P-FA | The problem of matching the frame data and the frame count when the frame is lost is not solved | [ |
Large amount of calculation, not easy to promote | [ |
|
P-TCMA | The number of data positions is wrong when the frame is dropped | [ |
Data transmission delay is not considered | [ |
|
P-ECA | Depends on device index value | [ |
Frame count error has not been resolved | [ |
|
No consideration of transmission delay | [ |
|
Large amount of calculation, not easy to promote | [ |
PSF-QEA | Data error does not affect the frame length, causing quality misjudgment. | [ |
To solve the judgment error caused by dropped frames | [ |
|
PFF-QEA | Unsolved the problem of different comparison results caused by dropped frames and errors | [ |
The assessment basis is relatively simple | [ |
|
Not given due to frame loss | [ |
|
Data preprocessing requirements are high, and the incomplete F-frame data is discarded, which is not conducive to the full use of data. | [ |
|
PSF-QEA | The calculation is cumbersome and not easy to promote | [ |
Cluster center radius is not easy to choose | [ |
帧序号 | 测站 A | 测站 B | 融合结果 | 正确 |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 28586 | 65530 | 28586 | 65530 |
2 | 65531 | 65467 | 65467 | 65531 |
3 | 65532 | 65356 | 65356 | 65532 |
4 | 65523 | 65533 | 65523 | 65533 |
FF-QEA | The system overhead is large, and when the amount of data increases, the information is too late to process. | [ |
Accurate quality evaluation when errors occur in unresolved frame counts | [ |
|
SF-QEA | Increased algorithm time complexity | [ |
基于全帧的实时质量评估算法 | 系统开销大,数据量增大时,信息来不及处理 | [ |
未解决帧计数出现误码时的精确质量评估 | [ |
|
基于子帧的实时质量评估算法 | 算法时间复杂度增加 | [ |
基于选段的事后质量评估算法 | 数据误码并不 影响帧长度,造成质量误判。 | [ |
为解决丢帧引起的评判失误 | [ |
|
基于全帧的事后质量评估算法 | 未解决丢帧误码引起的对比结果均不相同的问题 | [ |
评估依据较为单一 | [ |
|
未给出丢帧引起的 | [ |
|
数据预处理要求较高,丢弃残缺的全帧数据,不利于数据的充分利用。 | [ |
|
基于子帧的事后质量评估算法 | 计算繁琐,不易推广 | [ |
聚类中心半径不易选取 | [ |
1 | 28586 | 65530 | 28586 | 65530 |
2 | 65531 | 65467 | 65467 | 65531 |
3 | 65532 | 65356 | 65356 | 65532 |
4 | 65523 | 65533 | 65523 | 65533 |
事后标志位对齐 | 未解决丢帧时的帧数据与帧计数的匹配问题 | [ |
计算量大,不易于推广 | [ |
|
事后时码匹 配对齐 | 丢帧时数据位置数出错 | [ |
未考虑数据传输时延 | [ |
|
事后误差控 制对齐 | 依赖设备指标值 | [ |
帧计数误码尚未解决 | [ |
|
未考虑传输时延 | [ |
|
计算量较大,不易于推广 | [ |
实时标志位 对齐 | 帧计数误码影响较大 | [ |
累积错误 | [ |
|
实时时码匹配对齐 | ||
未考虑主站传输时延 | [ |
|
实时误差控 制对齐 | 子帧时码延时计算未解决 | [ |
依赖设备指标值 | [ |