1. bookVolume 8 (2018): Issue 3-4 (December 2018)
Journal Details
License
Format
Journal
First Published
16 Apr 2016
Publication timeframe
2 times per year
Languages
English
access type Open Access

The challenge of brain death for the sanctity of life ethic

Published Online: 31 Dec 2018
Page range: 153 - 165
Journal Details
License
Format
Journal
First Published
16 Apr 2016
Publication timeframe
2 times per year
Languages
English

For more than thirty years, in most of the world, the irreversible cessation of all brain function, more commonly known as brain death, has been accepted as a criterion of death. Yet the philosophical basis on which this understanding of death was originally grounded has been undermined by the long-term maintenance of bodily functions in brain dead patients. More recently, the American case of Jahi McMath has cast doubt on whether the standard tests for diagnosing brain death exclude a condition in which the patient is not dead, but in a minimally conscious state. I argue that the evidence now clearly shows that brain death is not equivalent to the death of the human organism. We therefore face a choice: either we stop removing vital organs from brain dead patients, or we accept that it is not wrong to kill an innocent human who has irreversibly lost consciousness.

Keywords

AVIV, R. (2018): What does it mean to die? In: New Yorker, February 5.Search in Google Scholar

BEECHER, H. (1967): Henry Beecher to Robert Ebert. In: D. Rothman (1991): Strangers at the Bedside. New York: Basic books, pp. 160–161.Search in Google Scholar

ENGELHARDT, T., Jr. (1975): Defining death: A philosophical problem for medicine and law. In: American Review of Respiratory Disease, 112(5), pp. 587–590.Search in Google Scholar

GREEN, M. & WIKLER, D. (1980): Brain Death and Personal Identity. In: Philosophy and Public Affairs, 9(2), pp. 105–133.Search in Google Scholar

GRIZEZ, G. & BOYLE, J. (1979): Life and Death with Liberty and Justice. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.Search in Google Scholar

JOHNSTON, M. (1987): Human beings. In: Journal of Philosophy, 84(2), pp. 59–83.Search in Google Scholar

KUHSE, H. (1987): The Sanctity-of-Life Doctrine in Medicine: A Critique. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

LAMB, D. (1985): Death, brain death and ethics. London: Croom Helm.Search in Google Scholar

LIZZA, J. (2006): Persons, Humanity, and the Definition of Death. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.Search in Google Scholar

LIZZA, J. (2018): Defining Death: Beyond Biology. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 1–19.Search in Google Scholar

MACHADO, C. (1995): A New Definition of Death Based on the Basic Mechanism of Consciousness Generation in Human Beings. In: C. Machado (ed.): Brain Death: Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on Brain Death. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 57–66.Search in Google Scholar

MCMAHAN, J. (1995): The Metaphysics of Brain Death. In: Bioethics, 9(2), pp. 91–126.Search in Google Scholar

MILLER, F. & TRUOG, R. (2011): Death, Dying, and Organ Transplantation. New York: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

PRESIDENT’S COMMISSION FOR THE STUDY OF ETHICAL PROBLEMS IN MEDICINE (1981): Defining Death: A Report on the Medical, Legal and Ethical Issues in the Determination of Death. Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office.Search in Google Scholar

PRESIDENT’S COUNCIL ON BIOETHICS (2008): Controversies in the Determination of Death. Washington, [online] [Retrieved August 30, 2018]. Available at: https://bioethicsarchive.georgetown.edu/pcbe/reports/death/Search in Google Scholar

REPETINGER, S. (2006): Long Survival Following Bacterial Meningitis-Associated Brain Destruction. In: Journal of Child Neurology, 21(7), pp. 591–595.Search in Google Scholar

REPORT OF THE AD HOC COMMITTEE OF THE HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL (1968): A Definition of Irreversible Coma. In: Journal of the American Medical Association, 205(6), pp. 337–340.Search in Google Scholar

SHEWMON, D. A. (1998a): Chronic ‘Brain Death’: Meta-Analysis and Conceptual Consequences. In: Neurology, 51(6), pp. 1538–1545.Search in Google Scholar

SHEWMON, D. A. (1998b): ‘Brain-stem death’, ‘brain death’ and death: a critical re-evaluation of the purported equivalence. In: Issues in Law & Medicine, 14(2), pp. 125–145.Search in Google Scholar

SHEWMON, D. A. (1999): Chronic ‘Brain Death’: Meta-Analysis and Conceptual Consequences [response to letters]. In: Neurology, 53(6), pp. 1369–1372.Search in Google Scholar

SHEWMON, D. A. (2001): The Brain and Somatic Integration: Insights into the standard biological rationale for equating ‘brain death’ with death. In: Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 26(5), pp. 457–478.Search in Google Scholar

SHEWMON, D. A. (2012): You only die once: why brain death is not the death of a human being. In: Communio, 39(2), pp. 423–494.Search in Google Scholar

SHEWMON, D. A. (2018): Truly Reconciling the Case of Jahi McMath. In: Neurocritical Care, 29(2), pp. 165–170.Search in Google Scholar

SINGER, P. (1995): Rethinking life and death. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

THE PROLONGATION OF LIFE: AN ADDRESS OF POPE PIUS XII TO INTERNATIONAL CONGRESS OF ANAESTHESIOLOGISTS (1957): In: The Pope speaks, p. 396.Search in Google Scholar

THOMAS, A. G. (2012): Continuing the Definition of Death Debate: The Report of the President’s Council on Bioethics on Controversies in the Definition of Death. In: Bioethics, 26(2), pp. 101–107.Search in Google Scholar

VEATCH, R. (1975): The whole-brain-oriented concept of death: An outmoded philosophical formulation. In: Journal of Thanatology, 3(1), pp. 13–30.Search in Google Scholar

Recommended articles from Trend MD

Plan your remote conference with Sciendo