International and Comparative Law Review

Int. & Com. Law Rev.

<abstract><title style='display:none'>Abstract</title>European Court of Human Rights applies the margin of appreciation doctrine in order to determine the level of its self-restraint and the latitude of free discretion of states when implementing their Convention obligations. The rationale behind this doctrine is that in certain cases, domestic bodies are in a better position than international judges to provide adequate protection to human rights. In this regard, they should be afforded a margin of appreciation. The Court subsequently only reviews, if the interferences contested by an individual fall within this margin or not. This doctrine was a subject of overwhelming critique because the European Court of Human Rights did not apply it transparently and consistently. Therefore the main goal of this article is to normatively construe an algorithm which could be taken into account by the European Court of Human Rights when applying the doctrine in order to prevent the mentioned critique.</abstract>

Abstract

Keywords

<article-title>The Algorithm of the Margin of Appreciation Doctrine in Light of the Protocol No. 15 Amending the European Convention on Human Rights</article-title>

The Algorithm of the Margin of Appreciation Doctrine in Light of the Protocol No. 15 Amending the European Convention on Human Rights

International and Comparative Law Review is covered by the following services: <UL> <LI>Baidu Scholar </LI> <LI>Cabell's Journalytics </LI> <LI>CNKI Scholar (China National Knowledge Infrastructure) </LI> <LI>CNPIEC - cnpLINKer </LI> <LI>Dimensions </LI> <LI>EBSCO </LI> <LI>ExLibris </LI> <LI>Google Scholar </LI> <LI>J-Gate </LI> <LI>JournalTOCs </LI> <LI>KESLI-NDSL (Korean National Discovery for Science Leaders) </LI> <LI>MyScienceWork </LI> <LI>Naver Academic </LI> <LI>Naviga (Softweco) </LI> <LI>QOAM (Quality Open Access Market) </LI> <LI>ReadCube </LI> <LI>SCILIT </LI> <LI>SCImago (SJR) </LI> <LI>SCOPUS </LI> <LI>Semantic Scholar </LI> <LI>TDNet </LI> <LI>Ulrich's Periodicals Directory/ulrichsweb </LI> <LI>WanFang Data </LI> <LI>WorldCat (OCLC) </LI> <LI>X-MOL </LI></UL>

International and Comparative Law Review ist in den folgenden Services indiziert: <UL> <LI>Baidu Scholar </LI> <LI>Cabell's Journalytics </LI> <LI>CNKI Scholar (China National Knowledge Infrastructure) </LI> <LI>CNPIEC - cnpLINKer </LI> <LI>Dimensions </LI> <LI>EBSCO </LI> <LI>ExLibris </LI> <LI>Google Scholar </LI> <LI>J-Gate </LI> <LI>JournalTOCs </LI> <LI>KESLI-NDSL (Korean National Discovery for Science Leaders) </LI> <LI>MyScienceWork </LI> <LI>Naver Academic </LI> <LI>Naviga (Softweco) </LI> <LI>QOAM (Quality Open Access Market) </LI> <LI>ReadCube </LI> <LI>SCILIT </LI> <LI>SCImago (SJR) </LI> <LI>SCOPUS </LI> <LI>Semantic Scholar </LI> <LI>TDNet </LI> <LI>Ulrich's Periodicals Directory/ulrichsweb </LI> <LI>WanFang Data </LI> <LI>WorldCat (OCLC) </LI> <LI>X-MOL </LI></UL>

Editor-in-Chief dr. Ondrej Hamulak, Palacký University Olomouc, Czech Republic Editorial Advisory Board prof. Marie-Elisabeth Baudoin, University of Auvergne, FRANCE prof. Andrzej Bisztyga, University of Zielona Góra, POLAND prof. Michael Bogdan, Lund University, SWEDEN dr. Martin Faix, Palacký University Olomouc, CZECH REPUBLIC assoc. prof. Vlastimil Fiala, Palacký University Olomouc, CZECH REPUBLIC dr. Miluše Hrnčiříková, Palacký University Olomouc, CZECH REPUBLIC prof. Massimo Iovane, University of Naples Federico II, ITALY prof. Tanel Kerikmäe, Tallinn Law School, ESTONIA dr. Michal Malacka, Palacký University Olomouc, CZECH REPUBLIC prof. Joseph Marko, University of Graz, AUSTRIA prof. Fabrizio Marrella, Ca' Foscari University of Venice, ITALY prof. James E. Moliterno, Washington & Lee University, USA prof. Bernd Wieser, Faculty of Law, University of Graz, AUSTRIA prof. Thomas Ratka, Danube University Krems, AUSTRIA assoc. prof. Václav Stehlík, Palacký University Olomouc, CZECH REPUBLIC assoc. prof. Armin Stolz, University of Graz, AUSTRIA prof. Hennie Strydom, University of Johannesburg, REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA assoc. prof. Naděžda Šišková, Palacký University Olomouc, CZECH REPUBLIC assoc. prof. Marek Števček, Comenius University in Bratislava, SLOVAKIA prof. Erika M. Wagner, Johannes Kepler University Linz, AUSTRIA Publisher De Gruyter Poland Bogumiła Zuga 32A Str. 01-811 Warsaw, Poland T: +48 22 701 50 15 Contact: <A href="mailto:iclr@upol.cz">iclr@upol.cz</A>

<DIV align=left> International and Comparative Law Review is a peer-reviewed legal journal published by the Faculty of Law, Palacký University Olomouc (Czech Republic) in cooperation with Johannes Kepler Universität in Linz (Austria) and Karl-Franzens Universität in Graz (Austria). The articles are published mostly in English; occasionally contributions in German or French may be also accepted. The journal has been published since 2001, peer-reviewed is since 2005. It is issued twice a year. The aim of ICLR is to reflect expert research in the field of International law and EU Law as well as in legal orders both of the Czech Republic and other Member States of the European Union. Here the special emphasis is given to the legal systems of Central European Countries. The journal is comparative by its focus and with respect to this perspective it deals with all areas of law. Rejection Rate: <UL> <LI>40% </LI></UL> Why subscribe and read <UL> <LI>Significant contribution to the legal studies in the field of international law, transnational law, EU law and comparative law as well as in related fields of research </LI> <LI>Contact with the up-to-date research </LI> <LI>Contact with the group of international of scholars </LI></UL> Why submit <UL> <LI>Fair and constructive double-blind peer review </LI> <LI>Fast and efficient publication process </LI> <LI>Commitment to the quality of every article </LI> <LI>Wide dissemination of content </LI></UL> Target group <UL> <LI>researchers and experts in the field of International law and EU Law </LI></UL> Archiving Sciendo archives the contents of this journal in <A href="https://www.portico.org/">Portico</A> - digital long-term preservation service of scholarly books, journals and collections. Plagiarism Policy The editorial board is participating in a growing community of <A href="https://www.crossref.org/services/similarity-check/">Similarity Check System's</A> users in order to ensure that the content published is original and trustworthy. Similarity Check is a medium that allows for comprehensive manuscripts screening, aimed to eliminate plagiarism and provide a high standard and quality peer-review process. </DIV>

<DIV align=left> Open Access Statement The journal is an Open Access journal that allows a free unlimited access to all its contents without any restrictions upon publication to all users. </DIV>

International and Comparative Law Review

The Algorithm of the Margin of Appreciation Doctrine in Light of the Protocol No. 15 Amending the European Convention on Human Rights

Martin Kopa
Martin Kopa

Data publikacji: 24 Jan 2018

Tom & Zeszyt: Tom 14 (2014) - Zeszyt 1 (June 2014)

Zakres stron: 37 - 53

Dziennik i szczegóły wydania

International and Comparative Law Review

Podgląd PDF

Najnowsze artykuły

International and Comparative Law Review

The Algorithm of the Margin of Appreciation Doctrine in Light of the Protocol No. 15 Amending the European Convention on Human Rights

Martin KopaMartin Kopa

Data publikacji: 24 Jan 2018

Tom & Zeszyt: Tom 14 (2014) - Zeszyt 1 (June 2014)

Zakres stron: 37 - 53

Dziennik i szczegóły wydania

International and Comparative Law Review

Podgląd PDF

Najnowsze artykuły

Martin Kopa
Martin Kopa