Animal models of spinal cord injury (SCI) using contusion have been developed to mimic signs and symptoms similar to those seen after SCI in humans [1] because most SCIs in humans involve spinal cord contusion. Histopathology in these models show an intact dura and external aspects of the spinal cord, but an internal cystic cavity. The loss of motor
and sensory function correlates with the preservation of white and gray matter [2]. SCI causes cellular damage in the gray matter, and the loss of the functional ascending and descending axonal signals in the white matter depends on the severity of the lesion.
In contusion injury of the fifth cervical vertebra (C5), rats show clubbing of their forepaws and perturbed grasping ability [2]. A horizontal-ladder test is sufficiently sensitive enough to study forelimb functional deficits resulting from cervical injury, forelimb compensation, adaptation, and recovery [3]. In addition to loss of motor function, SCI can also cause loss of sensation or hypersensitivity to stimuli, and symptoms of pain [4]. To examine the somatosensory asymmetry after hemicontusion injury, a bilateral tactile stimulation test called the adhesive sticker removal task has been used [5].
The successful evaluation of any therapeutic regimen for SCI depends on the reliability and reproducibility of experimental animal models of SCI. The severity of the injury should be mild enough to allow recovery. However, to our knowledge, there have been no appropriate models to date, with which to study the behavioral consequences, anatomical changes, and susceptibility to a mild contusion at a cervical level. The initial mechanical disruption of tissue depends on the impact force delivered to the spinal cord and leads subsequently to complex histopathological changes and neurological impairment. In the present study, we used a weight-drop device adapted with a tip diameter smaller than that of commercial devices to induce a hemicontusion injury at C5 and generate a precisely located SCI lesion in rats. To evaluate the efficacy of the adapted device, a fixed weight was used and dropped from various heights, followed by behavioral tests and histopathology.
Male Sprague Dawley rats weighing 180–200 g were obtained from the National Laboratory Animal Center, Mahidol University, Nakhon Pathom, Thailand. The rats were housed in flat-bottom plastic cages with standard laboratory rat food and water available ad libitum and under a standard 12-h light– dark cycle, at 25 ± 1°C. Experiments were performed after the rats had been acclimated to their new environment in our laboratories for at least 1 week. All procedures followed the Institute of Laboratory Animal Resources, Commission on Life Sciences, National Research Council “Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals” Washington, D.C.: National Academy Press; 1996 and were approved by Animals Experiments Ethics Committee of Mahidol University (approval No. 013/2555).
The weight-drop device for SCI was adapted from that described by Soblosky et al. [3] (
The sterilized impactor rod was inserted into a plastic tube that was made from a 10 mL disposable pipette cut off at both ends. The rod fitted loosely and slid freely through the pipette at the lower end with minimal friction and without lateral movement. The upper part of the rod was held by a string attaching to a pulley. The tip of rod was at first placed gently on the upper surface of dura mater, and the rod was raised by the string to various heights (4 or 6 mm), and then the pulley was locked. The pulley was then unlocked to allow the rod to drop and contuse the cord, generating a SCI (
Surgery was performed under anesthesia using a mixture of ketamine (120 mg/kg) and xylazine (8.5 mg/kg). Using sterile technique throughout the surgery, the neck region was shaved and prepared aseptically for a midline dorsal skin incision that was made between the spinous processes of the C2 and C7 vertebrae; the trapezius was incised at the midline; and the underling paravertebral muscles at C4–C6 were resected to expose the spinal lamina. A bilateral laminectomy was performed at C5 to expose the dorsal aspect of the spinal cord. The spinal column was stabilized by rigidly clamping the vertebral body of C2 and the spinous process of the C7 vertebra with toothed forceps that were connected to the supporting arms of an instrument stand. The right side of the C5 spinal cord was contused with the tip of the metal rod that brought over the laminectomy site and set perpendicular to the surgical table (
Immediately after surgery the rats were kept under a heating lamp until they regained consciousness. For 5 days, the rats were received subcutaneous injections daily of 5% dextrose and 0.45% sodium chloride injection (5 mL), ampicillin (20 mg/kg), and tramadol (5 mg/kg). The rats were observed to ensure that they were able to eat and drink without assistance. Feed pellets were placed directly on the bedding, individual water bottles with sippers placed just above the level of the bedding. To stimulate appetites after surgery, high glucose cereals were offered. Their bladder function was assessed and the rats observed for micturition to ensure that there were no urination problems. Manual expression was used initially as necessary.
We allocated 15 adult male Sprague Dawley rats to 3 groups of 5 rats that would undergo the following treatments: laminectomy only or sham (SH), mild spinal cord injury (MSCI), or severe spinal cord injury (SSCI). To induce SCI, the metal rod was held at a 4 mm from the spinal cord for MSCI or 6 mm height for SSCI. The rats in the SH (laminectomy only) group served as controls. The rats were maintained for measurements for 5 weeks.
Rats were acclimatized to their environment and tested for somatosensory function. Two small pieces of self-adhesive paper (stickers, equal size, about 10 mm × 10 mm) were applied to the dorsum of each forepaw innervated by the C5 dermatome [6]. Adult rats normally touched and removed stickers with their teeth. The time to remove a sticker was recorded for each forepaw, and the latency time from initial contact to removal was calculated. The time limit of the trial to remove the stickers was 120 s. Each animal underwent 3 trials. If a sticker fell off, the trial was repeated. Trials without either contact or removal within 2 min were recorded as lasting 121 s [5, 7]. The adhesive sticker removal task was evaluated at 1 day before injury (day 1) and postinjury on days 3, 7, 14, 21, 28, and 35.
A horizontal ladder test was used to assess skilled locomotion. The horizontal wooden ladder used was 129.39 cm long and 16.51 cm wide, and 37 rungs (0.79 cm diameter) were inserted 2.5, 3.2, or 5.7 cm apart [3]. While rats crossing the ladder, was focused behavior on the side of the injury. The pattern of rungs was changed weekly to prevent animals from learning and adapting to the rung pattern.
Before injury, animals were allowed to explore the test apparatus freely to habituate for 10–20 min on the first day and tested preoperatively to establish a baseline (day 1) and postinjury on days 3, 7, 14, 21, 28, and 35. Rats were pretrained to traverse the horizontal ladder. Training comprised 3 trials per day for 2 days and then 1 trial a day until the test criterion was achieved. The test criterion was set at an ability to cross the ladder with no more than 1 forepaw misplacement for 5 consecutive trials. Rats were subsequently injured 3–5 days after reaching criterion and did not receive further training during this time [8].
The side of the rats ipsilateral to the injury was recorded with a Logitech Webcam Pro 9000 at 65 images per second to determine the type and number of forepaw placements that were counted by an evaluator who was blinded to the experimental group. The forepaw placements were analyzed and categorized as follows: correct placement, touch, slip, or miss (
The type of forepaw placement was recorded including whether the rats failed to place the palm of their paw directly onto the rung (
On day 35, rats of all groups were deeply anesthetized with an intramuscular injection of 120 mg/kg of ketamine combined with xylazine 8.5 mg/kg. Each rat was perfused transcardially with 500 mL of saline solution, then followed by 500 mL of 4% paraformaldehyde solution. After perfusion, 3 segments (1 cm each) of the spinal cord were removed and indicated as lesion segment, rostral penumbra, and caudal penumbra [10]. The segments were fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde overnight and then dehydrated in a graded series of ethanol solutions and embedded in paraffin.
Transverse sections of the lesion segment were cut at 16
Differences between groups were compared using a one-way ANOVA followed by a Tukey post hoc test for multiple comparisons or using independent sample
After injury, all SCI rats showed the paralysis of digits known as “clubbing” on the ipsilateral side and a normal forepaw on the contralateral side (
For the adhesive paper (sticker) removal task, on 1 day before surgery (day 1) all rats used the least amount of time to remove sticker (
For the horizontal ladder test, the characteristics of forepaw placements on rungs are presented (
On day 1 (the day before treatment), the error scores (
The percentage of the total rungs used (
The percentage of the correct placement (
The type of forepaw placement was used to analyze skilled locomotor function (
The adapted weight-drop device produced graded hemicontusion injury as shown by the various sizes and the site of the cystic cavity on the ipsilateral side of the spinal cord at C5 (
MSCI rats showed the intact dura and external surface of spinal tissue. The cystic cavity was shown in the ipsilateral side of the spinal cord. The cystic cavity was located in dorsolateral funiculus.
SSCI also showed the intact dura mater and external surface of spinal tissue, but a larger ipsilateral cystic cavity located in the dorsolateral funiculus, ventral lateral funiculus, and gray matter of the spinal cord.
Contusion caused by a dropped weight in models of SCI has been used extensively, and suggests the efficacy of mild contusion of SCI at the thoracic level to demonstrate transient behavioral deficits proceeding to near-complete recovery [11]. In the present study, the adapted weight-drop device mimics a situation such as an injury caused by a motor vehicle accident where the spinal vertebrae break and exert pressure on a part the of spinal cord generating a force that will cause a contusion injury to the cord.
The efficacy of mild hemicontusion of SCI in the cervical level was evaluated using sensory and motor functional deficits. The adhesive sticker removal task by rats with either MSCI and SSCI at day 14 after injury showed a removal time similar to that by rats in the SH group, and indicates sensory recovery within 14 days.
The horizontal ladder test had been used to evaluate skilled locomotor function as previously reported after a study of the contributions of supraspinal motor pathways on forelimb function following cervical hemicontusion [9]. In the present study, the error scored, the percentage of total rungs used, and forelimb contact, which indicated a dysfunctional forelimb, showed the characteristics of graded injury. Rats with SSCI showed a greater severity of motor dysfunction with an increase in error scores and the percentage of total rungs used, and decrease in the percentage of correct paw placement. Normal recovered placement of paw on rungs (Type II) was observed on day 7 after injury, and recovery was faster for rats with MSCI than it was for rats with SSCI. Histopathology indicated the size and site of lesion (indicated by the cystic cavity) in rats with either MSCI or SSCI could be localized with specificity that did not involve the dorsal column of the spinal cord. The lesion site in the rats with MSCI showed the cystic cavity in the dorsolateral funiculus. Onifer et al. reported that the dorsolateral funiculi do not transmit forepaw sensory information [12]. They also suggested that dorsolateral funiculus motor tract injuries do not interfere with the rat’s ability to remove the adhesive stickers [12]. Therefore, the somatosensory sensation was affected only for about the first week after the injury caused by the surgical procedures including the laminectomy and all groups showed complete recovery in 14 days.
After injury, rats showed a clubbing forepaw on their ipsilateral side and normal forepaw at contralateral side. McKenna et al. [13] suggested that an injury at the level of the C5 vertebra causes damage to descending inputs to motor neuron pools that supply digital flexors of the ipsilateral forepaw. The lesion was unilateral; therefore, the contralateral forepaw was assessed as an internal normal control. In SSCI the greater force of the weight drop would produce larger lesion which involved the dorsal longitudinal fasciculus, ventrolateral funiculus, and most of the gray matter. By contrast, a smaller lesion size involving more specific tracts would be more useful because it would allow rats to perform better in specific behavioral tasks. To evaluate motor dysfunction in rats with SCI that were unable to remove a sticker, only the latency of initial contact to sense the stimulus can be used rather than the time to remove the sticker.
In the rats with MSCI group, the cystic cavity located in the dorsolateral funiculus involved the corticospinal and rubrospinal tract. The corticospinal and rubrospinal tracts have been implicated in initiating and modulating voluntary and goal-directed skilled movements [3, 14]. Dunham et al. reported that the horizontal ladder test requires 3 sequences of movement: (1) aiming of the limb to the rung, this sequence requires proximal muscle contraction to swing the limb to the appropriate rung [9]. The proximal muscle contraction is supplied by vestibulospinal and reticulospinal pathways that are located at ventromedial funiculi [15]. (2) Placement of the paw on the rung, requiring tactile stimulation [9]. The fasciculus cuneatus located in the dorsal column is associated with tactile sensation response, injuries to this area may contribute to loss of placing response [12]. (3) Grasping the rung is associated with the coordination between paw flexors and extensors [9]. These muscles were supplied by rubrospinal and corticospinal tracts, and the motor neuron pools at the level of the C5 vertebra that are correlated with skilled and goal movement, and grip strength [15, 16]. Using a modified tip with a small diameter in the adapted weight-drop device may contribute to MSCI for studies of recovery because the lesion site and size was appropriate for specific evaluation of the histopathological and functional recovery from SCI. A limitation of the small tip is that it may cause only partial functional deficit that is difficult to evaluate in smaller or larger experimental animals. Therefore, tip size should be optimized for the size of the animals before the weight-drop device is used for experiments.
A limitation of the present technique is that the results are highly variable. The error bars that represent SEM are large, especially in
The adapted weight-drop device is suitable for creating a rat model of SCI. The device is simple, reliable, and consistently produces a mild degree of injury. Mild deficits may be useful for evaluating therapeutic interventions for SCI.