens de proxénie et de citoyenneté (Eretria XI), Lausanne. Search in Google Scholar

Kosmopoulou A. 2001. “ ‘Working women’: Female professionals on Classical Attic gravestones”, ABSA 96, 281-319.10.1017/S006824540000530X Search in Google Scholar

Kossatz-Deissman A. 1981. s.v. “Achilleus und Aias beim Brettspiel”, Lexicon Iconographicum Mythologiae Classicae (LIMC), I, Zürich, 96-101. Search in Google Scholar

Kwapisz J. 2000. “Socrates’ answer to the ultimate question of life, the universe, and everything: explaining the arithmetical riddles of AP 14”, AJP 141, 3, 457-486. Search in Google Scholar

Leipen N. et alii 1984. N. Glimpses of Excellence: A Selection of Greek Vases and Bronzes from the Elie Borowski Collection, Toronto. Search in Google Scholar

Macé A. 2022, in press. “Platon, Homère et les mathématiques militaires”, Mètis 17. Search in Google Scholar

Mackay A. E. 2010. Tradition and Originality, A Study of Exekias, Oxford.10.30861/9781407305684 Search in Google Scholar

Mathé V. 2009. “Un abaque à Delphes”, BCH 133, 1, 169-178. Search in Google Scholar

Massar N. 2019. “Jeux de pente grammai à Athènes”, V. Dasen (ed.), Ludique. Jouer dans l’Antiquité, Catalogue de l’exposition, Lugdunum-musée et théâtres romains, 20 juin-1er décembre 2019, Gent, 2019, 82-83. Search in Google Scholar

Menninger K. 1969. Number Words and Number Symbols. A Cultural History of Numbers, New York.10.2307/2799719 Search in Google Scholar

Meyer J.W. 1982. “Lebermodell oder Spielbrett”, R. Hachmann – R. Echt (eds), Bericht über die Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen in Kamid el Loz in den Jahren 1971 bis 1974, Bonn, 53-79. Search in Google Scholar

Mirabella Roberti M. 1976. “Sezione archeologica”, Museo Teatrale alla Scala (Musei e Gallerie di Milano), I, Milano. Search in Google Scholar

Nagl A. 1914. Die Rechentafel der Alten, Wien. Search in Google Scholar

Nelson M. 2020. “Battling on boards: The ancient Greek war games of Ship-Battle(Naumachia) and City-State (Polis)”, Mouseion ser. III, 17, 3–42. Search in Google Scholar

Netz R. 2002a. “Counter culture: towards a history of Greek numeracy”, History of Science, 40, 321-352. Search in Google Scholar

Netz R. 2002b. “Greek mathematicians: a group picture”, C. J. Tuplin – T. E. Rihll (eds), Science and Mathematics in Ancient Greek Culture, Oxford, 196-229. Search in Google Scholar

Nollé J. 2007. Kleinasiatische Losorakel: Astragal- und Alphabetchresmologien der hochkaiserzeitlichen Orakelrenaissance, München. Search in Google Scholar

Pritchett W.K. 1965. “Gaming tables and IG I2 324”, Hesperia 34, 1965, 131-147. Search in Google Scholar

Pritchett W.K. 1968. “ ‘Five Lines’ and IG I2 324”, California Studies in Classical Antiquity 1, 187-215. Search in Google Scholar

Rousset D. 2013. “Aus der Arbeit der ‘Inscriptiones Graecae’. Un abaque au monastère d’Hosios Loukas”, Chiron 43, 285-295. Search in Google Scholar

Sannibale M. 2018. “L’anfora firmata con Achille e Aiace dei Musei Vaticani”, Chr. Reusser – M. Bürge (eds), Exekias hat mich gemalt und getöpfert, Zurich, 112-126. Search in Google Scholar

Schädler U. 1998. “Mancala in Roman Asia Minor?”, BGSJ 1, 10-25. Search in Google Scholar

Schädler U. 2002. “The Talmud, Firdausî and the Greek Game City”, J. Retschitzki – R. Haddad-Zubel (eds), Step by Step, Proceedings of the 4th Colloquium Board Games in Academia, 91-102. Search in Google Scholar

Schädler U. 2000. “Sphärenschach”, Zeitschrift für Geschichte der Arabisch-Islamischen Wissenschaften 13, 205-244. Search in Google Scholar

Schädler U. 2009. “Pente grammai – The ancient Greek board game Five Lines”, J. Nuno Silva (ed.), Board Game Studies Colloquium XI, Lissabon, 169-192. Search in Google Scholar

Schädler U. 2016. “Der Spieltisch Im Peristylhof 38b”, E. Rathmayr (ed.), Hanghaus 2 in Ephesos. Die Wohneinheit 7: Baubefund, Ausstattung, Funde, Forschungen in Ephesos Band VIII/10, Wien, 519-523. Search in Google Scholar

Schädler U. 2019. “Une table de jeu en terre cuite au Musée Suisse du Jeu”, V. Dasen (ed.), Ludique. Jouer dans l’Antiquité, Catalogue de l’exposition, Lugdunum-musée et théâtres romains, 20 juin-1er décembre 2019, Gent, 98-99. Search in Google Scholar

Schärlig A. 2001a. Compter avec des cailloux, Lausanne. Search in Google Scholar

Schärlig A. 2001b. “Au Musée d’art et d’histoire de Genève, la plus ancienne Table de Pythagore connue”, Genava, revue d’histoire de l’art et d’archéologie 49, 139-142. Search in Google Scholar

Schwarzmeier A. 2014. “Votive relief 50 BC-50 AD”, N. Chr. Stampolidis – Y. Tassoulas (eds), Hygieia. Health, Ilness, Treatment from Homer to Galen, Catalogue oft he Exhibition, Museum of Cycladic Art, Athens, no. 217, 342-344. Search in Google Scholar

Seigle M. 2018. “Jouer avec les animaux”, S. Chevalier – Th. Wendling (eds), Jouer avec les animaux, ethnographiques.org, 36. Open access: https://www.ethnographiques.org/2018/Seigle Search in Google Scholar

Sidoli N. 2015. “Mathematics education”, W.M. Bloomer (ed.), A Companion to Ancient Education, Oxford, 387-400. Search in Google Scholar

Sidoli N. 2020. “Ancient Greek mathematics”, L. Taub (ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Ancient Greek and Roman Science, Cambridge, 185-207. Search in Google Scholar

Trendall A.D. 1987. “An early South Italian bell-krater”, Record of the Art Museum Princeton University 46, 2, 3-7. Search in Google Scholar

Ussing J.L.1884, Nye Erhvervelser til Antiksamlingen I Kjøbenhavn, Kjøbenhavn. Search in Google Scholar

Vespa M. 2020a. “La sagesse de Palamède : les dés, les pions et l’établissement d’un ordre (à propos de Philostrate, Sur les héros, 10 Follet)”, D. Bouvier – V. Dasen (eds), Héraclite : Le temps est un enfant qui joue, Collection Jeu/ Play/Spiel 1, Liège, 75-94. Search in Google Scholar

Vespa M. 2020b. “Les effets néfastes de la kubeia. Mise en jeu du prestige et de l’image sociale en Grèce classique”, V. Dasen – M. Vespa (eds), Bons ou mauvais jeux ? Pratiques ludiques et sociabilité, Pallas 114, 173-192. Search in Google Scholar

Vespa M. 2019. “Jouer avec un chien”, V. Dasen (ed.), Ludique. Jouer dans l’Antiquité, Catalogue de l’exposition, Lugdunum-musée et théâtres romains, 20 juin – 1er décembre 2019, Gent, 34-35. Search in Google Scholar

Vespa M. 2022, in press. “Variations de comportement et communautés anthropozoologiques dans l’Antiquité gréco-romaine : le cas du chien dit maltais”, E. Baratay (ed.), Les animaux historicisés. Penser leurs comportements dans le temps et l’espace, Paris. Search in Google Scholar

Vespa M. In preparation. “Les skirapheia entre Athéna et les jeux d’argent. Enquête sur une reconstruction mémorielle savante”, Kernos. Search in Google Scholar

Villanueva-Puig M.-C. 1989. “Le Vase des Perses. Naples 3253 (inv. 81947)”, REA 91, 277-298.10.3406/rea.1989.4387 Search in Google Scholar

Wendling Th. 2015. “Les origines ludiques de la notion de monnaie”, L’esprit du jeu. Jouer, donner, s’adonner, Revue du MAUSS 45, 191-213. Search in Google Scholar

Widura A. 2015, SpielRäume. Kulturhistorische Studien zum Brettspiel in archäologischen Kontexten, Rahden/Westf. Search in Google Scholar

Woodford S. 1982. “Ajax and Achilles playing a game on an olpe in Oxford”, JHS 102, 173-185. Search in Google Scholar

Zazoff P. 1968. Etruskische Skarabäen, Mainz. Search in Google Scholar

Zucker A. 2021. “Gloser n’est pas jouer. Les formules de jeux dans les recueils parémiographiques”, V. Dasen – M. Vespa (eds), Play and Games in Classical Antiquity: Definition, Transmission, Reception, Collection Jeu/Play/Spiel 2, Liège, 239-266. Search in Google Scholar

Artículos recomendados de Trend MD

Planifique su conferencia remota con Sciendo