A crucial scene in the Swedish television series
The Nordic countries conceive of themselves as highly ecologically conscious. The consistent pursuit of an ecologically sustainable societal model is clearly illustrated by the 2017 Nordic Council of Ministers’ campaign,
The paradoxical coexistence in the Scandinavian collective consciousness of the environmentalist self-perception and the disturbing awareness of the detrimental effects human industrial activity has on the “nationalized nature” (Kääpä, 2014: 12) has lent itself to a large array of literary and cinematic interpretations, the importance of which cannot be overestimated. In their recent edited volume, Critical interdisciplinary exploration of the diversity of Nordic ecocinema can not only make a significant contribution to the study of Nordic cultures, but also to bring back political participation to a field which has lost some of its explicit engagement with political issues.
Remarkably, eco-critical fiction has been rather late to come to television and has only recently been taken up as a worthy subject for the internationally acclaimed Nordic Noir quality serial drama. The most illuminating examples of this newly kindled interest in environmental problematics are the Norwegian series It is worth noting that the Nordic region is not unique in picking up ecocritical narrative as a topic for the serial drama. To name but a few successful examples, the intention to articulate critique towards humanity's destructive impact on the natural world resonates at the core of the Australian drama
The fast-growing field of ecocinema scholarship has demonstrated that “it is important, in an era of expanding media universes, that critics look at mainstream as well as alternative uses of visual media” (Ivakhiv, 2008: 24) in order to “actively disrupt the distinctions and assumptions generated by traditional genre focus” (Rust & Monani, 2013: 4), and to broaden our understanding of all cinema as “ecologically embedded” (Rust & Monani 2013: 4). Expanding generic boundaries further, Julia Leyda (2016: 16–17) asserts that popular “quality” television series often bear textual and visual traces of what she calls the “climate unconscious”, fostering baseline awareness of the anthropogenic footprint even when their narratives do not explicitly revolve around environmental issues. Although, as David Ingram (2013) notes, (eco)critical cultural meanings may not be always acknowledged by viewers depending on their prior predispositions and training, various modes of these texts’ circulation together with the heterogeneity of their audiences always encourage multiple interpretations, and it is within this dynamic cultural field that dominant ideologies can be both reasserted and contested (cf. Hall, 1980). Leyda rightly contends that “engrossing audiences in […] fictional narrative means allowing them to process emotionally the implications of what they may well already know via facts and figures” (Leyda, 2016: 14). In line with this special issue's take on television as a part of the “discursive battlefield of global politics” (Saunders, 2017: 983), I would also like to point out that the growing global appreciation of dramatic serials makes them particularly well suited for influencing multiple audiences’ understanding of how the world works and what it will become. The long-term engagement with the televisual form of storytelling, moreover, increases viewers’ cognitive and affective investment in the narrative conflicts, thus endowing television with an even more powerful pedagogical potential compared to cinema. Representing this new generation of transnationally distributed and consumed popular narratives,
Already in the early stages of the narrative, viewers are given an inkling of Why do you think Silverhöjd forest remained untouched for such a long time? It stayed that way until your father took it over. And now yet another child is missing. There are forces in nature that can become dangerous if you harm them. Believe me or not, but you are in danger as long as you stay here.
Several years previously, Gran had been in charge of the failed investigation into the disappearance of Eva's six-year-old daughter Josefine during a picnic at the Silverhöjd lake. Today, Eva returns to her hometown to arrange her father's funeral but decides to stay when she learns that a young boy has gone missing in the Silverhöjd forest in a similar way to Josefine. It transpires that long before his death, Eva's father, who owned the Thörnblad cellulose and mining company, violently cleared vast expanses of the forest, destroying all living organisms and thus transgressing the mythical laws of nature according to which “the people of the woods” lived in harmony with humans since the ebbing of the last Ice Age, when Scandinavia was first settled. Eva is thus led to believe that her daughter was abducted by the old forest inhabitants as a gesture of retaliation for the historical ecocide. The more recent abduction also seems to have a causal connection with the current company board's plans for invasive mining activities which present a major threat to the precarious environmental balance.
What stands out in the above quotes is the notion of different genres brought together in a particular constellation. Genre hybridity, a phenomenon frequently practiced in cinema to achieve broad resonance across genre boundaries and audience groups (cf. Altman, 1999; see also Wright, 2010, for a Scandinavian example) has by now also become a well-established trend in transnational television drama because “producer risk is perceived to be reduced if elements of previously successful TV vehicles might be woven together in a new, and hopefully even more colourful, braid” (Nelson, 2015: 10). By transcending genre-specific expectations, each unique melange of innovative and familiar generic features possesses a capacity not only to ensure richer viewer demographics but, more importantly, also to open up uncountable productive spaces for multilayered and complex narrative structures and engage audiences on intellectual and affective levels. And it is exactly this layering, in
As Amitav Ghosh contends in his seminal book, There is power in fantasy, especially in stories that urge us to face the impossible or find ways to survive […]. The best stories take us inside of storytelling so seamlessly, that when we emerge, the impossible is easier to imagine. This fiction creates a space in our minds to consider other perspectives and adopt new solutions.
The close reading of certain thematic and visual tropes in
In 1994, Lars von Trier directed a four-part television mini-series
The comparison to
On the one hand, the realistic depiction of the economically motivated crime drives the ecological message home with acute precision. From the start, we are made cognisant of the approaching catastrophe as a direct repercussion of the Thörnblad company board's decision to ignore the outcomes of the geophysical survey, according to which the continuation of mining operations in the Silverhöjd's area would drastically augment the risks of land dislocation and earthquakes. In spite of this knowledge, the company's present CEO, Gustav Borén, is shown intimidating and bribing the environmental inspector in order to push his industrial plan through. On the other hand, as the opening sequence foreshadows, multiple leads in the crime investigation are inexplicably lost in the Silverhöjd forest, prompting the police to acknowledge that they need to “think bigger”. When, in episode 2, Eva hears Gran's emphatic assertion that her father's ruthless violation of the centuries-old treaty between humans and nature triggered the wrath of the forest, resulting in harm to the local community, we have little doubt as to the true reason of the present predicament. Instead of reproducing the conventional movement through which “actual landscapes become symbolic landscapes” (Meinig, 1979: 174), the forest in
As one of the most classic folktale landscapes, the forest is strongly associated in the popular imagination with unconscious, forbidden desires, adventure, secret forces, inexplicable phenomena, and rites of initiation. As “a passage-way of particular importance” (Messerli, 2005: 274), the forest is a space where protagonists of many folkloric stories must journey in order to discover their destiny and place in the world. It is often there that they gain a sense of what is to be done. In his book, The forest is always large, immense, great, and mysterious. No one ever gains power over the forest, but the forest possesses the power to change lives and alter destinies. In many ways it is a supreme authority on earth and often the great provider.
This rich imagery owes its potency to the fact that, since primeval times, forests have constituted a distinct characteristic of northern Europe's geographical and cultural space. According to cultural historian and literary scholar Robert Pogue Harrison (1992: ix):
Western civilization literally cleared its space in the midst of forests. A sylvan fringe of darkness defined the limits of its cultivation, the margins of its cities, the boundaries of its institutional domain; but also the extravagance of its imagination.
In the same vein, fantasy writer Sara Maitland contends that forest imagery has been particularly productive for northern European folklore's themes and ethics exactly because of a forest's easy availability as a suitable location for fantastic events: “The forest is the place of trial in fairy stories, both dangerous and exciting. Coming to terms with the forest, surviving its terrors, utilizing its gifts, and gaining its help is the way to ‘happy ever after’” (Maitland, 2012: 8).
The aforementioned views imply that in fairytales and myths, landscapes possess an equal and sometimes even greater power than people, and magic events usually occur through “contacts with the inhuman – trees and creatures, unseen forces” (Byatt, 2003: para. 6). In spite of presenting simplified versions of nature,
for audiences seeking entertainment but also a fairy tale format through which they can make sense of, and critique, today's social order, landscapes reflective of not only our cultural past but also current social realities and spatial relationships are used.
The emphasis put in critical literature on “the reciprocal relationship between place and imagination” (Brace & Johns-Putra, 2010: 20) as being always realised within a specific frame of sociocultural conditions also suggests that conventional popular tropes are prone to historical change and can be reconfigured into a new natural iconography to reflect today's cultural anxieties, one of which is environmental crisis. Seen through this contemporary lens, locally produced and circulated ancient legends about nature can become intelligible for a much larger diversity of audiences and even acquire transnational currency.
Using the immense dark forest as the main location of a Swedish television series is not surprising. I think Sweden is 80% forest or something like that – it's crazy! So the forest, of course, is part of our national identity and we have these beautiful forests to submerge ourselves into. I think the audiences are going to be seduced by that setting as well.
Indeed, as journalist and writer Maciej Zaremba reminds us, for Swedish people, forests constitute a natural arena for the multitude of daily practices and routines. Accordingly, the most preferred living location in Sweden is a luxuriant green area at the verge of a wood and a sizable distance from other dwellings to ensure privacy, and the most popular pastime is a contemplative healthy walk in a tree-rich environment (Zaremba, 2013). Zaremba also notes that forests are perceived to be the stronghold of Sweden's cultural origins and the so-called national spirit. One of the markers of this deeply-rooted collective identification is the fact that many Swedish surnames contain references to various tree species and types of wood. It should be noted that such identification with the natural environment is not a uniquely Swedish phenomenon. Dianne Harris (2008: 193), for one, has argued that the sense of the personal and the national self can often be “produced through sets of mediated experiences in which both the particular and general characteristics of our surroundings play a part”.
Indeed, the Silverhöjd forest in
Although the ultimate truth about the historic ecocide that made the ancient forest tribes perish would be revealed only towards the end of season two, and as such reaches beyond the scope of this article, it deserves noting that the narrative of the series consistently subverts traditional presentations of supernatural characters as dangerous monsters. Instead, it emphasises time after time the ability of humankind to relentlessly infringe on, cause harm to, and even eradicate other Earth species, be they mythical or real. The story of the näcken is particularly illuminating in this sense. The spirit emerges in the shape of a gigantic greenish-white male figure, with fins instead of hands. In the first episode, it is shot at with a rifle by the local youths playing in the woods and is shortly after killed by the water turbine on the premises of the Thörnblad company. The näcken's tragic fate foreshadows the town's subsequent ordeals, which include the contamination of the water in the sylvan stream and in the Silverhöjd lake. Another detail worth mentioning is that when the creature's dead body is laid out at the pathologist's table, it literally loses its form and dissolves into a slimy yellow matter. In an uncanny way, the scene is evocative of Timothy Morton's remark that in order to learn how to deal with contemporary ecological problematics, environmental imagery should not be limited to the contemplation of “pretty or sublime pictures of nature”, but needs to concentrate on the formless, the miasmic, and the polluted, that is, “to hold the slimy in view” (Morton, 2015: 250). In other words, in order to learn how to think ecologically, we should not content ourselves with the aesthetical consumption of beautiful natural scenery from the comfortably distant spectatorial position, but need to fully comprehend our intrinsic entanglement with other (non-human) ecologies and species, including “things that glisten, schlup, and decay” (Morton, 2015: 250). Morton's views have immediate implications for the next section, which will further unpack the role of the Silverhöjd forest not only as the story's evocative setting, but as its central character and the active proponent of ecological thought.
Despite many critical dimensions a real (or imaginary) forest displays in European – and in particular Swedish – culture, the previous descriptions still conceive of it as a natural backdrop for human activity. Yet, a thorough analysis of Interestingly, as Ruth McElroy (2013: para. 10) points out, this “aesthetic sensibility (wide angle shots cinematically showing bare and evocative landscapes …) come to be increasingly seen as a measure of [the local places’] transnational appeal”, which suggests that the Swedish forest in Jordskott operates both as a distinctly local setting and as an object of the transnational (tourist) gaze.
In a smooth oscillation between the generic conventions of Nordic Noir and horror, the Lefebvrian mode of detached contemplation (to which Morton is so insistently opposed in his ecological writing) Morton emphasises that sitting back and contemplating environmental crises will not provide humankind with sustainable solutions. To that effect, he contends: “At some level, respecting other species and ecosystems involves a choice. This choice is saturated with contingency (it is our choice) and desire (we want something to be otherwise). There is no place outside the sphere of this contingent choice from which to stand and assess the situation – no ‘nature’ outside the problem of global warming that will come and fill us in on how to vote” (Morton, 2015: 255).
We discover that many glamorous images of nature, which initially seemed to be included to facilitate transitions between scenes and to serve as intermezzos – or
Especially indicative are the successions of takes allowing the panoramic views to be followed by the medium and close-up shots of the thick formations of bushes and trees and, shortly after, by the images of cut tree trunks and barren sandy spots covered with dead, mouldy branches. In a number of such sequences, the final frame shows the crumpled leaflet, with a photograph of the missing boy Anton Leander, stuck in the broken twigs and dry leaves scattered on the ground. While Eva and the police persist in their pursuit of a human perpetrator, we are led to understand that the string of unexplained murders, deaths, and abductions is provoked by the years of Thörnblad factory's relentless encroachment on the forest's vulnerable ecology. Popular ecodrama usually shows the moment of the human protagonist's coming across the theatre of environmental destruction as a starting point of their journey to ecological awareness. In
Recent works of Andrew Smith, William Hughes, and David del Principe illuminate “how current ideas about Ecocriticism can be applied to Gothic narratives in order to help draw on their often dystopian ecological visions” (Smith & Hughes, 2013: 4). By complementing ecocriticism with ideas from posthumanism, ecofeminism, and animal studies, eco-Gothic ultimately seeks to challenge the anthropocentric gaze on nature and to (re)consider and (re)formulate theories about environmental and species’ identities (Del Principe, 2014). This line of enquiry is much indebted to Morton's ecological insights, and in particular to his assertion that the scope and complexity of the environmental crisis cannot be apprehended in a single glance (Morton, 2013, 2016). To theorise this, Morton invokes the notion of the Anthropocene, which was first introduced in 2000 by Paul Crutzen and Eugene Stoermer (2000) to denote the advent of a new geological epoch. The scholars argued that the impact of human activity has radically altered the Earth's ecosystems and climate and thus ended the Holocene during which major human civilizations developed over centuries.
In
This is exactly when the Gothic intrigue gains momentum. And although contemporary Scandinavian horror is known to always be substantially place-oriented (cf. Leffler, 2013), the series surpasses the usual tendency to relate the landscape's terrifying interventions with the human endeavour to the forgotten knowledge of the pre-Christian pagan and mythical past. The agonising past it invokes is by no means far removed from the people's memory. What is more, regardless of the growing protests of the town's inhabitants, similar catastrophic events threaten to be repeated in the present. And yet, the Silverhöjd forest succeeds in defying its oppressive status of an industrial object, or a piece of domesticated nature, analogous to the landscape paintings adorning the police station's walls. Instead, it positions itself as a vengeful agent taking hostages and disrupting the allegedly harmonious existence of the community. While the human protagonists struggle to perceive the totality of the pending environmental disaster, the forest sets out to direct their decisions and behaviour.
The absence of a human offender to account for the children's abductions enables
As a part of the transnationally influential corpus of Nordic television drama with its rigorous attention to the world's most pressing cultural anxieties,
Finally, the later emulation of the genre-blending approach and the creative take on telefantasy by other successful series, for instance