Uneingeschränkter Zugang

Participatory Budgeting as a Democratic and Managerial Innovation: Recent Trends and Avenues for Further Research5


Zitieren

Fig. 1:

Academic production.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)
Academic production.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)

Fig. 2:

A loess regression.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)
A loess regression.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)

Fig. 3:

A tree map.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)
A tree map.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)

Fig. 4:

Trending topics.Source: the present authors and Biblioshiny (based on the WoS database)
Trending topics.Source: the present authors and Biblioshiny (based on the WoS database)

Fig. 5:

Topic dendrogram.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)
Topic dendrogram.Source: the present authors (based on the WoS database)

Fig. 6:

Production in individual countries.Source: the present authors and Biblioshiny (based on the WoS database)
Production in individual countries.Source: the present authors and Biblioshiny (based on the WoS database)

Fig. 7:

Country collaboration map.Source: the present authors and Biblioshiny (based on the WoS database)
Country collaboration map.Source: the present authors and Biblioshiny (based on the WoS database)

Authors’ keywords in articles on PB.

Words Occurrences
Democracy 46
Governance 30
Porto Alegre 24
Politics 24
Citizen participation 21
Policy 21
Government 18
Framework 13
Management 12
Accountability 11
Brazil 10
Public participation 10
Decentralisation 9
Institutions 9
State 9
Civil society 8
Impact 8
Knowledge 8
Performance 8
Decision-making 7

The total number of articles published in each country.

Region Frequency
The United States 291
The United Kingdom 103
China 60
Spain 47
Canada 42
Brazil 37
Australia 36
Poland 31
Italy 23
Sweden 23
France 22
South Korea 19
Germany 17
The Netherlands 17
India 16
Thailand 16
Japan 13
Indonesia 12
Norway 12
Ukraine 11

The main information about the data.

Description Results
Main information about the data
Timespan 2001–2020
Sources (e.g. journals and books) 195
Documents 319
Average number of years since publication 6.05
Average number of citations per document 14.56
Average number of citations per document per year 1.7
References 12.17
Document types
Article 300
Article: book chapter 11
Article: proceedings paper 8
Document contents
Keywords plus (ID) 448
Authors’ keywords (DE) 921
Authors
Authors 668
Author appearances 773
Authors of single-authored documents 86
Authors of multi-authored documents 582
Authors’ collaboration
Single-authored documents 109
Documents per author 0.478
Authors per document 2.09
Co-authors per document 2.42
Collaboration index 2.77

Studies on PB.

Sources Articles
Environment and Urbanization 10
New Political Science 10
World Development 9
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 8
Sustainability 8
Journal of Civil Society 5
Local Government Studies 5
Administration and Society 4
Chinese Public Administration Review 4
Comparative Politics 4
Latin American Politics and Society 4
Politics and Society 4
Public Administration and Development 4
Public Performance and Management Review 4
Widening Democracy: Citizens and Participatory Schemes in Brazil and Chile 4
Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal 3
ACM Transactions on Intelligent Systems and Technology 3
Biodiversity and Conservation 3
European Journal of Operational Research 3
Habitat International 3

An overview of literature reviews (including embedded ones) focusing on PB (2000–2020).

Reference Year Type of work Field Main focus
Wampler 2007 ELR P The state and spread of PB
Van Cott 2008 ELR P Radical democracy
Matheus et al. 2010 ELR P Social control of the government in Latin America
Goldfrank 2011 ELR P The role of the left in deepening democracy
Verschuere et al. 2012 LR A Co-production
Scherer and Wimmer 2014 LR P ICTs and trust
Anessi-Pessina et al. 2016 LR A Public sector management accounting
Ebdon and Franklin 2006 ELR A The organisational capabilities of PB
Gerlit et al. 2017 LR A The barriers of PB
Wampler et al. 2018 ELR P The spread of PB
Omar et al. 2018 ELR P The engagement of citizens
Campbell et al. 2018 SR A The impact on health and well-being
Mancilla-García and Bodin 2019 ELR P Environmental governance
Cho et al. 2020 BA P PB
Falanga et al. 2020 ELR P The drivers of success of PB

A list of studies using the bibliometric method in public administration and accounting.

References Fields
Cho et al. (2020) PB in South Korea
Di Vaio et al. (2020) Sustainable business models
Zhao et al. (2019) Smart cities and participatory governance