1. bookVolumen 43 (2021): Heft 1 (March 2021)
Zeitschriftendaten
License
Format
Zeitschrift
eISSN
2519-5808
Erstveröffentlichung
12 Apr 2017
Erscheinungsweise
3 Hefte pro Jahr
Sprachen
Englisch, Deutsch
access type Uneingeschränkter Zugang

Relational Determination in Interpersonal and Intrapsychic Experience

Online veröffentlicht: 30 Apr 2021
Volumen & Heft: Volumen 43 (2021) - Heft 1 (March 2021)
Seitenbereich: 121 - 141
Zeitschriftendaten
License
Format
Zeitschrift
eISSN
2519-5808
Erstveröffentlichung
12 Apr 2017
Erscheinungsweise
3 Hefte pro Jahr
Sprachen
Englisch, Deutsch
Summary

The task of this article is to review the principle of relational determination, as described by Solomon Asch (1952) which expands over Karl Duncker’s (1939) critique of ethical relativism. Relational determination has much to offer to the therapeutic community first with regard to interpersonal relations and social relations. My main goal is to extend this relational analysis to intrapsychic life, which may expose new potentialities for internal conflict resolution and personal integration, predicated on the cultivation of relational understanding (i.e., recognition of relational determination in organization of conscious experience). But this approach is best illustrated in its application to value differences and conflict across societies, which are typically viewed from the absolutist or relativist perspective.

The principle of relationality casts doubt on elementaristic assumptions common to both (e.g., meaning constancy). Such assumptions lead to some ill-considered conclusions: of irreconcilable moral differences dividing both individuals and groups, deprived of any basis in understanding. Those views fail to consider the contexts underlying the meanings and valuations we impute. When these are taken into account, Duncker’s hypothesis of an invariant relation between meaning and value finds support. Value differences (or changes) need not represent fundamental differences in morality, but instead (factual) differences in understanding of the situation. If so, then value differences may indeed be both understandable and reconcilable. Relational determination reveals this same potentiality with regard to intrapsychic conflict, where the same presumption of irreconcilable differences must be overcome. Work by Erich Neumann provides a valuable depth psychological perspective on this inner conflict, which accords surprisingly well with the relationality principle in particular and field theory in general. From that vantage point, psychological defenses may be recognized as structural properties of yet unreconciled psychical fields. Gestalt theory’s relational view, which aligns well with Neumann’s account of a “new ethic” helps to reveal the processes by which these defensive postures might abate, as value realms that earlier dwelt in hostile opposition develop more of a conscious and respectful relation with each other, as the individual inches toward greater wholeness.

Asch, S. E. (1952). Social psychology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.10.1037/10025-000 Search in Google Scholar

Böhm, A. (2021). Basic principles for therapeutic relationship and practice in gestalt theoretical psychotherapy. Gestalt Theory, 43(1).10.2478/gth-2021-0001 Search in Google Scholar

Duncker, K. (1939). Ethical relativity? (An enquiry into the psychology of ethics). Mind, 48, 39–57.10.1093/mind/XLVIII.189.39 Search in Google Scholar

Eliot, T. (1959). The Elder Statesman (p. 44). London, UK: Faber and Faber. Search in Google Scholar

Henle, M. (1961). Some effects of motivational processes on cognition. In M. Henle (Ed.), Documents of Gestalt Psychology (originally in Psychological Review, Vol 62, No. 6. 1955). University of California Press, 172–186.10.1525/9780520313514-014 Search in Google Scholar

Henle, M. (1962). Some aspects of the phenomenology of the personality. Psychologische Beiträge, VI(3–4), 395–404. Search in Google Scholar

Henle, M. (1971/1986). The snail beneath the shell. [orig. publ. Abraxis, Winter 1971] 1986 in: M. Henle, 1879 and all that: Essays in the Theory and History of Psychology. Columbia University Press, 172–189. Search in Google Scholar

Henle, M. (1977/1986). On the distinction between the phenomenal and the physical object. In: 1879 and all that: Essays in the theory and history of psychology. Columbia University Press: 1986 [orig. published in J. Nicholas, Images, Perception, and Knowledge. 1977. Search in Google Scholar

Köhler, W. (1947). Gestalt psychology (rev. ed.). New York, NY: Liveright. Search in Google Scholar

Köhler, W. (1966). The place of value in a world of facts. New York, NY: Liveright. (Original work published 1938). Search in Google Scholar

Montaigne, M. de (1942). Essays. Tr. by E. J. Trechmann (Vol. 1). New York, NY: Oxford University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Neumann, E. (1969/1990). Depth psychology and a new ethic. Boston, MA: Shambala. [Original published New York Putnam’s 1969]. Search in Google Scholar

Stemberger, G. (2013). Eine Besonderheit der psychotherapeutischen Situation. Phänomenal, 5(1-2), 27–31. Search in Google Scholar

Stemberger, G. (2014). Gestalttheoretische Aspekte der “Arbeit mit dem leeren Stuhl”. Phänomenal – Zeitschrift für Gestalttheoretische Psychotherapie, 6(1), 30–38. Search in Google Scholar

Stemberger, G. (2021). Ego and self in Gestalt theory. Gestalt Theory, 43(1).10.2478/gth-2021-0006 Search in Google Scholar

Sternek, K. (2021). Critical Realism: The epistemic position of Gestalt theoretical psychotherapy. Gestalt Theory, 43(1).10.2478/gth-2021-0004 Search in Google Scholar

Wertheimer, M. (1924 in 1944). Gestalt Theory. Translation of “Über Gestalttheorie” (Address, by MW, before the Kant Society, Berlin, 17th December, 1924) by N. Nairn-Allis 1944. Social Research, 11(1), 81–99. Search in Google Scholar

Empfohlene Artikel von Trend MD

Planen Sie Ihre Fernkonferenz mit Scienceendo