Uneingeschränkter Zugang

Shedding light on neurocysticercosis misinformation in the media

, ,  und   
12. Dez. 2024

Zitieren
COVER HERUNTERLADEN

Recent research, published in the American Journal of Case Reports, examined the case of a 52-year-old American man without a recent travel history exhibiting atypical migraine symptoms which ultimately led to a diagnosis of neurocysticercosis (NC) (Byrnes et al., 2024). This neglected tropical disease is endemic in most countries in Asia, Sub-Saharan Africa, and Latin America, clearly linked to poor sanitation and hygiene practices, and free-range pig rearing, among other factors (Sciutto et al., 2000). Additionally, it is included in the PAHO/WHO action plan for its elimination (PAHO/WHO, 2016).

The casual agent of NC is Taenia solium (Cestoda, Cyclophyllidea, Taeniidae). This parasite's larvae migrates through the bloodstream of the human body, which is an accidental host, and eventually reaches the brain. However, it is also known to affect the eyes, liver, muscles, lungs, and kidneys, among other organs (CSPH et al., 2020). NC is a severe illness frequently associated with epilepsy, headaches, cognitive deficits, and stands as a leading cause of death among food-borne diseases (Havelaar et al., 2015). Given that the United States is not considered an endemic country, the story garnered worldwide attention from various digital media outlets. However, many of these reports have been characterized by a notable lack of scientific rigor, incorrectly attributing the condition to the consumption of undercooked pork.

Understanding the parasite's life cycle is crucial to contextualize the situation. Taeniosis occurs when individuals consume undercooked pork containing embedded larval cysts, known as cysticercus, which develop into adult tapeworms in the human small intestine. This presentation typically does not cause severe illness but can lead to occasional symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, loss of appetite, and weight loss. However, harbouring a single T. solium tapeworm poses a significant health risk, as humans may develop cysticercosis by ingesting T. solium eggs, typically transmitted through poor hygiene practices resulting in fecal-oral transmission (Nash et al., 2013). This can occur either by touching the hands of a carrier of the adult form with poor personal hygiene, or by consuming vegetables, fruits, or water contaminated by T. solium eggs. Additionally, pigs may ingest these eggs, which then develop into larvae, subsequently forming oncospheres, and eventually maturing into infective tapeworm cysts in their muscle (Fig. 1). The most common places to find these cysts are the psoas, masseters, triceps, tongue, diaphragm, and heart (Boa et al., 2002).

Fig. 1.

Taenia solium life cycle.

Byrnes et al. (2024) speculated on the possibility of the patient contracting NC through autoinfection due to improper handwashing after acquiring taeniosis from his eating habits. However, it should be noted that this is merely a hypothesis by the authors, who did not conclusively diagnose taeniosis in the patient. Furthermore, contracting the adult form of T. solium through pork consumption is limited to regions with inadequate sanitation measures, predominantly found in rural communities within endemic areas. Here, pigs are often raised close to households for self-consumption, without any veterinary control. Misinterpretation of information has caused the media to erroneously associate NC with the consumption of undercooked pork, as evidenced by several headlines in digital press platforms from various countries. Recent media coverage has showcased scientific publications concerning this disease, exemplified by the fatal case of an 18-year-old Indian male diagnosed with disseminated cysticercosis, presenting numerous well-defined cystic lesions in the brain (Dev & Abbas, 2019). This case attracted substantial media attention, with most outlets once again attributing the cause of the infection to pork consumption in their headlines. Some examples of the news that inaccurately echoed these case reports are displayed in Table 1.

Some examples of sensationalism news about different T. solium case reports in different countries.

Byrnes et al. 2024 Neurocysticercosis Presenting as Migraine in the United States
Date of publication 10/03/2024
Media Le Parisien
Country France
Headline “Des vers retrouvés dan le cerveau d'un homme qui avait mangé du bacon mal cuit”
Link https://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/des-vers-retrouves-dans-le-cerveau-dun-homme-en-floride-apres-quil-a-mange-du-bacon-mal-cuit-10-03-2024-YRV7SQHGYBGOLJ56KC23D7IMYI.php

Date of publication 10/03/2024
Media The National Desk (TND)
Country USA
Headline “Doctors discover man suffering from chronic migraines had worm eggs in his brain”
Link https://thenationaldesk.com/news/americas-news-now/doctors-discover-man-suffering-from-chronic-migraines-had-worm-eggs-in-his-brain-tapeworm-cyst-neurocysticercosis-bacon-pork-hospital-doctor-health-wellness-ct-mri-tests-swelling

Date of publication 12/03/2024
Media NBC News
Country USA
Headline “Man finds out migraines caused by tapeworms; undercooked bacon may be culprit”
Link https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/man-finds-migraines-caused-brain-tapeworms-undercooked-bacon-may-culpr-rcna143011

Date of publication 13/03/2024
Media The Guardian
Country UK
Headline “Tapeworms found in brain of US man who ate undercooked bacon”
Link https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/mar/13/brain-tapeworms-undercooked-bacon

Date of publication 14/03/2024
Media El Mundo
Country Spain
Headline “Hallan Tenia en el cerebro de un estadounidense que comió tocino poco hecho”
Link https://www.elmundo.es/ciencia-y-salud/2024/03/14/65f2a14a21efa05e448b4591.html

Date of publication 14/03/2024
Media TVI Notícias
Country Portugal
Headline “Este homem sofria de enxaquecas horríveis. Tinha larvas de ténia no cérebro. A causa? Bacon mal pasado”
Link https://tvi.iol.pt/noticias/dores-de-cabeca/enxaquecas/este-homem-sofria-de-enxaquecas-horriveis-tinha-larvas-de-tenia-no-cerebro-a-causa-bacon-mal-passado/20240314/65f30f9dd34e87e0c08abb2f

Date of publication 15/03/2024
Media News9Live
Country India
Headline “Bacon lovers, beware! Man complains of excruciating migraine pain after eating uncooked pork”
Link https://www.news9live.com/health/health-news/bacon-lovers-beware-man-complains-of-excruciating-migraine-pain-after-eating-uncooked-pork-2465479

Date of publication 16/03/2024
Media Corriere della Sera
Country Italy
Headline “Mal di testa causato da larve di verme solitario nel cervello: forse dopo aver mangiato pancetta poco cotta”
Link https://www.corriere.it/salute/24_marzo_16/mal-di-testa-larve-verme-solitario-nel-cervello-ee32ee06-72d3-44ab-9767-db43645c7xlk.shtml
Dev & Abbas 2019 Disseminated Cysticercosis
Date of publication 28/03/2019
Media Correio da Manhã
Country Portugal
Headline “Jovem morre com larvas acumuladas no cérebro por comer porco mal cozinhado”
Link https://www.cmjornal.pt/mundo/detalhe/jovem-morre-com-larvas-acumuladas-no-cerebro-por-comer-porco-mal-cozinhada

Date of publication 28/03/2019
Media New York Post
Country USA
Headline “Teen dies after brain infection from eating undercooked pork”
Link https://nypost.com/2019/03/28/teen-dies-after-brain-infection-from-eating-undercooked-pork/

Date of publication 28/03/2019
Media TN
Country Argentina
Headline “Comió carne de cerdo cruda y su cerebro se llenó de gusanos que le causaron la muerte”
Link https://tn.com.ar/salud/familia/2019/03/28/comio-carne-de-cerdo-cruda-y-su-cerebro-se-lleno-de-gusanos-que-le-causaron-la-muerte/

Date of publication 28/03/2019
Media Daily Mail
Country UK
Headline “How eating under cooked pork can kill you by invading your brain: Neural scans of ‘white spots’ reveal how teenager, 18, died when parasitic larvae built-up in his central nervous system and triggered deadly seizures”
Link https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-6859681/Man-18-dies-eating-undercooked-pork-caused-parasitic-larvae-invade-BRAIN.html

Date of publication 29/03/2019
Media Il Giornale
Country Italy
Headline “India, mangia carne di maiale poco cotta: 18enne ucciso dalla tenia”
Link https://www.ilgiornale.it/news/mondo/india-mangia-carne-maiale-poco-cotta-18enne-ucciso-tenia-1670578.html

Date of publication 29/03/2019
Media Doctissimo
Country France
Headline “Un jeune indien meurt d'une infestation de larves de ténia dan son cervau”
Link https://www.doctissimo.fr/sante/news/manger-porc-mal-cuit-mort

Date of publication 30/03/2019
Media El Comercio
Country Spain
Headline “Muere por un afectación de larvas en el cerebro tras comer carne cruda”
Link https://www.elcomercio.es/sociedad/muere-joven-afectacion-larvas-cerebro-carne-cruda-20190330063538-nt.html

Date of publication 01/04/2019
Media Sky News
Country UK
Headline “Man, 18, dies from tapeworm larvae in his brain after eating pork”
Link https://news.sky.com/story/man-18-dies-from-tapeworm-larvae-in-his-brain-after-eating-pork-11681211

Such cases are likely rooted in the viral dissemination of digital misinformation, a phenomenon in which media outlets propagate or amplify stories without conducting fact-checking or verification, merely echoing the narrative of the original source. Media coverage of medical issues sometimes introduces fake news driven by ignorance or sensationalism, as previously addressed by García and Del Brutto (2020) concerning other cases associated with NC. Humans navigate the world through a collective process of gathering, filtering, and disseminating information. The integrity of this process is crucial, as misinformation can have far-reaching consequences (West & Bergstrom, 2021), including in the realm of Global Health. The dissemination of inaccurate information regarding the detrimental health effects of consuming pork can also precipitate significant economic ramifications within the swine industry. Such misinformation may instigate consumer reluctance towards pork consumption, leading to decreased demand and subsequently impacting swine producers' revenue streams. Thus, the dissemination of accurate, clear, and well-contextualized information is vital to empower individuals against the spread of serious diseases like NC.

Finally, effective prevention can be achieved through targeted hygiene practices, including consistent handwashing, and ensuring raw vegetables and fruits are washed with potable water. Additionally, to prevent taeniosis in high-risk areas, it is recommended to cook whole cuts of meat to a minimum internal temperature of 145 °F (63 °C), and ground meats to 160 °F (71 °C), following CDC (2013) guidelines. Also, freezing pork at 39 °F (4 °C) for more than 1 month, or at −4 °F (−20 °C) for 1 – 3 days, is an effective measure to kill cysticerci (Sotelo et al., 1986).

Sprache:
Englisch
Zeitrahmen der Veröffentlichung:
4 Hefte pro Jahr
Fachgebiete der Zeitschrift:
Biologie, Zoologie, Ökologie, Biologie, andere, Medizin, Klinische Medizin, Mikrobiologie, Virologie und Infektionsepidemiologie